Elton Johns Wig
Premiership Ruckman
- Moderator
- #151
S'bottom -
--- G-------B-------K-------H-------D--------M-------T
Cotchin -
--- G-------B-------K-------H-------D--------M-------T
I like Sidebottom, I'd take him.
Regarding these stats, it just proves that numbers aren't everything. In the 3/4 years previous, people were (rightly) critical of Cotchin for out the back possessions and looking for the return handball, padded stats if you will. This year, less stats, and most would agree, far more impact.
Now, I didn't watch every Pies game, so I can't fairly comment, but saying Sidey had a better year because his numbers were better can be misleading.
Thanks mate, could argue if we had a year like Richmond then Steele would not be "under the radar" and if they had a year like us then Cotchin would be under the radar
I do struggle with Sidey under the radar. Pendles rightly gets his dues. I really like Adams, people crack at his disposal but I'd rather have him in a midfield rotation than not. Treloar gets his press. Sidebottom seems to miss out. Why is that?
I don't think the Pies list is near as bad as some people are making out. Can definitely make the 8, and anything can happen from there.
augie I don't know what's up your arse, but not every Tiges supporter has been dismissive of the Pies, same as any other club. But you keep seeing what you want to see.