melb vs north vs richmond which has a better midfield

[The Mighty Boosh]

well trengove has 3 years to win a Bnf, come runner up in another and make the AA squad of 40.

like i said untill then swallow>trengove

oh and btw swallow more hurt factor. Kicks more goals also

Sure, whatever. He's played one year - Swallow 5 and he's nearly caught him up already.

North BnF's are North BnF's. It doesn't come into consideration. So he has 3 or 4 years to make the extended AA squad of 40? Consider it done.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Sure, whatever. He's played one year - Swallow 5 and he's nearly caught him up already.

Norf BnF's are Norf BnF's. It doesn't come into consideration. So he has 3 or 4 years to make the extended AA squad of 40? Consider it done.

BnFs do count

good luck to trengove getting 2 top 2 finishes in the next 3 years

 

[DarwinRoo]

Brogan is a good solid ruckman while lobbe is relatively untried.Dont rate mcintosh or goldstein really.Both are average at best.
Cox and nic nat.
Mumford and seaby.
jacobs and maric.
kreuzer and warnock.
jolly and brown.
hudson and roughead.
all these combinations of player i rate higher than mcintosh and goldstein.
Maybe you should watch more football.North really arent that good

If anyone needs to watch footy it's you. The only two ruckman on that list that have had a better career than Mcintosh are Cox and Jolly. Goldstein is so far in front of blokes like Brown, Maric, Jacobs and Warnock it's not funny.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

goldstein and macintosh = easily the best ruck pairing in the afl imo

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

I tried really hard not to read this thread, I truly did, but now that I'm in here 20 posts have been scrubbed and a few cards have been handed out.

In future, if you have concerns about someones posts REPORT IT.

As far as this thread goes though, no more warnings. Keep to the discussion and follow the rules of the board.