Preview Changes vs Nth Melbourne

Predict your Thursday night melt level


  • Total voters
    42
  • Poll closed .

Remove this Banner Ad

What on earth are we even thinking about next coach for as absolutely no way going to replace Nicks in the year they have given him 2 more years .
That's admitting they are as bad as we think they are.

If we lose to North and then get smashed in the Showdown, I would fully expect that there would be absolutely searing scrutiny on the club that will be too noisy for them to ignore.

Once you start hearing Silvers or Olsen come out and and say "He (Nicks) has the full support of the board" - thats usually the death knell and the sacking is usually imminent from there.

They will spin it like "We gave Matthew the extension to provide him with less distraction and let him focus on the playing group, unfortunately we are in a results based industry and given the level of expectation we had internally we have had to part ways with Matthew"
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Looks like Murphy will play AFL. Pedlar, berg and Dowling will be in AFL Squad

Butts named in SANFL

League

F: Tahana, T. Murray, Daniele

HF: Gallagher, Smithson, O’Leary

C: Schoenberg, J. Boyle, Bond

HB: Curtain, Burgess, Madgen

B: Ryan, Butts, Clifford



R: Strachan, Edwards, Taylor

INT: Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Whimpress, H. Boyle, Thomas

IN: Butts, Clifford, Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Thomas

OUT: Welsh (AFL Academy), Himmelberg (AFL), Pedlar (AFL), Dowling (AFL)

NEW: Jayden Davis (Prince Alfred OC), Austin McDonald (Barossa District)
 
Looks like Murphy will play AFL.

Butts named in SANFL

League

F: Tahana, T. Murray, Daniele

HF: Gallagher, Smithson, O’Leary

C: Schoenberg, J. Boyle, Bond

HB: Curtain, Burgess, Madgen

B: Ryan, Butts, Clifford



R: Strachan, Edwards, Taylor

INT: Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Whimpress, H. Boyle, Thomas

IN: Butts, Clifford, Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Thomas

OUT: Welsh (AFL Academy), Himmelberg (AFL), Pedlar (AFL), Dowling (AFL)

NEW: Jayden Davis (Prince Alfred OC), Austin McDonald (Barossa District)
Don't think Murphy is ready this week.
 
Don't think Murphy is ready this week.
From Burgo unless Murph didnt pull up after training right is ready

Small forward Lachlan Murphy, who has been sidelined for the past three matches with a knee injury, is also expected to be available for selection.

“Murph has completed everything we have asked of him over the past three weeks,” Burgess said.

“And as long as he gets through training tomorrow, we expect him to be available this weekend.”
 
Looks like Murphy will play AFL. Pedlar, berg and Dowling will be in AFL Squad

Butts named in SANFL

League

F: Tahana, T. Murray, Daniele

HF: Gallagher, Smithson, O’Leary

C: Schoenberg, J. Boyle, Bond

HB: Curtain, Burgess, Madgen

B: Ryan, Butts, Clifford



R: Strachan, Edwards, Taylor

INT: Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Whimpress, H. Boyle, Thomas

IN: Butts, Clifford, Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Thomas

OUT: Welsh (AFL Academy), Himmelberg (AFL), Pedlar (AFL), Dowling (AFL)

NEW: Jayden Davis (Prince Alfred OC), Austin McDonald (Barossa District)
You know, it’s really same s**t dished out on yet another week. Putting Murphy and Himmelberg in time and time again is appauling. And they don’t seem to surprise us these useless bunch of sh!t selectors. Thank God Dowling is in, but he should’ve been in round 7 2023. Good pedlar is back, as I’ve always backed him. Tell me what sholl, McHenry, and even Jones to a point are still in this squad. Opinions below please ⬇️
 
If I see Murphy in this side just one more time, I really think it’s time as a club we look in the mirror. Players like him, McHenry, himmelburg, have been given a hell load of chances over the years. Constantly all being chosen, while dishing useless sh!t out. I want to see Dowling, Curtain, Taylor, Pedlar all in the squad. It ain’t gonna happen, maybe Pedlar at most. Pathetic… 😡
 
Looks like Murphy will play AFL. Pedlar, berg and Dowling will be in AFL Squad

Butts named in SANFL

League

F: Tahana, T. Murray, Daniele

HF: Gallagher, Smithson, O’Leary

C: Schoenberg, J. Boyle, Bond

HB: Curtain, Burgess, Madgen

B: Ryan, Butts, Clifford



R: Strachan, Edwards, Taylor

INT: Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Whimpress, H. Boyle, Thomas

IN: Butts, Clifford, Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Thomas

OUT: Welsh (AFL Academy), Himmelberg (AFL), Pedlar (AFL), Dowling (AFL)

NEW: Jayden Davis (Prince Alfred OC), Austin McDonald (Barossa District)
Butts back might mean Curtin can play further up the ground.

On SM-S928B using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Butts back might mean Curtin can play further up the ground.
Imagine when the most exciting possibility your club can muster is that MAYBE your highly rated, highly skilled top draft pick MIGHT get to play in a position better suited to him IN THE *ing SANFL.

Enjoy the big contract at West Coast mate, they'll be in a GF before us.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

All Clubs are striving for that QB role .....ESS put Martin back, CARL opted Zilliams, RICH with Rioli, NORTH with Sheezel ....and so on

We are the worse club for having any QB at all .....Milera was that man .....no-one has replaced his role

View attachment 1970464
Hinge? Or is he different to how you’d define that role
 
Hinge? Or is he different to how you’d define that role
He certainly could do the role .....his target selection and execution by foot was terrible in the first 4 games .....he's slowly getting back to his 2023 form

We have to have a want to free him up & get the ball in his hands
 
I wonder how Worrell would go in the forward line?

He attacks the ball in the air and has good pace and agility so could be a difficult matchup and it opens a position for Curtin to play which is a better match for his skill set.
I’d be fascinated to see what Keane to do up forward as he’s one of our best contested marks. A luxury we can’t afford right now unfortunately
 
Looks like Murphy will play AFL. Pedlar, berg and Dowling will be in AFL Squad

Butts named in SANFL

League

F: Tahana, T. Murray, Daniele

HF: Gallagher, Smithson, O’Leary

C: Schoenberg, J. Boyle, Bond

HB: Curtain, Burgess, Madgen

B: Ryan, Butts, Clifford



R: Strachan, Edwards, Taylor

INT: Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Whimpress, H. Boyle, Thomas

IN: Butts, Clifford, Davis, Sigal, McDonald, Thomas

OUT: Welsh (AFL Academy), Himmelberg (AFL), Pedlar (AFL), Dowling (AFL)

NEW: Jayden Davis (Prince Alfred OC), Austin McDonald (Barossa District)
If Murphy is a walk up start returning from a decent injury it shows that our list is the worst in the league.
 
Back
Top