Liam Jones vs Rhys Stanley

[Adam H]

Footscray VFL > St Kilda AFL

Yep now he has just netted us pick 21 from the best recruiting guy in the AFL Wells. In the mean time pick 80 odd will see Jones at the Blues.

Wells>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>MOC

 

[Heisenberg_]

Stanley is the lesser of 2 duds

 

[Ant_]

Pick 21 is the greatest thing either player has done in their careers.

 

[Adam H]

Stanley is the lesser of 2 duds

Vickery not even worthy of this poll?

 

[Adam H]

Pick 21 is the greatest thing either player has done in their careers.

Pick 46 is bordering on DESPERATION by Carlton way over s for Jones.

 

[Ant_]

Pick 46 is bordering on DESPERATION by Carlton way over s for Jones.

If pick 21 got a dud like Stanley over the line anything is possible. Here's hoping we get your good luck

Edit : I guess we didn't

You win the trade round Stanley.

 

[Falchoon]

so the Saints 'win', pick #21 vs #46

over to you Cats and Blouse

 

[Ant_]

so the Saints 'win', pick #21 vs #46

over to you Cats and Blouse

Still shocked you got 21

 

[Falchoon]

Still shocked you got 21

I'm disappointed

 

[Adam H]

Still shocked you got 21

Guess you know more than Stephan Wells.

 

[Tank Girl]

Jones won easily.

Pick 60 or whatever we gave up for him vs pick 21

 

[HARKER]

Stanley = #21
Jones = #46

Clearly Stanley is at least twice as good. .................... staggering.

 

[Adam H]

Stanley = #21
Jones = #46

Clearly Stanley is at least twice as good. .................... staggering.

Pretty much yes.

 

[Sidebottom2Beams]

Stanley = #21
Jones = #46

Clearly Stanley is at least twice as good. .................... staggering.

He sure is.

 

[Adam H]

He sure is.

18yo makes a mistake lets hang him. Stanley>>>>>>>Witts >>>>>White

 

[HARKER]

Pretty much yes.

Stanley had Riewoldt taking all the heat in the Saints forward 50.

Jones was supposed to be Riewoldt in the Dogs forward 50. Big difference.

 

[Adam H]

Stanley had Riewoldt taking all the heat in the Saints forward 50.

Jones was supposed to be Riewoldt in the Dogs forward 50. Big difference.

Jones is rubbish.+

 

[TN25]

How can you still argue that Jones is better. Last time I checked 21>46

 

[Adam H]

How can you still argue that Jones is better. Last time I checked 21>46

Throw in who gave up 21 for Stanley and its game set match.

 

[ManOfClay]

Except that both are still playing so of corse the bebate is still open

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

Why exactly are Dogs and St Kilda fans still arguing over players that don't even play for either team anymore?

 

[ManOfClay]

Why exactly are Dogs and St Kilda fans still arguing over players that don't even play for either team anymore?

Because those players still exist?

 

[Adam H]

Why exactly are Dogs and St Kilda fans still arguing over players that don't even play for either team anymore?

I know seeing as though Stephen Wells made those that voted Jones look silly.

 

[Shaneprice97]

18yo makes a mistake lets hang him. Stanley>>>>>>>Witts >>>>>White

Witts is a ruckman, i dont see where he comes into this.

 

[Zgope1]

reflects poorly on us dogs and saints fans that geelong and carlton fans clearly don't even care about these two players haha.

Who's having the better year?