Review Mike's Top 50 post season

[murph4charlie]

The post season top 50 is based on season 2011 and finals appearances

So far only 50 - 31 have been announced. They read like this:

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/af...-1226158367144

31: Fyfe
32 SIMPSON
33: Gibson
34: Wells
35: Petrie
36: Bock
37: Birchall
38: Scott Thompson
39: Hodge
40: Ben Reid
41: Sewell
42: Goddard
43: Watson
44: Robert Murphy
45: David
46: GIBBS
47: Deledio
48: Corey
49: Moloney
50: Milne

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/af...-1226158367144

Great to see simpson get recognised, he had a great year. Also Gibbler getting in is promising.

Scotland isn't there (yet) - surely he will be top 30?
Goddard and Wells are lucky to be that high after their seasons IMO
Other than that I don't think its too bad so far.

Thoughts?

 

[murph4charlie]

Also what do you think the top 5 or so will be?

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Pendles
4. Franklin
5. Murph
6. Cloke

Some familiar names in mine, I hope Swan isn't too high

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Wells had a good year. No issue with him being in there.

Judd, Murphy, Scotland should be in. Walker and Betts a chance but possibly not given there are only 30 spots left. That would be impressive though.

Is there a link to this list, so we can credit the source appropriately?

 

[thylacine60]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...-players-of-2011/story-e6frf9jf-1226158367144

 

[murph4charlie]

danke thy

 

[SpaceCow]

Considering Milne is at 50 I doubt we'll see Betts or Jeffy. Walker a slight chance.

Judd, Murph and potentially Scotland to come.

 

[sifo]

Also what do you think the top 5 or so will be?

1. Judd
2. Ablett
3. Pendles
4. Franklin
5. Murph
6. Cloke

Some familiar names in mine, I hope Swan isn't too high

Mike Shehan is the man who said judd wasn't in the top 5 players last year. so it wouldn't surprise me for a spud like him to put judd 20 or something outlandish like that.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Ben Reid was the AA CHB. Seriously Mike 40...

I just don't dig these top 50's

unless of course a Carlton player is at 1.

 

[Aphrodite]

Ben Reid was the AA CHB. Seriously Mike 40...

I just don't dig these top 50's

unless of course a Carlton player is at 1.

Totally agree.

Afterall it's only Mike's opinion and it gets people talking much like KB does with his ramblings on GuesSEN.

 

[Stig O'Hara]

....and it gets people talking much like KH does with his ramblings on sportsnewsfirst.

efa.

He knows his stuff.

 

[Wickzki]

Fully expecting the list to come out looking something like the following;

1 - Lance Franklin
2 - Joel Selwood
3 - Scott Pendlebury
4 - Gary Ablett Jr
5 - Dane Swan
6 - Sam Mitchell
7 - Marc Murphy
8 - Jimmy Bartel
9 - Travis Cloke
10 - Nick Dal Santo
11 - Dean Cox
12 - Chris Judd
13 - Steve Johnson
14 - Dale Thomas
15 - Adam Goodes
16 - Matthew Boyd
17 - Matthew Priddis
18 - Cyril Rioli
19 - Darren Glass
20 - Paul Chapman
21 - Josh Kennedy
22 - James Kelly
23 - Nicolas Naitanui
24 - Daniel Kerr
25 - Matthew Scarlett
26 - Shane Mumford
27 - Andrew Swallow
28 - Luke Ball
29 - Jordan Lewis
30 - Corey Enright


Note: That's NOT how I would see it but how I think he would.

 

[Aphrodite]

efa.

He knows his stuff.

Ken Hinkley

 

[Wickzki]

Bit of a spoiler... In the section you can pick your top fifty they have 60 players listed...

Carlton players on that list NOT already named (Simpson, Gibbs) are Chris Judd, Marc Murphy, Andrew Walker and Chris Yarran. Eddie Betts and Jeff Garlett are supposively not in his unlucky to miss group either (51-60).

From my top 30 Daniel Kerr and Paul Chapman aren't listed in the 60 either.

Simon Black, Trent Cotchin, Andrew Embley, Sam Fisher, Todd Goldstein, Dyson Heppell, Brent Moloney, Luke McPharlin, Tom Rockliff, Rhyce Shaw, Andrew Walker and Chris Yarran are the names I did not list in the top 30 that appear on his board.

 

[marcmurphy#3]

Mike will do something stupid, like putting Cyril in the top 5 or something along those lines.

 

[Wickzki]

Mike will do something stupid, like putting Cyril in the top 5 or something along those lines.

No, he'll have Nic Spudanui in the top ten.

 

[jackn]

Carlton players on that list NOT already named (Simpson, Gibbs) are Chris Judd, Marc Murphy, Andrew Walker and Chris Yarran. Eddie Betts and Jeff Garlett are supposively not in his unlucky to miss group either (51-60).

Please tell me you forgot scotland and he's in the top 60. Joke list otherwise

 

[Wickzki]

Please tell me you forgot scotland and he's in the top 60. Joke list otherwise

Yes, he made the list. My bad.

 

[Wickzki]

30. Luke McPharlin
29. Andrew Swallow
28. Matthew Priddis
27. Shane Mumford
26. Josh Kennedy (Sydney) -- WTF?! Would not crack a gig in our midfield.
25. Trent Cotchin
24. Matthew Boyd
23. Todd Goldstein
22. Luke Ball
21. HEATH SCOTLAND "Deserved an All-Australia berth. Had 617 possessions and an efficiency rating of 80 per cent. Just because he's 31 ...
20. Jimmy Bartel
19. Nick Dal Santo
18. Steve Johnson
17. Sam Fisher
16. Matthew Scarlett
15. Dale Thomas
14. Adam Goodes
13. James Kelly
12. Dean Cox
11. Corey Enright

Good to see Scotland in his top 22 and great to see Murphy and Judd inside the top ten, you'd have to imagine. Am shocked to see Scotland ahead of Matthew Boyd, however.

 

[Sublime]

Don't underestimate what Josh Kennedy would do in our midfield. Big bulldozer who always gets first hands on the ball. The exact player to compliment Judd, Gibbs, Murph & Co.

 

[zeeCFC]

I'd start talking dynasties if we had any of the two Josh Kennedys

 

[GordonBlue]

26. Josh Kennedy (Sydney) -- WTF?! Would not crack a gig in our midfield.

Not true at all... Sydney version of JK is exactly what our midfield would require! I would go as far to say, there wouldn't be another player out there that would suit to cover our deficiencies in our midfield like JK Sydney format!

JK West Coast format would be handy too

 

[ESKIE]

Mike Sheahan has an over exaggerated estimate of his own opinions and importance ...

 

[Aphrodite]

Mike Sheahan has an over exaggerated estimate of his own opinions and importance ...

Spot on Bluesque.

My thoughts exactly as it is only his opinion and gets people talking.

 

[Pafloyul]

Mike Sheahan has an over exaggerated estimate of his own opinions and importance ...

Yeah, I didn't spot Walker there, either.

 

[Tanks_Alot]

26. Josh Kennedy (Sydney) -- WTF?! Would not crack a gig in our midfield.

I'm going to have to agree with the others on this one. Kennedy would be a perfect inside mid to compliment Judd and Murphy. He's hard at it and wins his own ball plus he has a big body he's actually the exact kind of player we need.