Mesc
Ayahuascero
- Mar 30, 2008
- 8,337
- 7,468
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- South Freo , Coney Island Warriors.
Nat Fyfe
- Thread starter Blues90
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Noobz0r
Tom Jonas Fan Club Junior VP
- Aug 18, 2009
- 30,325
- 40,079
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
So he's the WA version of Ben Cunnington?
Shane Heard
Brownlow Medallist
- Mar 11, 2018
- 10,285
- 17,293
- AFL Club
- Essendon
metrosexual lives matter
harty1221
Senior List
- Aug 1, 2020
- 183
- 201
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #104
What a ridiculous argument! Buckley was a better player then dusty Richo and Fyfe and never won a flag??
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
You're right, he ain't no James Hird, all and sundry stopped making the comparison years ago when Fyfe surpassed Hird.
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 19,598
- 42,299
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
What's the consensus on Pav v Fyfe for Freo fans?
Pav and Fyfe kinda similar in terms of impact on game. Fyfe great midfielder who can be pushed forward and make an impact. Pav great forward who could be thrown in the midfield and make an impact. Pav ahead for mine at the moment. Fyfe should pass him by careers end.
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,253
- 71,626
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #108
GAJ is the best since 2000 personally, Judd and Franklin I wouldnt be able to differentiate (thought prime Judd is my absolute favourite of all time to watch). There is a logjam behind them though I'd have Fyfe pretty much the best of that lot. It's funny, Pav will probably have the better career because Fyfe wont get to 300 games I dont think (yet alone close to 350) but Fyfe's peak is better.
There is a bit of differentiation between best career and best player to me.
There is a bit of differentiation between best career and best player to me.
- Apr 30, 2015
- 13,620
- 24,448
- AFL Club
- West Coast
This isn't adding to the discussion, but it is pretty funny
(ignore the top tweet)
(ignore the top tweet)
Pavlich, but only because he was more durable. In 17 seasons he had 1 where he played less than 18 games.
I reckon on any given day Fyfe is the slightly better player.
Parasite
Norm Smith Medallist
If I saw my 10 year old daughter doing that during a basketball game I’d be pissed - now I’ve seen that.. wtf.
I'm not sure. You'd have to ask them
What about Hawkins v Pavlich?
- Sep 27, 2018
- 2,313
- 4,622
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- brisbane lions
Thats a very interesting question.
hawkins probably better to build a forward line around because hes taller and a better contested mark. Never underestimate how hard it is to build a functioning forward line .
Pav kicked 700 goals despite playing 6 seasons of 17 in either midfield (averaging over a goal a game and 20+ disposals) or back (played remarkably like shannon hurn i reckon). On a side note from the period 2002 to 2015 which was his prime i don't think freos percentage dipped below 85 could be wrong though.
So if i were to draft one I'd actually go for what I need. If i need a key forward hawkins otherwise all other positions pav is better.
People get sentimental about pavlich but fyfe is undoutably the better player.
I put fyfe 5th since 2000 ablett, franklin, judd, martin and fyfe. However if fyfe manages to get a premiership medallion or another brownlow genuine chance of jumping to third.
- Mar 19, 2016
- 1,488
- 5,289
- AFL Club
- Richmond
22 Ablett Srs would beat a 22 of any other player except, maybe, 22 Fyfes.
He’s the best I’ve seen since Ablett Sr and I hope he wins a third Brownlow and gets a premiership.
He’s the best I’ve seen since Ablett Sr and I hope he wins a third Brownlow and gets a premiership.
lumpinee
MK ULTRA
what a w***er,wouldnt get a game at a professional club,but hey thats the standard fremantle accept,individual idoltry
Imagine believing Nat Fyfe wouldn't get a game at a 'professional' club lmao what a loser
Wojcinski
Brownlow Medallist
He's the best since ~2015. If he weren't quite as injury prone he could possible elevate even higher. He's won 2 Brownlows already so if he gets a good run at a year or 2 mostly injury free he could reach the next bracket of peak Judd, GAJ and Buddy as a modern great.
Last edited:
- Apr 26, 2011
- 10,430
- 12,339
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Wimbledon AFC
I can see
Can't see him getting another as he will be playing more & more forward as the young guns take control of the midfield.
He should have won 3 already. He was robbed 1 year.
Can't see him getting another as he will be playing more & more forward as the young guns take control of the midfield.
- Aug 17, 2006
- 23,308
- 21,607
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Can I say how impressive it is that you've just made the seventeen posts after this?
lumpinee
MK ULTRA
hes won 1 more brownlow than that other afl legend shane woewodin,that should add some perspective in regards to achievements on winning the brownlow and where that now sits and has sat for the past 22 years after essentially becoming just a midfielders award
Depends on the team you have. Hawkins is elite 1 on 1 in comparison. Good when the balls coming into him 1 on 1 and when you have good crumbling forwards. But pav was more versatile, plays in the mid and was still a strong contributor when the ball hit the deck.
So few players on field in basketball. Probably possibly to win a premiership of the boot (or hand) of one player.
Try Leigh Matthew trophies then. Havings said that Buddy probably deserved one, too.
Anyway. Overall it is impossible to make a final decision. He is among the very best. Everything else is based on a bit of luck with injuries, team success and media reception.
Those goals still give me goosebumps and I hate Hawthorn.
Similar threads
