Scott Pendlebury or Michael Rischitelli

[Hollow Knight]

Which young midfield gun would you prefer in your team?

 

[FlamingDon]

Well there both doing great jobs at there own clubs so if I were either Brisbane or Collingwood I would pick our player.

 

[DapperDon]

nice poll,

I can't actually choose between them as both have heaps of upside. Both players welcome at Bomberland anytime.

 

[Ron]

Haven't watched many Brissie games so not sure how well now Rischitelli has been going, but i am more than impressed by Penders.
Going to be a star, and is more than capable atm.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I think this is a fantastic comparison, as both look to be tremendous talents and have a good head on their shoulders.

Can't split them.

 

[Hollow Knight]

I think this is a fantastic comparison, as both look to be tremendous talents and have a good head on their shoulders.

Can't split them.

It's funny, because I did a poll comparing Jed Adcock to Heath Shaw and got similar comments.

We've both got a pair of similar young players.

For the record, I chose Rischitelli in this poll because he is just a little harder at the ball and a fraction composed in traffic at this stage, keep in mind he's got a year or two on Pendles though. Both are going to be future marquee players in the competition.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Hardness at the ball is the area I criticize Pendlebury about most, although he has improved this year. Last year in particular, he sometimes sat back and waited for the ball to get to him, rather than closing the gap and making the ball his own.

The obvious advantage he has over Rischa is the physical dimensions, he could eventually play key position, which you would expect Rischitelli would be pretty unlikely to do. Having said that, our obvious need is in midfield, so I'd be happy for him to stay there.

Looking forward to seeing how their careers pan out, and congrats to the Lions for finding Rischitelli later in the draft

 

[andypie]

Which young midfield gun would you prefer in your team?

havnt seen much of your bloke so i can only vote on my allegiance.
what number was richitelli drafted?

 

[Jabso]

I think Pendles is in our top 5 for hardball gets so far. I just looked it up and saw Rischitelli was a 4th year player, I thought he'd be a 3rd year at the most but oh well. H.Shaw is also in his 4th year which suprises most people.

Rischitelli was an absolute bargain at pick 60 odd.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Pendles seems to be such an ideal player with a bit of pace, silky skills and poise way beyond his years.

 

[Hollow Knight]

Rischitelli seems to be such an ideal player with a bit of pace, silky skills and poise way beyond his years.

 

[Ysaye]

Both good young players, but Pendlebury impresses me more.

 

[don vito of fitzroy]

Rischitelli seems to be better at grabbing possessions and tackling but Pendlebury looks like a better goalscorer.

 

[scott522]

Rischi - though Pendlebury is a star in the making...

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Bit of an unfair comparison. Rischitelli is more ready made and a year older. Right now he's better but in 4-5 years Pendlebury's class will shine and he'll be considered better.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

I think Pendles is in our top 5 for hardball gets so far. I just looked it up and saw Rischitelli was a 4th year player

4th year player compared to a 2nd year player

 

[Hollow Knight]

4th year player compared to a 2nd year player

Take it as a compliment that a second year player on your team is getting compared to a 4th year player.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Take it as a compliment that a second year player on your team is getting compared to a 4th year player.

I dont need reassurance that Pendlebury is a gun.

 

[Hollow Knight]

I dont need reassurance that Pendlebury is a gun.

Then stop sooking.

 

[Pancakes]

Oh goodie yet another BrownDog "quick quick look at our youngsters circlejerk thread"
They are getting pretty predictable and boring, no one gives a shit about your overrated list of hacks at the bears, so please stop bringing them up every single time you post.

And for what its worth even though Pendlebury has been playing for two less years he is streets ahead of Brisbane youngster.

 

[don vito of fitzroy]

Oh goodie yet another BrownDog "quick quick look at our youngsters circlejerk thread"
They are getting pretty predictable and boring, no one gives a shit about your overrated list of hacks at the bears, so please stop bringing them up every single time you post.

That's wquite ironic considering that Kerr likes to whack opposition players in the testicles.

 

[anzacs]

Which young midfield gun would you prefer in your team?

Pendles 2 years younger and barely played the game as a junior.. far more upside in him

This is only his 3rd or 4th year of football at any level

Ridiculous comparison

 

[Richo83]

Which young midfield gun would you prefer in your team?

Said before, but great poll. This is the polls we need, not Cornes V Stanton.

Rischitelli for mine. He's doing a bit more in a midfield that is a lot more competitive to get into, Brisbane have Black and Power and Pendlebury doesn't have those players to compete with.

But I'd have either at my club in a heartbeat.

 

[wce4premiership]

not that we need more midfielders but i would like rischitelli

 

[doppleganger]

Rischitelli seems to be such an ideal player with a bit of pace, silky skills and poise way beyond his years.

silky skills???

his disposal often lets him down, the one thing rischitelli needs to work on the most

pendles has nothing really to work on, he will hopefully keep developing as he plays more games, has absolutely no weaknesses