Remove this Banner Ad

Justin Longmuir V Troy Simmonds

Who would you rather have in your team?


  • Total voters
    48

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Cassius_Clay

Cancelled
NFL Mock Draft Participant NFL Fantasy Comp Champion Armchair Endzone Major Comp Champion Armchair Endzone Participant
Joined
Jul 6, 2004
Posts
4,921
Reaction score
1,136
AFL Club
Collingwood
Longmuir 25, Simmonds 27.

Who would you rather have in your team. Both the same type of players, both ruck and both play up forward.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Freo Big Fella said:
JLo is twice the player Rubbertits is. Better ruckwork, better marking, a more accurate kick and can play all over the ground.
I wouldn't say he has better ruckwork. A more complete player than Simmonds. More versatile and better up forward and around the ground, meaning I concur with you.
 
Versatility = Longmuir
Ruck work = about equal
Aggressiveness = Simmonds
Forward = Longmuir
Marking = Longmuir
Set shot on goal = Longmuir

Longmuir struggles against the aggressive ruck type. Thats where Sandilands excels though, so we have a very good pair.

Watch out for Sandilands this year. He will be very dominant, with an excellent backup in Longmuir.
 
Interesting to compare them, given where they came from. JLo, a #2 pick, Troy in the PSD. JLo also touted as the next big thing, firstly as a CHF/FF, now as a ruck/CHF; Troy always a borderline player at Melb as a tall defender, backup ruck. Freo gave Troy a huge boost by making him our #1 ruckman, but it probably held JLo back a bit - he wasn't ready to be a #1 CHF/FF, should have been a backup ruck/bit forward instead.

No real surprise to see the vote so heavily weighted towards JLo.

Very happy to not have Simmonds on our books for 4 more years.
 
They are both pretty average, but if I had to pick one i'd take Longmuir.
 
Jarryd_S said:
Neither?

We'd probably take Longmuir though, with our lack of experience ruckmen.

Any club in the AFL would love to poourtunity to pick J'Lo up. If you dont agree your obviously a poor judge of tlent, have no idea in general or have never seen him play.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Brittany said:
They are both pretty average, but if I had to pick one i'd take Longmuir.
Both would make your side very easily.

J-Lo would make any team in the comp.
 
Considering Justin Longmuir is one of my favourite players of all time, simle answer really.

When i saw this as last post said Poll: Justin Longmuir v Troy..., I at first thought the other was Troy Longmuir :p
 
Lonie_from_50 said:
Considering Justin Longmuir is one of my favourite players of all time, simle answer really.

When i saw this as last post said Poll: Justin Longmuir v Troy..., I at first thought the other was Troy Longmuir :p
Haha so did I, until i voted and realised :)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom