Newman vs Gibbs

[Willie Stark]

Seriously have you ever rated any Carlton player's past or present?

Just give me one, or are they all crap in your mind!

Zac Dawson>>>>>>>Stephen Silvagni!!!!!!!!!!

 

[azza_24]

Gibbs by a mile.

 

[Thrawn]

Don't worry about it mate.

I bet he rates Nick Holland ahead of Kernahan

He rates Fletcher ahead of Silvagni, so yeah...

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Current votes:

Newman - 114
Gibbs - 103

*giggles*

Ah bigfooty, you never fail to make me laugh!!

 

[CranePooleSchmidt]

Right atm; clearly it is Gibbs

 

[gandaal]

Right atm; clearly it is Gibbs

2 minutes after Gibbs' birth it was clearly Gibbs.

 

[Barry Zuckercorn]

Hahahahahaha!

Worst. Poll. Ever.

 

[Muji]

The word that epitomises a Bitchmond supporter.

Delusional

 

[Team Mo']

2 minutes after Gibbs' birth it was clearly Gibbs.

What did Newman do right in that minute?

 

[celtic_pride]

this is such a stupid poll there is aboloutly no doubt that newman is the better player

LOL LOL LOL ...

Having second doubts champ ???

 

[Team Mo']

Thanks CP. I thought I killed a great thread.

 

[eth-dog]

Newman>>>Gibbs

you see, Newman can play HB, C, Wing, HF, BP and pretty much all over the ground. Gibbs is over-rated

 

[mickelboy182]

Newman>>>Gibbs

you see, Newman can play HB, C, Wing, HF, BP and pretty much all over the ground. Gibbs is over-rated

And Gibbs can't/hasn't played in all of those positions you've just listed?

Obviously watched him play a fair bit!

 

[Team Mo']

Newman>>>Gibbs

you see, Newman can play HB, C, Wing, HF, BP and pretty much all over the ground. Gibbs is over-rated

Is this a joke? I'd say it's the exact opposite.

Gibbs can play anywhere but ruck whereas Newman is a rebounding defender who goes into the midfield occasionally with minimal effect.

Laughable that you'd compare 2 players on versatility alone.

 

[HARKER]

Bryce is much better than Sam

 

[celtic_pride]

Newman is dog poo ..

Worst captain in the league by a mile (and even richmond fans would agree with that)