McLean VS Mitchell (neutral supporters only)

[rick James]

This is a public poll to see who non demons/hawks fans reckon is better - Mitchell or McLean.

I will deduct votes from Hawthorn or Melbourne fans anyway, so please dont' vote if you go for Melbourne or Hawthorn.

 

[CrazyQ]

Mitchell now, McLean very soon.

How many standout years has McLean had?

But in saying that, I'd rather McLean.

 

[rick James]

lol all of mitchell's votes so far have been from hawks supporters

 

[Sylvia Saint]

lol all of mitchell's votes so far have been from hawks supporters

So much for neutral supporters only.

 

[gandaal]

Offical list of illiterates:

BudddddyLove
GAMBLER
Hawker_Boy
Hawkk

 

[rick James]

Offical list of illiterates:

BudddddyLove
GAMBLER
Hawker_Boy
Hawkk

i just can't believe they thought nobody would notice...

 

[Hawkk]

i just can't believe they thought nobody would notice...

Just here to serve Rick

 

[Moss Rocket]

Problem is you start a poll, but you put people off McLean because of your 3 options for him and one for Mitchell. This causes people to think your a tosser. I voted for Mitchell only because it will be fun to see girls like Franklin2Hodge hassle you with their victory.

BTW Brock is better

 

[gandaal]

Offical list of illiterates:

BudddddyLove
GAMBLER
Hawker_Boy
Hawkk

First Melbourne member:
unstable punt

 

[rick James]

lol 8 of the twelve Mithcell votes are hawthorn supporters...

 

[H2F]

lol 8 of the twelve Mithcell votes are hawthorn supporters...

Keep trying RJ you lost the other poll hands down so you try again ... No one has bothered to vote so it's simply irrelevent, even though again it's very close.

Fact is it's been about half, half, which is probably about right considering we both believe we're right and probably both are.

Good punch on though, I'll think of something else we can go each other at

 

[rick James]

Good to see the people speaking so clearly opn this issue and giving Brock a resounding victory

 

[Heisenberg_]

Keep trying RJ you lost the other poll hands down so you try again ... No one has bothered to vote so it's simply irrelevent, even though again it's very close.

Fact is it's been about half, half, which is probably about right considering we both believe we're right and probably both are.

Good punch on though, I'll think of something else we can go each other at

Your wrong, McLean is better, nothing in it ATM, but McLean has a lot more potential then Mitchell

 

[The Zebra]

I would take McLean over Mitchell in a heartbeat.

 

[Richo83]

In a few years when McLean is mid 20s and reaching his potential to be a great midfielder, McLean will be better than Mitchell is. Remember, Mitchell is over three years older than McLean, bit of an unfair comparison.

 

[DannyJ]

In a few years when McLean is mid 20s and reaching his potential to be a great midfielder, McLean will be better than Mitchell is. Remember, Mitchell is over three years older than McLean, bit of an unfair comparison.

Stupid comparison.

Mitchell is better now, and had a better career.

McLean potentially could be better and have a better career.

 

[CrazyQ]

I would take McLean over Mitchell in a heartbeat.

McLean already better than Mitchell? I doubt that alot.

 

[The Zebra]

McLean already better than Mitchell? I doubt that alot.

Mitchell is overrated. Gets plenty of the ball but isn't damaging enough. handballs too often, kicks often lack penetration and he has no idea how to kick a goal.

Brock averages a few possessions less but does more, plays the game very aggressively, hits players hard and is damaging with his possession. Was also massively impressive in the first final - the way he picked his team up and dragged them across the line. All at 20. He'll get his possession count up and establish a fair gap, but even if we were picking teams for tomorrow - I'd take Brock.

 

[RoyalBlue]

Mitchell is overrated. Gets plenty of the ball but isn't damaging enough. handballs too often, kicks often lack penetration and he has no idea how to kick a goal.

