Mega Thread Delist/Trade/Draft Super-mega-ultrathread

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Aish, Boyd, Scharenberg seem to be the popular top three.



So you see Adelaide and Gold Coast finishing above us. Fair chance of that happening if we lose next week.

Whats your opinion of Tom Hodgson as a small defender?

Yea like what i have seen so far on Hodgson although very happy with how Bennell is progressing.
Like you not a fan of Clem Smith at all kicking is shocking.
Acres popped his shoulder again so will be out for a while may need a reco, I really want him EH.

 

[dajesmac]

Yea like what i have seen so far on Hodgson although very happy with how Bennell is progressing.
Like you not a fan of Clem Smith at all kicking is shocking.
Acres popped his shoulder again so will be out for a while may need a reco, I really want him EH.

I don't know much about Acres. Inside/outside?

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

I don't know much about Acres. Inside/outside?

Acres is both inside/outside more outside at the moment because of his shoulder problems 188cm lovely kick 16 beep 2.90 for 20m

 

[the harry]

Yea like what i have seen so far on Hodgson although very happy with how Bennell is progressing.
Like you not a fan of Clem Smith at all kicking is shocking.
Acres popped his shoulder again so will be out for a while may need a reco, I really want him EH.

Gun mid with a dodgy shoulder? This seem familiar and I like where it is going.

 

[PAdman]

Do we make a play for Yarran? It's clear Malthouse doesn't want him.

 

[othmana]

I'd do a trade for a 2nd round draft pick for yarren

 

[dajesmac]

Acres is both inside/outside more outside at the moment because of his shoulder problems 188cm lovely kick 16 beep 2.90 for 20m

How would you rank Sheed, Garlett and Acres in terms of your preferences? Knowing we may end up with 2 of them at best.

 

[whatis]

Do we make a play for Yarran? It's clear Malthouse doesn't want him.

I'm with Malthouse.

 

[bluengold89]

I'd do a trade for a 2nd round draft pick for yarren

You and 16 other teams.

 

[Falco]

Youre doing alright when you put a bloke like Yarran on the pine for three quarters.

 

[GrandBlue]

Sheed won't slide. A broken collarbone will affect his placing about as much as Plowman's bad elbow affected his. He's clearly too talented to be selected outside the top 5.

Dayle Garlett still my tip for your first pick.

 

[dajesmac]

Sheed won't slide. A broken collarbone will affect his placing about as much as Plowman's bad elbow affected his. He's clearly too talented to be selected outside the top 5.

Dayle Garlett still my tip for your first pick.

First time I've heard him described as top 5.

Who knows, we could still end up with a good enough pick yet.

 

[groga]

Acres popped his shoulder again so will be out for a while may need a reco, I really want him EH.

One of my favourites! I would love Sheed first round, Acres 2nd and garlett 3rd rounder.

 

[the harry]

Anyone ever consider there are guys outside of WA?

Having said that, WA has produced a lot of talent recently.

 

[groga]

Anyone ever consider there are guys outside of WA?

Having said that, WA has produced a lot of talent recently.

Of course, but living in Perth naturally my and many others exposure is w.a based. I can only judge on what I have seen.

 

[the harry]

Of course, but living in Perth naturally my and many others exposure is w.a based. I can only judge on what I have seen.

Sorry, it wasn targeted at anyone specifically, just a general comment of the path the thread has taken lately. But fair point.

 

[tesseract]

So you see Adelaide finishing above us. Fair chance of that happening if we lose next week.

Where Adelaide finish is of no/little consequence to any club, for they're out of the first two rounds of the draft, this year and next.

 

[Masto]

Sheed is a safe pick but there are other WA players such as Acres, Marsh and Robertson who are bigger, more athletic and may have more upside. Its not the end of the world if we miss out on him.

 

[Bacchus]

Sheed looks a good prospect, just what we need, will probably miss out because we won't have a low enough pick, GWS or some other hack ES outfit will snaffle him just like all the other brilliant WA juniors of recent years except Darling.

 

[groga]

Sorry, it wasn targeted at anyone specifically, just a general comment of the path the thread has taken lately. But fair point.

Agree with your point as well mate.

Also massive fan of its always sunny in Philadelphia.

 

[QS]

Draft better.

 

[eagles rule]

Do we make a play for Yarran? It's clear Malthouse doesn't want him.

Brown for Yarren , pretty sure Brown is leaving at end of year ..

 

[InTheWings]

Before he was drafted, was it Yarren that stated he'd rather stay in WA because his father was in gaol? Not sure if this is still applicable but if it is, would be a huge draw for him to come home.

 

[eagles rule]

Before he was drafted, was it Yarren that stated he'd rather stay in WA because his father was in gaol? Not sure if this is still applicable but if it is, would be a huge draw for him to come home.

not sure but damn Yarren lit up patterson`s last time he played us and once you upset mick well who knows now,,

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

How would you rank Sheed, Garlett and Acres in terms of your preferences? Knowing we may end up with 2 of them at best.

Garlett is a better talent than Sheed, weather you would use a first round pick is debatable at this stage.
I rather have Acres on our list than Sheed at this stage.
Sheed is one paced but is a good kick and kicks goals as a mid, he also has great smarts.
Sheed will be very good but is similar, to what we have, and we need pace.