Riders of Rohan
Club Legend
Hope you guys get Seaby, as a number one ruckman he's fantastic, struggled as a backup however once Mumford overtook him when he was injured last year.
Trades/Delistings/Recruitment Part 3
- Thread starter tigs2010
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
nikolasmia
Senior List
Has been rumoured Port are interested.
- Aug 8, 2009
- 9,787
- 11,153
- AFL Club
- Richmond
I have said all along I would be going for Seaby ahead of Maric. Would have been Sydneys number 1 ruck but Mumford turned into a jet.
I would imagine Sydney would be alot easier to deal with as well.
I would imagine Sydney would be alot easier to deal with as well.
Toadvine
17?19?
- Feb 29, 2008
- 8,296
- 14,707
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Baltimore Ravens
Craig Cameron will be on Trade Week Radio sometime after 3pm.
Someone listen out and give us all a run down on what he has to say.
Someone listen out and give us all a run down on what he has to say.
Nah mate... it's a totally different scenario
They have a few they're interested in - makes sense, seeing as it can be relatively difficult to get trades through, so no point putting all eggs in one basket.
Griffin and Renouf are the other two that have been mentioned in relation to Port BTW. Are either seen as better options than Maric, or are we left choosing between 2nd string rucks who can't get games at their respective clubs (as opposed to genuine 1st rucks who just happen to be kept out by out and out guns?)
Port said on trade week radio that they spoke to Ivan but he indicated that he wants to come to Tigerland and they respect that so havent spoken to Adelaide about him! they're more into Griffin and would prefer to develope Lobbe instead of bring Maric in to hold him back!
Let's be honest, it's been pretty poor drafting with the only ruckman on our list 2 ex-rookie list players and a speculative pick #63. No wonder we're in this position.
Did we delist Vickery?
We're planning to use Maric in the forward line?
Wacky Tiger
Parmy
Tend to agree. After every draft period we hear that we were interested in this young ruckman and that young ruckman but rarely end up with one. Would like to think that will change now.
hardball01
Debutant
what would people give up for tom gillies? starved of opportunity at geelong. and when you consider how well laidler played this year, i think we should give him an opportunity.
192cm and 89kg, could be solid down back for us.
also jarrad moore from sydney? fallen way down the pecking order at sydney, i think he'd be a good midfielder to throw into our mids, i mean we are probably 3-4 mids short. loves winning the contested footy.
thoughts?
192cm and 89kg, could be solid down back for us.
also jarrad moore from sydney? fallen way down the pecking order at sydney, i think he'd be a good midfielder to throw into our mids, i mean we are probably 3-4 mids short. loves winning the contested footy.
thoughts?
- Banned
- #967
Would love Tom Gillies Cats arnt known for asking alot for there fringe players. Only young type of player we need shown some good signs and has developed under some of the best coaches in the leaugue and one of the AFL's greatest full backs of all time in Scarlett.
I used to think Seaby was a dud, but I am starting to think you are correct. He was a very good tap Ruckman just useless around the ground (upgrade on Graham as he is just useless).
Would spew if we caved into Adelaide just because we need a Ruckman. I would have told Adelaide to stick it yesterday and walked out, the fact we are continuing talks has me slightly concerned.
hardball01
Debutant
when seaby played against us he tore us a new one, scored about 150 supercoach points. has always played second fiddle though, michael gardiner at west coast and now behind mumford at sydney. surely he'd be starving for a first ruck role?
tigersno1fan
Draftee
you serious? gillies is a replacement for Matthew Scarlett for when he retires at the end of 2012, he would cost more than you think. cause the Cats said he's a required player and he's also Contracted
DeepThroat007
Team Captain
- Jul 1, 2006
- 391
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Ivan Maric should be a tiger by lunch time tomorrow, we could have another trade done by then as well.
Maric to Tigers. Geez, big call there DT. I dunno about that one.
- Thread starter
- #973
Which would be? Player coming in or going out? And do u know what is agreed on the Maric deal?
- Banned
- #974
you cant compare what ruckmen did against us when Browne was rucking dude.
Its what Seaby did against actual ruckmen, like Griggs that matters..
But seriously I hope the brains trust look beyond what ruckmen did against us, when assessing their worth.
DeepThroat007
Team Captain
- Jul 1, 2006
- 391
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Did I say i was breaking news, re read what I wrote! By lunch time tomorrow. The 2nd trade could be the influencing factor on what we give crows for.
It could be Luke M with our pick 55 for lions pick 30 something then we trade that pick to crows, but I'm only summizing could be way of. I M should be a tiger by tomorrow.
- Status
