Poll only.. we have enough threads..

[jefffff34]

Well he has treated everyone at the Club and Supporters like Crap. I don't really want someone like that at collingwood

I dare say he has given more to the fans by being an exciting player that has equisite skills than treating us like crap...

 

[Visions]

I think he is finished playing for the year. The leadership group will make sure of that, and the club may revise his contract.

If he was an average footballer he would be sacked or traded, however due to him being one of our top few footballers (lets face it we are definitely struggling for those) he will be allowed to play on next year.

All this business about getting rid of him to make an example, well the point is valid, but having a team of nice guys won't win you a premiership.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Suspend for two weeks and offer up at trade week, but not do a trade unless a suitable trade is workable.

This could be a blessing in disguise as up until now we havent had suitable trade bait to pull in a big name.

 

[jefffff34]

This could be a blessing in disguise as up until now we havent had suitable trade bait to pull in a big name.

Nope, I won't accept that.

Didak is a big name, he is a matchwinner, and he's our matchwinner.

I'm over football.

 

[Pies_10]

Re: Poll only.. we have enough thread..

A $5,000 fine for lying, and then let it be.

Or at worst, suspend him for this week.

Love Dids butt couldnt disagree more this is why our players do this.
Cloke,Welly,Dids,Shaw we need to finally come down REALLY hard. suspend for season and then trade, dont worry this season we arent even gonna be in the finals anyways our club is in real trouble atm on and off the field.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Nope, I won't accept that.

Didak is a big name, he is a matchwinner, and he's our matchwinner.

I'm over football.

I'm more interested in premierships. Didak has shown he doesnt give a rats about his teammates.

 

[jefffff34]

I'm more interested in premierships. Didak has shown he doesnt give a rats about his teammates.

Gotta win matches to win premierships, and a lot too.

 

[pongo_3931]

Suspend then trade.

Leaves the door open for some sort of negotiation / redemption during the suspension period any way.

 

[shawthing09]

Revise contract and suspened indefinately. New contract obviously including being able to be sacked for mistakes of this nature. I do not think the new contract should have unrealistic curfew's etc which are only gonig to create more trouble. He should not be allowed to play AFL or train with the senior team till the leadership group etc feel he has proven and redeemed himself.

 

[Mental Magpie]

I love both these players, so it kills me saying this.

Suspend both players until the end of the season. Throw both of them up at trade time. Didak for Kerr. Shaw and first round pick for J. Brown. Either for O'keefe. (for example)

If the club can pull off a couple of good trades as a result, then so be it.

If it can't, then it will be a massive reality check for both players.

Why lie? This is the real issue, not the Drink Driving!

 

[Visions]

Suspend for two weeks and offer up at trade week, but not do a trade unless a suitable trade is workable.

This could be a blessing in disguise as up until now we havent had suitable trade bait to pull in a big name.

There's only two big names that might be on offer this year, Kerr and Brown.

Brown - Didn't want to come to the club a few years back and doesn't want to come this time around.

Kerr - If Collingwood is so adamant about a clean culture why would they pick him up? His off field behavior track record is as bad, if not worse than Didak's. Would be totally contradicting themselves.

 

[fossman]

obviously they have both acted like complete tools and made the club look stupid.
About 10 pages on this in Herald Sun today, the usual anti collingwood witch hunt. Eddie should have taken out an injunction.

 

[Godfrey Jones]

obviously they have both acted like complete tools and made the club look stupid.
About 10 pages on this in Herald Sun today, the usual anti collingwood witch hunt. Eddie should have taken out an injunction.

yeh bad, huh??

that mike sheahan shits me to no end.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Kerr - If Collingwood is so adamant about a clean culture why would they pick him up? His off field behavior track record is as bad, if not worse than Didak's. Would be totally contradicting themselves.

Kerr is a more genuine midfielder than Didak.

 

[Shellz]

Hey sorry to troll but had to have a say.
Gee you guys are amazing. At least West Coast had the balls to sack cousins . Grow up show some guts and delist the idiot wether he is one of your best or not. One bad apple and some of the others will follow. Remember cousins never proved positive to any afl tests . It was West Coast to had had enough of his behaviour. Be interesting to see how strong big Ed is now.

Yeah and were are the Eagles this year?? Enjoying life down the bottom?

 

[Visions]

Kerr is a more genuine midfielder than Didak.

Yes I know, but that's not the point of my argument. Why would we trade for him when we are trying to bring a "culture" to the club?

 

[didaka]

In all honesty, I will be filthy if he does not play this weekend.

It's a dead set witch hunt by the media, surely some perspective here.

Any wonder Heath lied for Alan really, they knew what was going to come out of this if it got out that Alan was in the car. Ridiculous.

How much was Cousins allowed to get away with, how much is Fevola allowed to get away with (and then get a meaty contract to boot), how much is Todd Carney from the Canberra Raiders allowed to get away with?

For Mike ****ing Sheahan to come out and say "DIDAK MUST GO" is an embarrassment to journalism.

Best post I've seen on the subject

 

[mattys123]

Suspend for one week, then revise contract now.

He hasnt done much wrong, lying is his sin here.

Heath is in more trouble from this situation then Alan.

Dont want to lose him, especially for Johnathon Brown.

 

[didaka]

Lying to the club stinks, but Didak hasn't really ever broken any laws.

I think some of these opposition internet hero's would be a little surprised if they new what is possibly going on at their club, it just never hits the papers.

It's a hard gig being a pies supporter sometimes.

I got a card in the mail from the Collingwood football club last week signed by certain high profile players with some really special messages written by all involved and I will cherish it for the rest of my life. Both Didak and Shaw were involved.

They may stuff up and do a few bad things, but I tell ya something, these blokes lifted my spirits 100% last week and I've had a pretty rough time.

The media will never get hold of that and print a story.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Yes I know, but that's not the point of my argument. Why would we trade for him when we are trying to bring a "culture" to the club?

As far as I know Kerr has never lied about his activities. Misbehaviour is one thing but lying is something else again. Didak has burnt his bridges.

 

[pooley]

As requested, I voted delist.

You can only give idiots (regardless of talent) so many chances. This guy is a cancer and Collingwood (or anybody else) will continue to rue having this tool on their list.

A career criminal / serial pest in the making perhaps?

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Lying to the club stinks, but Didak hasn't really ever broken any laws.

Leaving the scene of an accident is a crime, albeit that if they hadn't lied to the club, I wouldn't have raised an eyebrow if told Didak was a passenger. It's Whocaresville.