Reid Vs Butcher Vs Gunston

[detox]

Who do you think will end up the best KPF of these 3?

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Too early to tell
At the moment it is Reid, and by some margin

Think gunston will kick the most goals of the 3 though

 

[detox]

Too early to tell
At the moment it is Reid, and by some margin

Think gunston will kick the most goals of the 3 though

I'd Say the opposite.

Gunston has had the better start, would expect Reid to just shade him in the future as the focal point of Sydneys attack. Butcher could be the best of the lot tho..

 

[Wizard]

I actually think this is a really clear order with these guys if your looking long term:
Sam Reid
John Butcher
Jack Gunston

All very very good footballers, but thats a resounding order IMO.

 

[Bardo State]

It's really hard to judge KPFs at that sort of age. I think Gunston would be very good as the focal point of a forwardline but that won't happen for another 5+ years.

I'd say Reid at the moment looks likely to have the brightest future but you really couldn't say any of the three with any sort of surety.

 

[Monkey King]

I went with Butcher for the future

 

[raymagoo]

Reid by a bit IMO

 

[detox]

Gunston

28 Games
Reid
42
7.2 Kicks Per Game 5.9
4.0 Handballs Per Game 4.1
11.2 Disposals Per Game 10.0
4.6 Marks Per Game 4.1
1.8 Goals Per Game 1.2
1.0 Behinds Per Game 1.0
1.6 Tackles Per Game 1.9
0 Hitouts Per Game 0
0.8 Frees For Per Game 1.2
0.4 Frees Against Per Game 0.5

 

[Wizard]

Doesnt hurt Gunstons cause that he got to play 2nd, 3rd and sometimes 4th string in his career thus far meaning he never gets the best and rarely the 2nd best defender.
At Adelaide he was behind Walker, Tippet and sometimes Henderson and now behind Buddy, Rough, Hale and somewhat Bruest.

While at Sydney who does Reid have to support him? White, Pyke, LRT? Occasionally Goodes provides a little help but generally when you play the Swans your number 1 goes to Reid. Doesnt happen with Gunston.

 

[raymagoo]

Doesnt hurt Gunstons cause that he got to play 2nd, 3rd and sometimes 4th string in his career thus far meaning he never gets the best and rarely the 2nd best defender.
At Adelaide he was behind Walker, Tippet and sometimes Henderson and now behind Buddy, Rough, Hale and somewhat Bruest.

While at Sydney who does Reid have to support him? White, Pyke, LRT? Occasionally Goodes provides a little help but generally when you play the Swans your number 1 goes to Reid. Doesnt happen with Gunston.

exactly why i picked reid! the gunt is currently the best but gets it a bit easier IMO

 

[MiloStedman]

If Reid can get his kick down, it'll be him. Faster, stronger, makes better leads. I'll back him to get his kick going, so I'll say Reid. Not too sure what Butcher's doing here. Not quite on the level of the other two

 

[detox]

exactly why i picked reid! the gunt is currently the best but gets it a bit easier IMO

Lol @ the gunt

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Would absolutely love to see what Reid could do playing second string

 

[Neville Bartos]

Gunston was practically first-string for 6 weeks while Buddy was injured and Roughead backed up the ruckman...

He did ok!

FWIW, Reid > Gunston > > > > Butcher

 

[bombermick]

Norman slightly behind Reid. Butcher will one of those players that will almost always be injured, sadly.

 

[Schulzenfest]

Bigfooty has the memory span of a goldfish.