scarlett vs ruttern

[geelong_crazy26]

who is the better player ?

 

[Big Nasty]

Geez your bloody insulting Scarlett they're mate.
Rutten definately not in the same class.

 

[relapse]

Who is this "Ruttern" that you speak of ???

 

[LemmingMaster]

Scarlett is by far the best fullback playing at the moment.

I think he may even come close to knocking off SOS as the best ever.

 

[Last Line Hero]

Joke thread.

We are talking about a bloke, the first whom we can compare with Silvagni, up against a lumbering pretender.

 

[Chief Crow]

Joke thread.

We are talking about a bloke, the first whom we can compare with Silvagni, up against a lumbering pretender.

Your comment is a joke. Both are excellent full backs

 

[Power King]

in my opinion, rutten is better at one on one contests - and i'm a port supporter

having said that, ill vote scarlett, because he is great at ground level for a full back, also great at clearing the last line, and ain't to shabby at one on ones either haha

so as a player - scarlett

as a one on one fullback - rutten

 

[geelong_crazy26]

Scarlett is by far the best fullback playing at the moment.

I think he may even come close to knocking off SOS as the best ever.

if he keeps going the way he is going than he will knock SOS off

 

[geelong_crazy26]

in my opinion, rutten is better at one on one contests - and i'm a port supporter

having said that, ill vote scarlett, because he is great at ground level for a full back, also great at clearing the last line, and ain't to shabby at one on ones either haha

so as a player - scarlett

as a one on one fullback - rutten

a few say that but i am not sure where they get that from, Scarlett rarely gets beaten one on one

 

[Southerntakeover]

Ive never seen Ruttern play...

 

[Southerntakeover]

Joke thread.

We are talking about a bloke, the first whom we can compare with Silvagni, up against a lumbering pretender.

Are you using your imaginary stats again?

 

[Last Line Hero]

Are you using your imaginary stats again?

No just general form, skill, playing ability, defensive ability etc, etc, etc.

 

[Carn Hawkas]

Definetly Scarlett.

 

[anti.]

Definetly Glass.

 

[Last Line Hero]

Definetly Glass.

BAHA...

No two year flash in the pans who only play well when their team does thank- you.

Ever notice how there is more of a similarity between Darren Gaspar and Darren Glass than just their first names and initials.

 

[Skeppersap]

The one thing I can say for certain is that so far 6 Adelaide supporters have voted.

 

[El_Scorcho]

I hate the Crows, but I think Rutten is a better one on one defender. Scarlett may be able to provide better run, but if I had to pick on i'd take Rutten first.

A Geelong fans starts a thread about who is better out of one of their players, and an opposition player, and the rest of the Geelong fans precede to have a go at anyone who votes against their man. Well done idiots. There isn't much between the two players at all.

 

[Niximus]

Well I'm not sure how good Ruttern is as I've never seen him play or even heard of him. Who does he play for?

 

[hellfire]

Scarlett is by far the best fullback playing at the moment.

I think he may even come close to knocking off SOS as the best ever.

Great post there mate, it's almost as if you read the paper yesterday.

Scarlett for me.

 

[Schmick]

Scarlett, Better all round game.

 

[P.A.F.C]

Scarlett, but not by much. I think Rutten will be taking a back seat to Bock in the next few years as he doesn't have the pace to go with the Franklin and Fevola types who will be the most dangerous forwards for quite a while. He'll still do good jobs on Tredrea though

 

[jazz]

who is the better player ?

Looking for more Scarlett adulation GC26?

I might as well start a "Who's Better, Franklin or Gamble" thread. The gap is so large as to be stupid.

 

[HighettBomber]

Not even close, Rutten is a good ordinary player and Scarlett is a star

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Scarlett = Jack Regan

Rutten = Steve Silvagni

So Scarlett is better.

 

[Thunderstruck]

Geez spell it properly you gimp

Very close contest, I am a crows fan here, Rutten is better one on one and has a better record against the big, strong and muscular power forwards such as Brown, Gehrig and Tredrea. Scarlett is better at nullifying an opponent and attacking so creates a bit more all round damage. Rutten is the better pure full back for stopping (and yes he does create some run too) but Scarlett overall is pretty damn good. Has a yard more pace as well. I'd take both...but Scarlett by a nose.