List management

[Toots Hibbert]

TBH I wouldn't be fussed if a new coach came in and just went nuts with delistings. Thompson, Harding and Dawson all MUST go, and I wouldn't be disappointed to see any or all of Cloke, Webb, Johns, Meyer, Nash, Davenport and M. Westhoff (contract or no contract, he can't be on that much coin) out the door.

With Webb you could be throwing out the baby with the bathwater. We need another year to see how he goes instead of dumping him now. Has shown some good signs.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

dont care who stays goes

as long as we get 4 magic beans for pearce and rodan

my 2 favourite players but they offer us nothing

nothing at all

meyer has more upside. nash and harding produce more

Still rubishing our players Bodyman? I notice you arent still calling for Westhoff and D Stewart to get the chop?

 

[Toots Hibbert]

dont care who stays goes

as long as we get 4 magic beans for pearce and rodan

my 2 favourite players but they offer us nothing

nothing at all

meyer has more upside. nash and harding produce more

What are you smoking?

 

[Schulzenfest]

With Webb you could be throwing out the baby with the bathwater. We need another year to see how he goes instead of dumping him now. Has shown some good signs.

To be honest I haven't actually seen him play. I just see a 21 year old playing SANFL reserves and think we could probably do better.

 

[240volt]

I know Pearce has his moments but he would have to be about Fav to win our B&F this year, i think if he was playing in a better team he would be a much better player if that makes sense

 

[Schulzenfest]

IMO Boak might've overtaken him in the latter half of the year. Pearce will be well ahead at the halfway mark though IMO.

 

[Jimbo7]

To be honest I haven't actually seen him play. I just see a 21 year old playing SANFL reserves and think we could probably do better.

Webby is a 20yr old key position player. 196cm and 90kg kid that is still learning the game. Can play FF,CHF,Ruck and CHB. Hopefully if given a chance could develop into a Daniel Stewart type. Has a great leap and when he is on he is hard to stop and exciting to watch. Maybe you could see him play before you cut him. Has played 27 games of league in total with ten this year. Probably the type you want on the rookie list.

 

[Phhht]

To be honest I haven't actually seen him play. I just see a 21 year old playing SANFL reserves and think we could probably do better.

do yourself a favour and have a look at him. He has a good pair of hands and one of he most effortless leaps you will see. Think he is around the 195cm mark but his leap sees him compete in the ruck regularly. Unfortunately westies have needed rucks this year and he has drawn the short straw. Would love for him to be plonked at CHF and left there for a fair chunk of a season to let him grow into the position. If he could get more intensity ito his game he has REAL potential. Big guys do take time to mature but you are right, he should have established himself in the SANFL this year.

 

[tribey]

I know Pearce has his moments but he would have to be about Fav to win our B&F this year, i think if he was playing in a better team he would be a much better player if that makes sense

Don't count out Cassisi.

21.7 inside disposals and 8 tackles a game will see him struggle to get too many Brownlow Votes, but is the sort of stuff that will always register votes with a friendly coaches box.

A pair of magnificent Showdown performances too.

 

[brogan2motlop]

Re: Butcher

The grounds are his entire career to date.

Thomas will still be there barring injury I remember you saying the same stuff about westhoff too

 

[Schulzenfest]

Re: Butcher

Thomas will still be there barring injury I remember you saying the same stuff about westhoff too

Westhoff's had a good month or so. Not the first time he's done that, is it? The challenge is keeping it up. I hope he does, because it makes us a better side.

 

[brogan2motlop]

Re: Butcher

Westhoff's had a good month or so. Not the first time he's done that, is it? The challenge is keeping it up. I hope he does, because it makes us a better side.

I didn't even begin to mention the stuff you said about Sargent


All good though I think I got it wrong with boak I just hope he can clean his disposal by about 10%