He kicked 4 in a GF (16 minute quaters, "probably kick 5"?) with a midfield of Cotchin, Prestia & Edwards, but you say only 1 extra goal? To justify picking those two and Gary jnr over Cotchin, Prestia & Edwards I'd expect Martin to get more than 5 in any hypothetical game.These two and GAJ are your starting midfield in any hypothetical grand final. Dusty would be on a forward flank and would probably kick 5 goals with that midfield ahead of him. But it's ludicrous to ignore the talents of the 3 that are clearly ahead of him - as shown by the posts in this thread.
Even in that hypothetical game it would still be Martin that we'd all be saying "don't get beaten by what you know" about.
Martin would still have to play some time in the middle in the hypothetical game when one of those other 3 needs to take a rest, we can't expect them to play the full game in the middle, they're not Bryan Wood, Robert Wiley and Geoff Raines.