Morabito vs Melksham vs Bastinac

[Lance Uppercut]

Bastinac has it all over Melksham.

the **** he does

 

[Brad Roo]

the **** he does

Apologies, Melksham has 0.1% more inside 50's and 0.9% one percenters per match over Bastinac.

Otherwise, Bastinac has it all over him.

 

[Spitz]

Apologies, Melksham has 0.1% more inside 50's and 0.9% one percenters per match over Bastinac.

Otherwise, Bastinac has it all over him.

He averages about 5 touches a game more, and leads North for clearances by a fair margin.


Melksham has been good, but Bastinac's season to date is underrated, he's been in the top 3 first year players easily, his KPI's are similar to Marc Murphy's, minus the goals.

 

[Brad Roo]

He averages about 5 touches a game more, and leads North for clearances by a fair margin.


Melksham has been good, but Bastinac's season to date is underrated, he's been in the top 3 first year players easily, his KPI's are similar to Marc Murphy's, minus the goals.

Now THAT is interesting.

 

[Sin City]

Now THAT is interesting.

No, it's not.

 

[Bigeasy]

Bastinac is definately the better looking. Football wise, all pretty good so far. Melksham's been dropped hasn't he? Mora is playing in a winning team so on those facts, i say Scully.

 

[Tailypo]

Bastinac is definately the better looking. Football wise, all pretty good so far. Melksham's been dropped hasn't he? Mora is playing in a winning team so on those facts, i say Scully.

Injured.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

Melksham's been dropped hasn't he?

god almighty, at least know what you're talking about can't you?

 

[Brad Roo]

Bastinac - 25 possessions (84% eff), 3 tackles, 4 clearances in a team that was smashed in the middle.

Morabito - 18 possessions (67% eff), 2 tackles, 4 clearances.

 

[dutchy12]

Bastinac - 25 possessions (84% eff), 3 tackles, 4 clearances in a team that was smashed in the middle.

Morabito - 18 possessions (67% eff), 2 tackles, 4 clearances.

Could you find a metres gained statistic?

 

[CrimsonRaven]

I reckon Morabito will probably take longer, but at the end of their careers barring injuries he will be a awesome player and ahead of the other two.

 

[TigerTime88]

Morra is the biggest risk draft pick wise. Could go 2 ways superstar that grows into his body and dominates even if with a lack of footskills aka Adam Goodes mark II, or his big body in under 18's is what made him stand out.

Have see him do a couple of nice things just simple taps to advantage..

Would take Morrabito purley for the fact he could be a superstar...

 

[creamygoodness]

Morra is the biggest risk draft pick wise. Could go 2 ways superstar that grows into his body and dominates even if with a lack of footskills aka Adam Goodes mark II, or his big body in under 18's is what made him stand out.

Have see him do a couple of nice things just simple taps to advantage..

Would take Morrabito purley for the fact he could be a superstar...

Wouldn't say Morabito lacks footskills, Goodes either, I've seen him kick some gorgeous long goals. I would say his problem atm is bombing it long without surveying options, definitely something he needs to work on. You're right about his upside though, has got greater potential than Stephen Hill who's getting all the attention atm. Very similar player to Goodes and the midfield version of Pavlich, so strong in the core, can't be tackled, great acceleration for his size.

 

[eth-dog]

Mora then Melk then Basti for me

 

[symmos]

Bastinac is ahead of Morabito and Melksham. Morabito has played avery game but hasnt consolidated a regular spot in the Fremantle line up. He has played on the wing, on a half back flank and up forward. He has done some impressive things but they have been few and far between. Melksham hasnt played every game for the Bombers this season. When he gets the ball in his hands, he usually makes the right decisions and executes these with precise skills. The problem for Melksham is getting the ball in his hands. When he starts winning his own footy and getting more touches he will be a very good midfielder. Bastinac has played every game for the Kangaroos this season. He is a integral part of the North midfield and can find the footy. He has good skills and makes smart decisions on the field but the thing that seperates him from the other two is his consistency. He has been one of the most consistent player in the North line up this year and the most consistent player from the 2009 draft.
He will be a great player for many years to come.

 

[Red Black and Blue]

Mora has had a great day, not sure about his stats, but nearly everything he has done has been very clean and very damaging.

 

[E Shed]

Couple of things Mora did today were jaw dropping wow moments.
Kid is going to be a gun.

 

[Gazza_11]

Melksham the pick for me, his disposal is beautiful and he's a jet too. Used to think Morabito was a spud but he's played well the last few.