Nat Fyfe

[WCEbrody]

I'd have him 3rd, just below Martin & Dangerfield over the past 5 years.

Fantastic individual player.

 

[scottishfiction]

Reminds me of a young Koutafides

ahahahahahha

Koutafides was a spud; athletic beast but pretty questionable with the football. which matters. or it used to...

 

[PAFC_1870]

ahahahahahha

Koutafides was a spud; athletic beast but pretty questionable with the football. which matters. or it used to...

You can't even spell his name Rook.

Delete your account before you humiliate your fellow fans with more stupid posts.

 

[MadMundy]

what a w***er,wouldnt get a game at a professional club,but hey thats the standard fremantle accept,individual idoltry

Mate he'd be a walk on starter at yours or any other team in the league. Would be your best player instantly too.

 

[Darcy 2 Fyfe]

Cant impact a game like this fella. Read his bio, it's impressive-

 

[Numero Uno]

Cant impact a game like this fella. Read his bio, it's impressive-

View attachment 938460View attachment 938463

didn't have your 3 goal advantage Margetts umpiring for you

 

[Darcy 2 Fyfe]

didn't have your 3 goal advantage Margetts umpiring for you

No he's been busy pushing you lot into finals

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

Reading through this thread and here some thoughts

- Imagine calling Fyfe just an accumulator. Save that tag for the Gaffs and Mitchell's of the league.

- Imagine comparing basketball to AFL in terms of the amount of influence you can have on the game. Giannis, Harden, LBJ touch the ball on almost every possession and form 20% of the starting line up. Fyfe is just 1 of 18 players on the field.

-No awards for anyone who can guess from which club's supporters these comments came from.

- If Fyfe was Victorian, he'd be the consensus best player in the comp. If Fyfe wasn't so injury prone, he would have finished up as the 2nd best player this century behind Ablett.

 

[Bald]

Nat Fyfe averages 1 brownlow vote per game in his career.

He is at least the third best player on the ground in every one of the games he's ever played. He is a long way ahead of the next best in that statistic. I personally think he's only behind Buddy and GAJ in the players I've ever seen.

 

[WCEbrody]

If Fyfe wasn't so injury prone, he would have finished up as the 2nd best player this century behind Ablett.

You've just gone too far the other way now.

 

[Numero Uno]

No he's been busy pushing you lot into finals

View attachment 938487

lol what ever lie you need to cling to

 

[The Falcon Strike]

The best footballer (imo) is the one that can win a contested ball and get it to a teammate in an j contested position (or kick a goal)

for mine - fyfe has been the standout for quite a while now

whilst it’s amusing to mock his sub par kicking - it doesn’t really matter - it’s what a player can do - not can’t do - that matters

 

[Darcy 2 Fyfe]

lol what ever lie you need to cling to

Your delusional comments are true but the stats aren't. You're a rare breed you lot.

 

[T2B_]

Great player, just wish he'd have less injury troubles. Hate seeing injuries interrupt brilliant players, but that's footy I know.

 

[Tim Evans Beard]

He does have a tendency to cheap shot players and throw his leg out to trip when better players get past him. Pretty well looked after to get a Brownlow one year when should have been rubbed out.

 

[Vintage]

He does have a tendency to cheap shot players and throw his leg out to trip when better players get past him. Pretty well looked after to get a Brownlow one year when should have been rubbed out.

Fortunately for him there aren’t many better players so that tendency doesn’t come out too often

 

[PP34]

You reckon Michael Jordan would consider himself the goat if he never overcame those Pistons and win 6 champiobships in a "team" sport?

You can't reach atop the mountain, you shouldn't be in the conversation for this almighty accolade.

Hes a phenomenal player, but a career incomplete without a premiership, he's in the Robert Harvey, Scott West, Lenny Hayes, Nathan Buckley tier. And seriously, that's fantastic company.

What a silly comparison. A single player can have a massive impact on the basketball court with it only being a 5 vs 5 game. Football has been and always will be a much more team orientated game.

No champion player has ever done it on his own in the AFL.

Dusty been great the last few years but wouldn't be a two time premiership player without Vlastuin, Rance, Grimes etc down back, Prestia, Cotchin etc in the middle and Riewoldt, Lynch etc up forward. Ablett wouldn't have won anything without Scarlett, Enright, Johnson, Bartel, Mooney etc. Buddy likewise without Hodge, Rioli, Mitchell, Lewis, Birchall etc.

 

[Handsome_Jack]

I'd have him over any player in the league and that's about all you can say about a player really.

 

[lumpinee]

Those goals still give me goosebumps and I hate Hawthorn.

along with GAJ the only 2 true superstars this century so far

 

[lumpinee]

He's the best since ~2015. If he weren't quite as injury prone he could possible elevate even higher. He's won 2 Brownlows already so if he gets a good run at a year or 2 mostly injury free he could reach the next bracket of peak Judd, GAJ and Buddy as a modern great.

Google Image Result for https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cf/Dustin_Martin_2017.3.jpg

images.app.goo.gl

 

[Darren Moore]

He's a champ, but wasted the bulk of his career under Lyon.

 

[deskc]

yes one of the greatest I've ever seen a great player and a good person too

 

[lumpinee]

I’ve got my opinion and it’s right! 2 Brownlows doesn’t make you “a good ordinary player” as much as it pains me to say he probably has dusty covered! Especially from a consistency point of view.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

u wanna re visit this opinion ? theyre not even in the same conversation ...never have been imo,except for about 1.5 seasons...chalk n cheese mate...Dustys getting compared to the legendary KB ...that says it all
no disrespect but ive watched footy for 44 years,Fyffes not even top 50, believe me

 

[PhatBoy]

The bloke is a rolls Royce

 

[74561347]

nat fyfe bought a milk bar in lake grace he served me the other day

cheap smokes but the milkshake was average

i got vanilla