Remove this Banner Ad

Kane Johnson to be named skipper....

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yze_Magic said:
Jeffrey Hogg, Wayne Campbell, Matthew Knights.,,

now Kane Johson?

I have never seen a worse list of captains for a professional footy club
It highlights that Richmond have not had a lot of stars with leadership material. Richo is a star but has shown himself to be a bit fragile mentally at times. Respect for the likes of Knights who was a Tigers champion but he was always a very good honest player rather than out and out star IMO. There just seems to be an evenness about the Tigers and they really need the likes of Coughlan to jump up and star from the front. Richmond's 2001 side finished top 4 but they were very even across the board.

Carlton have had some down times too but our captains in reverse chronological order have been:

Koutoufides
McKay* (Ratten injured)
Ratten
Bradley
Kernahan
Maclure
Johnston
Fitzpatrick
Jesaulenko

With the exception of Maclure, all were considered stars.

Look at the other teams

Buckley - star
Hird - star
King - star
Crawford - star
Grant - star
Neitz - star
Cousins - star
Ricciuto - star
Voss - star
Bell - star
Primus - star

The only exceptions to this are St Kilda because of their rotation policy though some of their choices are stars anyway and I consider Maxfield and Simpson to be in the Johnson mould, prolific tough midfielders who lead by example rather than full blown AFL stars at the moment. Just my opinion.

The Swans had Kelly previously though who was a tough midfielder who ended up being a star through sheer weight of deeds and the Roos had Carey who speaks for himself.

The Tigers should appoint Coughlan as Carlton did to a young Kernahan back in 1987. Stars rise to the challenge and inspire those around them by their example. Failing that Nathan Brown is their biggest star who would lead well onfield but would need to develop his off field role.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Yze_Magic said:
lol


Jeffrey Hogg, Wayne Campbell, Matthew Knights.,,

now Kane Johson?

I have never seen a worse list of captains for a professional footy club



Ummmm remember .........Greg Wells, Greg Healy, Todd Viney??????
But then again you wouldn't really call melb. a professional club would you? :rolleyes:
 
spot said:
Ummmm remember .........Greg Wells, Greg Healy, Todd Viney??????
But then again you wouldn't really call melb. a professional club would you? :rolleyes:


Todd Viney a bad captain?

havent watched much footy have you?
 
Richo would be the worst possible choice as captain, his behaviour on field is a disgrace sometimes

No surprises if Kane got it, Coughlan needs to get back into form after an injury interrupted year this year, Brown has only been here a year and not really captaincy material

For what its worth I would have thought everyones ex fave whiiping boy Joel Bowden would have been a slight chance. Sure he has had one good year out of many frustrating ones but he kept trying last year, has been around the place long enough also
 

Remove this Banner Ad

ExTasDeeMan said:
the thing is that Brown deserted the Doggies - would you give a captaincy to someone who would jump if it all went pearshaped?
Brown left the doggies for more MONEY and to be reunited with his girlfriend Wallet. And beetween the 2 of them they will suck the club dry. :)

Richmond are actually worse at Richmond now then they were at the Bulldogs.

The Bulldogs at least had and still have a stable admin.

Tigers are the real deal. A genuine AFL team of RABBLE.

STUGUTZ
 
stugutz said:
Brown left the doggies for more MONEY and to be reunited with his girlfriend Wallet. And beetween the 2 of them they will suck the club dry. :)

Richmond are actually worse at Richmond now then they were at the Bulldogs.

The Bulldogs at least had and still have a stable admin.

Tigers are the real deal. A genuine AFL team of RABBLE.

STUGUTZ
tell me that 4 months when our membership will be a record high and the bulldogs will be doing their usual tin rattling! :D
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Kane Johnson to be named skipper....

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top