Our current 'Top 10'

[Vdubs]

Following on from the overrated argument, how do we rate our TOP 10?? How about?

1. Bartel
2. Hawkins
3. Selwood
4. Taylor
5. Johnson
6. Kelly
7. Enright
8. Scarlett
9. Chapman
10. Mackie

I expect Varcoe, Menzel, West to displace Enright, Scarlett and Chappy, by or during 2013 or sooner

 

[bulletproof]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Hawkins, 2, eh?

 

[vinum coupe]

Re: Our current Top 10.

here you go, in order.



Johnson
Bartel
Enright
Selwood
Scarlett

Kelly
Taylor
Mackie
Chapman
Corey

The good thing is that I reckon the following are 1 year away from kicking someone out of the top 10

Menzel, Hawkins, Lonergan, Varcoe, Duncan, Christensen.
Not saying all 6 will go in, of course they wont, but gee they'll be fighting for it.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1.Selwood
2.Scarlett
3.Johnson
4.Enright
5.Bartel
6.Kelly
7.Chapman
8.Corey
9.Mackie
10.Podsiadly

 

[muttweed]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1. Bartel
2. Scarlett
3. Selwood
4. Enright
5. Johnson
6. Kelly
7. Corey
8. Mackie
9. Lonergan
10. Taylor

Unlucky: Pods, Chapman

 

[ChappyUK]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1. Johnson
2. Selwood
3. Bartel
4. Chapman
5. Hawkins
6. Scarlett
7. Enright
8. Kelly
9. Podsiadly
10. Taylor

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Our best ten players, going into 2012

1. Selwood
2. Enright
3. Bartel
4. Johnson
5. Kelly
6. Scarlett
7. Chapman
8. Taylor
9. Corey
10. Lonergan

 

[bulletproof]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Scarlett
Enright
Selwood
Bartel
Taylor
Johnson
Kelly
Podsiadly
Corey
Hawkins

Would have liked to make room for Stokes, Varcoe and Mackie.

 

[Rosso]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Bartel
Selwood
Scarlett
Enright
Johnson
Chapman
Kelly
Corey
Taylor
Pods

Lonners & Mackie stiff to miss.
Menz, Bundy & Hawkins to slot in by the end of the year.

 

[David the Cat]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1 Scarlett
2 SJ
3 Bartel
4 Selwood
5 Enright
6 Kelly
7 Chapman
8 Taylor
9 Corey
10 Hawkins

Varcoe, Pods, Mackie and Lonergan next in line. Bundy, Menzel and Duncan won't be far away by 2013/14.

 

[muttweed]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1. Johnson
2. Selwood
3. Bartel
4. Chapman
5. Hawkins
6. Scarlett
7. Enright
8. Kelly
9. Podsiadly
10. Taylor

No Corey?

 

[vealesy]

1 Scarlett
2 SJ
3 Bartel
4 Selwood
5 Enright
6 Kelly
7 Chapman
8 Taylor
9 Corey
10 Hawkins

Varcoe, Pods, Mackie and Lonergan next in line. Bundy, Menzel and Duncan won't be far away by 2013/14.

Agree with this.

 

[ChappyUK]

Re: Our current Top 10.

No Corey?

Love Corey. The list is more of a Top 10 of who I think we can't afford to lose. As good as Corey is, the Cats have shown they have enough to cover him when he's injured.

 

[bobbycatsfanme]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1. Selwood
2. Johnson
3. Bartel
4. Enright
5. Kelly
6. Scarlett
7. Corey
8. Taylor
8.5 Chapman
9. Mackie
10. Hawkins

 

[Ninty]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Bartel
Selwood
Johnson
Scarlett
Enright
Lonergan
Hawkins
Taylor
Kelly
Varcoe

 

[oozeboss]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Last time I looked it was:

10. Dan Menzel.

 

[longtimecat]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Enright [ twice B&F in a premiership team]
Bartel
Selwood
Johnson
Lonergan
Scarlett
Kelly
Chapman
Varcoe
Taylor

These are on recent form not reputation, Lonergan for example has become our most important backman and Hawkins our key forward.
Congrats to bobbycatsfanme for fitting 11 players into top ten.

 

[muttweed]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Enright [ twice B&F in a premiership team]
Bartel
Selwood
Johnson
Lonergan
Scarlett
Kelly
Chapman
Varcoe
Taylor

These are on recent form not reputation, Lonergan for example has become our most important backman and Hawkins our key forward.
Congrats to bobbycatsfanme for fitting 11 players into top ten.

If we're talking recent form, Taylor (and maybe Chappy and Kelly) should be nowhere near this list.

Mackie was one of our best on GF day, played the game of his life.

 

[David the Cat]

Re: Our current Top 10.

If we're talking recent form, Taylor (and maybe Chappy and Kelly) should be nowhere near this list.

Mackie was one of our best on GF day, played the game of his life.

You can't be serious mutty......Kelly was enormous all year and won AA.....

Absolutely in our top 10!

 

[Partridge]

Re: Our current Top 10.

1 Scarlett
2 SJ
3 Bartel
4 Selwood
5 Enright
6 Kelly
7 Chapman
8 Taylor
9 Corey
10 Hawkins

Varcoe, Pods, Mackie and Lonergan next in line. Bundy, Menzel and Duncan won't be far away by 2013/14.

Based on 2011 form, especially late in the season, Mackie and Lonergan are very very close to that list.

We need Hawkins to take number 1 now.

 

[marshhhhh]

Re: Our current Top 10.

You can't be serious mutty......Kelly was enormous all year and won AA.....

Absolutely in our top 10!

Totally agree
Kelly was being talked up by many as a big chance to take out the B&F.
Stellar season.

 

[Sttew]

I see our top 10, on sustained form up to the GF, as follows:

1. Joel Selwood
2. James Kelly
3. Corey Enright
4. Matthew Scarlett
5. Jimmy Bartel
6. Steve Johnson
7. Harry Taylor
8. Paul Chapman
9. Andrew Mackie
10 Tom Hawkins = Joel Corey

 

[longtimecat]

Re: Our current Top 10.

Recent form is not just one game, I find Mackie too inconsistant. I will grant you Taylor's form in the G/F was not great and I tried to fit Hawkins into the ten given he was our best finals performer, but how you can doubt Paul Chapmans team worth is beyond me.

 

[Big Nasty]

1) Selwood
2) Bartel
3) Enright
4) Johnson
5) Scarlett
6) Chapman
7) Kelly
8) Taylor
9) Corey
10) Lonergan

 

[Farmer2Goggin]

Based on 2011

1. Bartel
2. Enright
3. Scarlett
4. Kelly
5. Selwood
6. Corey
7. SJ
8. Lonergan
9. Chapman
10. Mackie