Preview The No Changes Thread: Crows v Saints, Sun May 14th, 12:40pm

Who should be the sub this week?

  • Crouch (again)

    Votes: 6 18.8%
  • Himmelberg

    Votes: 1 3.1%
  • Borlase

    Votes: 3 9.4%
  • Gollant

    Votes: 2 6.3%
  • Strachan

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Keane

    Votes: 1 3.1%
  • Dawson

    Votes: 11 34.4%
  • Thilthorpe

    Votes: 2 6.3%
  • Brown

    Votes: 4 12.5%
  • O'Brien

    Votes: 2 6.3%

  • Total voters
    32

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Thilthorpe isn't going to survive selection, he's been poor for a month, and just got thrashed by Blicavs, playing bruise free football of the Brad Moran type. I strongly expect him to be dropped for Himmelberg
 
Out: Murray (inj), Sholl (weak as piss), Keays (completely devoid of any skill), Milera (not an AFL player), Crouch (has played his last game for the club)

In: Worrell, Hamill, Berry, Parnell

Sub: Cook

Thilthorpe is extremely lucky that Himmelberg shat the bed in the SANFL.
 
Out: Murray (concussion), Milera, Sholl, Keays, Thilthorpe
In: Worrell, Parnell, Cook, Berry, Gollant

Crouch to never be the sub and never play ever again

Murray, Milera and Sholl are correct. Keays needs to stick to lockdown roles.

But Crouch? Just busting up on an easy target that actually played well. Irrational hatred dilutes your posts.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Out: Murray (concussion), Milera, Sholl, Keays, Thilthorpe
In: Worrell, Parnell, Cook, Berry, Gollant

Crouch to never be the sub and never play ever again
Milera, Keays guaranteed vs Saints. I agree re: Crouch, awful.

What I fear most is Crouch retained.
 
Murray, Milera and Sholl are correct. Keays needs to stick to lockdown roles.

But Crouch? Just busting up on an easy target that actually played well. Irrational hatred dilutes your posts.
He had a grand total of 2 kicks, and 3 contested possessions in a half, playing as an inside mid against a side missing their best inside mid.

He also butchered multiple simple handballs, and had minus 16m gained.

Edit: he also had a grand total of 1 clearance.
 
Out: Murray (inj), Sholl (weak as piss), Keays (completely devoid of any skill), Milera (not an AFL player), Crouch (has played his last game for the club)

In: Worrell, Hamill, Berry, Parnell

Sub: Cook

Thilthorpe is extremely lucky that Himmelberg shat the bed in the SANFL.
Gollant can come in for thillthorpe
 
Double-dribble:
Thilthorpe isn't going to survive selection, he's been poor for a month, and just got thrashed by Blicavs, playing bruise free football of the Brad Moran type. I strongly expect him to be dropped for Himmelberg
Possibly the worst pick 1 ?
You two are equivalently over-reactive.

Thilthorpe is a work in progress and needs exposure to games like today and next week.
 
He had a grand total of 2 kicks, and 3 contested possessions in a half, playing as an inside mid against a side missing their best inside mid.

He also butchered multiple simple handballs, and had minus 16m gained.

Edit: he also had a grand total of 1 clearance.

The -16m gained sums him up perfectly.
 
Some knocking in the SANFL so you expect to pick them but given it's was a close game like against Collingwood, I suspect it will be Worell for Murray.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #22
Edit: he also had a grand total of 1 clearance.
And that was the one he missed a wide open Murphy by an absolute mile with a simple handball and created another stoppage
 
Patently untrue. Overreactive nonsense.

I agree that Milera should be dropped; shouldn't have been out there today.

Both will be retained vs Saints. Coaches love'em.
Milera played with more urgency today but he will be back to his laconic usual self next week.
 
Back
Top