Brock averages a few possessions less but does more, plays the game very aggressively, hits players hard and is damaging with his possession. Was also massively impressive in the first final - the way he picked his team up and dragged them across the line. All at 20. He'll get his possession count up and establish a fair gap, but even if we were picking teams for tomorrow - I'd take Brock.

I agree. I'd take McLean.

 

[CrazyQ]

Well, I guess I disagree.

I think Mitchell has earnt the title of being better than Brock quite easily. Excellent clearance player and by foot is very underrated, usually never misses a target even though it travels 20-45 metres. He makes up not kicking enough goals by creating them through sheer brillance ie: very good vision and clearance work.

McLean is a freak, has everything and some, however I want him to back it up before I claim him to be a top class player. I believe he will get there and will surpass Mitchell.

For me, if it were 'Which player would you want at your club?" easy choice, McLean. However if it were "Who, at the moment, is the better player" has to be Sammy M.

 

[DannyJ]

Well, I guess I disagree.

I think Mitchell has earnt the title of being better than Brock quite easily. Excellent clearance player and by foot is very underrated, usually never misses a target even though it travels 20-45 metres. He makes up not kicking enough goals by creating them through sheer brillance ie: very good vision and clearance work.

McLean is a freak, has everything and some, however I want him to back it up before I claim him to be a top class player. I believe he will get there and will surpass Mitchell.

For me, if it were 'Which player would you want at your club?" easy choice, McLean. However if it were "Who, at the moment, is the better player" has to be Sammy M.

Spot ON !

 

[Fastback]

Mitchell is overrated. Gets plenty of the ball but isn't damaging enough. handballs too often, kicks often lack penetration and he has no idea how to kick a goal.

Brock averages a few possessions less but does more, plays the game very aggressively, hits players hard and is damaging with his possession. Was also massively impressive in the first final - the way he picked his team up and dragged them across the line. All at 20. He'll get his possession count up and establish a fair gap, but even if we were picking teams for tomorrow - I'd take Brock.

its pretty hard to overrate someone who ranks 2nd in clearances, wins 2006 club B&F, averages 27 disposals whilst copping illegal hits and tags all season - the bloke has got 110% out of himself and continues to improve.

You want overrated, how about no.8 for your mob.

 

[H2F]

Well, I guess I disagree.

I think Mitchell has earnt the title of being better than Brock quite easily. Excellent clearance player and by foot is very underrated, usually never misses a target even though it travels 20-45 metres. He makes up not kicking enough goals by creating them through sheer brillance ie: very good vision and clearance work.

McLean is a freak, has everything and some, however I want him to back it up before I claim him to be a top class player. I believe he will get there and will surpass Mitchell.

For me, if it were 'Which player would you want at your club?" easy choice, McLean. However if it were "Who, at the moment, is the better player" has to be Sammy M.

Doubly spot on.

As I have said a number of times I have a feeling there is a large number of BigFooty regulars who watch a lot less football than they make out. so in turn they follow the popular view and it is annoying.

You can quickly see people who do watch a lot of footy such as CrazyQ and Danny J. Actually also have a lot of respect for the Zebras views normally but I suspect his view is tainted against Mitchell because of bitterness over recent Hawthorn/North trading.

 

[CrazyQ]

its pretty hard to overrate someone who ranks 2nd in clearances, wins 2006 club B&F, averages 27 disposals whilst copping illegal hits and tags all season - the bloke has got 110% out of himself and continues to improve.

You want overrated, how about no.8 for your mob.

Going overboard now.

If anything, Wells is underrated.

People now reckon Walker has surpassed him, ridiculous.

 

[H2F]

Going overboard now.

If anything, Wells is underrated.

People now reckon Walker has surpassed him, ridiculous.

Wells in under-rated he is another enigma like Mitchell who cops it as unfairly as Brock McLean is hyped up unfairly.

It's so funny how certain players are continually put down, i.e Wells, Tambling, Walker, Cooney and others seriously over-rated such as the Grandmaster McLean !!!