Mega Thread Delist/Trade/Draft Super-mega-ultrathread

[Eastern Rangers]

very good investment advice

Assuming you can afford it.

 

[Spooky17]

I think GC & GWS will be looking for key forwards or backs more than anything as they have good mid stocks currently but are lacking reliable marking options and potency in attack.

I wonder if A.Sel has any trade currency? LOLOLOLOLOLOL!

 

[kane249]

I think GC & GWS will be looking for key forwards or backs more than anything as they have good mid stocks currently but are lacking reliable marking options and potency in attack.

GWS have Patton and Cameron, GC have Charlie Dixon and Sam Day

Their tall forward stocks are already pretty good.

 

[dajesmac]

Warming to the idea of Garlett as our first rounder.

Then ideally a Marsh or Cripps could slide.

 

[Obeanie1]

Warming to the idea of Garlett as our first rounder.

Then ideally a Marsh or Cripps could slide.

Why wouldn't Garlett slide?

 

[Groupie_]

Apparently WC is chasing Rance?

 

[kane249]

Apparently WC is chasing Rance?

Wouldn't suprise me, Glass is reaching the end of his career and he is also the son of a former captain

 

[Groupie_]

Wouldn't suprise me, Glass is reaching the end of his career and he is also the son of a former captain

I could see him leaving. With all the stalker shit here and Melbourne and all. It was mentioned on 360 yesterday

 

[kane249]

I could see him leaving. With all the stalker shit here and Melbourne and all. It was mentioned on 360 yesterday

If he's being stalked by the thing in your avatar I don't blame you

 

[9494]

I could see him leaving. With all the stalker shit here and Melbourne and all. It was mentioned on 360 yesterday

Rance for Mitch brown?

 

[Groupie_]

If he's being stalked by the thing in your avatar I don't blame you

Lewl

 

[the harry]

If MM had have just played his old man for one more game we wouldn't have to trade for Rance.

I personally would see Rance as an upgrade on Brown but I'm not sure how many on here would. They might point to the Pies match where Rance was monstered by Cloke or how his kicking isn't flash despite finding it a fair bit. But Brown had more than a couple kicked on him on Friday night, dropped simple marks, and has the lowest kicks per minutes of games of all players last year (to have played more than about 6 games).

Get Rance in and teach him to handball to Hurn/Wilson/someone else and everything would be good.

I don't think he'd leave though. Why would anyone in the Tigers best 22 leave? Finals at Tiger land, would just be amazing.

 

[Noctorniquet]

If MM had have just played his old man for one more game we wouldn't have to trade for Rance.

I personally would see Rance as an upgrade on Brown but I'm not sure how many on here would. They might point to the Pies match where Rance was monstered by Cloke or how his kicking isn't flash despite finding it a fair bit. But Brown had more than a couple kicked on him on Friday night, dropped simple marks, and has the lowest kicks per minutes of games of all players last year (to have played more than about 6 games).

Get Rance in and teach him to handball to Hurn/Wilson/someone else and everything would be good.

I don't think he'd leave though. Why would anyone in the Tigers best 22 leave? Finals at Tiger land, would just be amazing.

Think you are spot on, purely defensively speaking i think he has brown, but his disposal and decision making seem to severely lack, where Mitch Brown is ok in those areas

 

[kane249]

If MM had have just played his old man for one more game we wouldn't have to trade for Rance.

Murray Rance only played 57 games for us, one more wouldn't have made a difference?

 

[the harry]

Murray Rance only played 57 games for us, one more wouldn't have made a difference?

Oh my bad, I just remember (as in heard it somewhere) him being dropped on 99

 

[Keys]

Oh my bad, I just remember (as in heard it somewhere) him being dropped on 99

Murray rance played 97 games total. Because he played for footscray pre eagles under the hybrid father son rules we might have been able to get Alex as a father son if murray had got to 100 games I think. So maybe 3 short

 

[dajesmac]

I would only want Rance if Brown was hellbent on leaving.

 

[Keys]

I would only want Rance if Brown was hellbent on leaving.

He would be a good replacement if brown did leave

 

[the harry]

I would only want Rance if Brown was hellbent on leaving.

Obviously you can't have both. But given the choice, which would you pick for West Coast 2014 and beyond?

 

[Spooky17]

Murray rance played 97 games total. Because he played for footscray pre eagles under the hybrid father son rules we might have been able to get Alex as a father son if murray had got to 100 games I think. So maybe 3 short

Bugger

 

[kane249]

Obviously you can't have both. But given the choice, which would you pick for West Coast 2014 and beyond?

Well if we got Rance he wouldn't get homesick and leave so there is that

 

[kane249]

Murray rance played 97 games total. Because he played for footscray pre eagles under the hybrid father son rules we might have been able to get Alex as a father son if murray had got to 100 games I think. So maybe 3 short

Nah you still need someone to have played 100 games per club, not in total. So the ones that could come back and bite us in coming years are Paul Symmons (99) and Josh Wooden (96).

 

[Chris_6678]

I would take Rance over Brown..but if Glass plays on there is a chance he might be in and out of the side next year like Brown.

This is the ideal setup:

Wilson Emac Glass
Waters Schoey Hurn

With Brennan/Smith/Bennell

Rance could just slide into Glass's position.

 

[twce13]

Warming to the idea of Garlett as our first rounder.

Then ideally a Marsh or Cripps could slide.

I dunno, I'm not sure I agree with everyone that "Garlett is exactly what we need", no doubt we need a player like him but he wouldn't solve all our problems. I'm wondering if he could slide to our 2nd pick and we then can pick up a big bodied midfielder with our first pick, someone like Botempelli could be available at our first pick and he has a lot of upside.

 

[Jimmy_the_Gent]

So, we chased Harry Taylor, there was an article in the West about us getting Michael Johnson and now we're allegedly interested in Rance.

I predict Glass has signalled his intention to retire while Brown will probably leave.

I would happily do Brown for Rance but Richmond would want a fair bit more.