- Oct 14, 2011
- 9,668
- 13,505
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
They have no need for Patton, Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg are all the tall options they need.How? Patton is on alot of money, if Cogs don't re-sign they won't be trading Patton
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 10
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
They have no need for Patton, Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg are all the tall options they need.How? Patton is on alot of money, if Cogs don't re-sign they won't be trading Patton
They have no need for Patton, Cameron, Finlayson and Himmelberg are all the tall options they need.
How you don't win a flag with Kelly, Coniglio, Shiel, Whitfield, Taranto, Hopper, Ward and Scully in the midfield is beyond me.Tomlinson too. Let's be honest, it's the best list in the league by a country mile.
They could delist Cogs and it not even touch the sides.
The kid is a jet, make no mistake. Both he and Brayshaw down on last years performances. Cera playing a negative role at half back. He will be an A grade mid in the next few years.Cerra looks bog average to me.
I hear you. But he was poo against the Dons. Looks disinterested. Brayshaw looked like a rookie.The kid is a jet, make no mistake. Both he and Brayshaw down on last years performances. Cera playing a negative role at half back. He will be an A grade mid in the next few years.
They probs play too much Xbox...I hear you. But he was poo against the Dons. Looks disinterested. Brayshaw looked like a rookie.
We must all remember that Scrimshaw was so disinterested that he could barely get a game ala what Brodie is going through now. Put them in an environment where their settled and happy and then add a dash of Clarko and anything is possible.I hear you. But he was poo against the Dons. Looks disinterested. Brayshaw looked like a rookie.
How you don't win a flag with Kelly, Coniglio, Shiel, Whitfield,
Taranto, Hopper, Ward and Scully in the midfield is beyond me.
It's the coach thats the problem, not the talent on the park.It's not Supercoach. That's why.
20 blokes doing it the way they always have - as Numero Uno.
Easily one of the worst collection of players - they are no more a "team" than Carlton.
They needed 4-5 "blue collar" blokes in there early and a coach willing to pick based on tackles/smothers/shepherds, rather than just looking at the stat sheet.
Playing 4 inside midfielders who all were top draft picks for being the best primary target ball winner in their age-group has just created an unbalanced (albeit supremely talented) list.
How you don't win a flag with Kelly, Coniglio, Shiel, Whitfield, Taranto, Hopper, Ward and Scully in the midfield is beyond me.
Individually, they may not have peaked, but more than enough of them were more than good enough to have won multiple flags by now. That's the point.Because Ward and Scully aside, the rest weren't at their peak yet.
Immaturity and injuries cost the Giants before. The kids have grown up and notwithstanding our win against them, their time is now. It's why it will be tough for Cogs to leave IMO.
Individually, they may not have peaked, but more than enough of them were more than good enough to have won multiple flags by now. That's the point.
Plenty of our 2008 side hadn't peaked & we didn't have half their talent. And, we beat a genuinely good opponent, not the also-rans clogging up the top of the leader board the last couple of years.
How you don't win a flag with Kelly, Coniglio, Shiel, Whitfield, Taranto, Hopper, Ward and Scully in the midfield is beyond me.
I hear you. But he was poo against the Dons. Looks disinterested. Brayshaw looked like a rookie.
'COS ROSS LYON IS BORING EVERYONE TO DEATH OVER THERE
The Bus Driver coach.
He's playing with no flair or desperation in his game. Just going through the motions. Looked VFL standard v the Dons.Disinterested for what reason ?????
Way to drive the kids valueHe's playing with no flair or desperation in his game. Just going through the motions. Looked VFL standard v the Dons.
He's playing with no flair or desperation in his game. Just going through the motions. Looked VFL standard v the Dons.
Still looking at Weitering?Again. Mmmmmmmm..... !!!
Will Brodie, Cerra ....... who else ????
Still looking at Weitering?
Is he CHF or CHB?Still looking at Weitering?
Because Patton leaving opens up money to keep CogsWhy would Cogs leaving/staying have any bearing at all as to whether Patton is leaving/staying?