McGuire has done her dash I think, just cannot get fit enough or mobile enough, but has talent.
I think Pisconeri is a good state league player, but not up to AFLW standard as a ruck. Not mobile, and not tall enough to compensate. Either needed to be more athletic, or 3 inches taller.
Bartlett I feel sorry for, is a good player of a type not seen much in AFLW, but never got a look in. I think she is ambitious though, and may be back.
Bonser is good enough I think.
Personally I would be looking at Bonser and Bartlett again, depending on WAFLW form.
I think Pisconeri is a good state league player, but not up to AFLW standard as a ruck. Not mobile, and not tall enough to compensate. Either needed to be more athletic, or 3 inches taller.
Bartlett I feel sorry for, is a good player of a type not seen much in AFLW, but never got a look in. I think she is ambitious though, and may be back.
Bonser is good enough I think.
Personally I would be looking at Bonser and Bartlett again, depending on WAFLW form.