Kouta Vs Tyson Edwards

[knackers27]

My mate Gets think that everyone on here would take edwards of Kouta whether it would be in their prime or for their whole career. I have to disagree because Edwards could never just take a game by the scruff of the neck and win it, Kouta is one of a kind and could never be replaced.

Its Kouta Easily for me what a champ.

What do you think

 

[94_Eagles]

Why don't you just do Kouta v Jobe Watson.

 

[Gets!]

Edwards for me

 

[writeoff]

I agree that Kouta could change the result of a game more dramatically than Edwards but if you measure their onfield contribution to their clubs over their careers Edwards would come out on top - easily.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Kouta has had 2 very good seasons (Champion seasons at that). Edwards at least 5.

Edwards for me

 

[Mr Magoo]

Edwards is very under rated & simply far more consistent than Kouta. So it's Edwards for me.

 

[earlsta]

Edwards by a country mile, you ask any coach who they'd take out of the two and it would be Edwards.
Kouta's a good player, but Edwards is more valuable.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Edwards

I rate Koutofides the most overrated played of the last 12 years, while Edwards is the most underrated


Give me skill ,consistency and professionalism over some Greek guy that can pick the ball up with one hand

 

[Carltonbluez]

In their prime - Kouta without a doubt

Over career - Edwards

 

[Southerntakeover]

In the current? Edwards.

At peak, Kouta might be better, but he saw his peak for too little of his career.

 

[goal sneak]

Kouta by the length of the equator.

 

[DG-Man]

Kouta by a fair bit. Carlton fans can help me here, but i doubt he has had only 2 good seasons like Clay said. In 95 he was awesome, especially in the GF against Geelong. So what were 96-98 like?? We all know in 99 and 2000 he was the complete package. Assuming he was ok during some of the last 6 years when he wasn't injured?

Anyone hav e any stats. B&F results. Didn't he win one recently?

Wheres parrot when you need him?

 

[Gets!]

Anyone hav e any stats. B&F results. Didn't he win one recently?

Wheres parrot when you need him?

It's a bit easier to win a B&F at Carlton than at the AFC mate

 

[Art Vandelay]

Edwards. Gives a 110% week in week out.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Edwards. Gives a 110% week in week out.

Your username is easily the best on BigFooty

 

[Silvagnis]

What has Edwards done as an player that puts him above Koutoufides?

Zero AA guernseys and best and fairests.

A joke of a thread and the clock is ticking for the Crows.

If you had put Van Berlo up against Koutaman in the poll then it would be a good thread.

 

[Silvagnis]

It's a bit easier to win a B&F at Carlton than at the AFC mate

Just like it's easier for Licuria to be judged the B & F ahead of Buckley?

 

[Gets!]

Tyson Edwards came 3rd in the brownlow last year.

Fair to say he has matured far batter then Koutafififididies.

Quite embarassing for Kouta actually.

 

[ICanDressMyself]

Kouta in his prime was great, but his prime didn't last for long.

Edwards by a long way.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Just like it's easier for Licuria to be judged the B & F ahead of Buckley?

Leave Lica alone, all of you.

 

[ICanDressMyself]

Leave Lica alone, all of you.

He waxes.

Pansy.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

He waxes.

Pansy.

 

[parrot]

My mate Gets think that everyone on here would take edwards of Kouta whether it would be in their prime or for their whole career. I have to disagree because Edwards could never just take a game by the scruff of the neck and win it, Kouta is one of a kind and could never be replaced.

Its Kouta Easily for me what a champ.

What do you think

No disrespect, but this is a silly poll, because Kouta at his peak was the best midfielder our game has ever seen- easily. Was impressed with his efforts V Pies. The weight of the anti-Carlton media, has clearly affected him, and getting the contract issues sorted early has been a great relief for him. On Sunday he lined up in the middle against several Pies small, slow, low-talent midfielders and totally dominated. Admittedly the Pies midfield is pretty ordinary, but it was nice to see some of Kouta’s trademark powerhouse clearances. I’m delighted he’ll play on next year. His experience will be invaluable to the top-shelf midfield talent we’re accumulating ie Marc Murphy, Andrew Walker, Bryce Gibbs, Simpson, Blackwell, Russell, Jackson etc etc. Don’t really rate the crows guy you mentioned. Probably a good contributor for the Crows.

 

[ICanDressMyself]

No disrespect, but this is a silly poll, because Kouta at his peak was the best midfielder our game has ever seen- easily. Was impressed with his efforts V Pies. The weight of the anti-Carlton media, has clearly affected him, and getting the contract issues sorted early has been a great relief for him. On Sunday he lined up in the middle against several Pies small, slow, low-talent midfielders and totally dominated. Admittedly the Pies midfield is pretty ordinary, but it was nice to see some of Kouta’s trademark powerhouse clearances. I’m delighted he’ll play on next year. His experience will be invaluable to the top-shelf midfield talent we’re accumulating ie Marc Murphy, Andrew Walker, Bryce Gibbs, Simpson, Blackwell, Russell, Jackson etc etc. Don’t really rate the crows guy you mentioned. Probably a good contributor for the Crows.

Doesn't surprise me. You're in your own little world over there in Vic aren't you.

 

[Jimthegreat]

If your talking about careers surely, even with my Carlton bias, that would be Kouta.......easily! Even more so when talking about being in their prime. Unless you follow the Crows, which is fair enough, there's no other way you can vote, surely.