Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes: Round 17 v Melbourne

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scorpus
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Rate tonight's selection melt


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Well Thommo proved he isn't up to it.

Thought Douglas, Mackay and Milera were largely ineffective as well. Mackay in particular was a clamger merchant and his defensive work was poor both on and off the ball

Out: Thompson, Mackay
In: Greenwood, Gallucci.
 
Well Thommo proved he isn't up to it.

Thought Douglas, Mackay and Milera were largely ineffective as well. Mackay in particular was a clamger merchant and his defensive work was poor both on and off the ball

Out: Thompson, Mackay
In: Greenwood, Gallucci.
100% agree. Kelly played well. Otten was good.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Charlie was terrible but he's not a natural footballer...he will improve so he stays.

Thompson that was embarrassing.

Kelly cannot be dropped, nor Otten though the defensive mix worries me if a dry day against a decent forward line.
 
Well Thommo proved he isn't up to it.

Thought Douglas, Mackay and Milera were largely ineffective as well. Mackay in particular was a clamger merchant and his defensive work was poor both on and off the ball

Out: Thompson, Mackay
In: Greenwood, Gallucci.

Pretty rough mentioning Mackay in the same sentence as Thommo. 72% TOG as a full time stoppage midfielder and he only just cracks double figures by picking up 2 late one's in the last couple of minutes. Deduct his 5 free kicks from his disposals and it's probably one of the worst games of football played by a full time mid in the last 20 years. Disgusting selection, disgusting performance and what's even worse is that he's a lock for next week. Now he's in, guess what? You can't drop Thommo, he's a warrior and he makes us better even when he can't run or get his hands on the ball. We got smashed in clearances which is why this liability was selected. But guaranteed, his name is penned in for at least a month whilst Greenwood gets to re-prove himself in the 2's.
 
Think you forgot your weekly Otten out Scorpus ;)

Thompson out for Greenwood would be the one change then possibly Lynch if he's fit, not sure who for though...
 
Thought kelly was outstanding tonight. This kid just keeps surprising me. That hit on the dogs player in the pocket was awesome! His 1 on 1 marking aas also a feature. Good on you jake, keep up the great work.
Thommo so slow. Greenwood needs to comeback next week.
Milera quiet but when he gets it his use by foot is precise. Rarely misses a target.
Mackay again just does enough to stay in the team. Seed would be a much better option.
 
Thommo with equal least amount of disposals. How far he's fallen.......
 
If you're meant to be a prolific ball winner (and with vast experience), 10 disposals is self explanatory - you're not even close to AFL standard anymore. You can't really even apply 'but give him some more time!' to him at his age. It's done. He's finished. Pyke and co., stop pretending otherwise. Greenwood in.

I think that's about the only change I'd make, Mackay won't get dropped with 20 disposals.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Well Thommo proved he isn't up to it.

Thought Douglas, Mackay and Milera were largely ineffective as well. Mackay in particular was a clamger merchant and his defensive work was poor both on and off the ball

Out: Thompson, Mackay
In: Greenwood, Gallucci.
Did you not watch Cameron tonight?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Greenwood is the obvious in for a retired Thommo.

Seedsman/Gallucci - whoever is in form for Cameron, who needs to get his head right. He was elsewhere tonight.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom