Once again, a tall will come in for Gibcus.
Player Watch Welcome - James Trezise - 2023 VFL B&F Winner
- Thread starter _RT_
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Once again, a tall will come in for Gibcus.
Gibcus comes over the top and does a lot of pack spoiling, ask his knee. Trezise can't do that but he is good in the air so Broad and Grimes, who were both much better last night, might have to play taller. It will only be for a week as Miller will come in for Young and hopefully stay in as the Gibcus replacement. Was close to best on in the VFL, not that he was up against much.
rfctigerarmy
🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆
lizard man
All Australian
- May 27, 2023
- 857
- 1,415
- AFL Club
- Richmond
So does this guy have a pretty high chance of playing this week in the seniors?
Its either him or Brown imo.
lizard man
All Australian
- May 27, 2023
- 857
- 1,415
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Yeah I agree with that … I’m gonna go with Trezise as my guess
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
If Yze is true to his word that he wants players with elite foot skills, Trezise might struggle to make the team. With that in mind, I think Brown plays.
He kicked it beautifully on the weekend.
I'd love to see him play half forward if it means both Brown and trezise get a game in the ones.
What are you talking about? Tresize is a very good kick
- Mar 9, 2014
- 1,436
- 2,942
- AFL Club
- Richmond
How do people think trezise is ahead of brown in the pecking order? Brown played in the seniors all pre season and has been emergency both games. He’s obviously ahead of trezise in yze’s mind atm.
Last edited:
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
He doesnt usually kick it well, thats the knock on him
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
No he's not
Watching the VFL last week I'd have Trezise over Brown at the moment. Brown started like a house on fire, but he doesn't seem to have that hard edge that Trezise has, he sort of floats around a bit. Trezise seems a bit more of a natural backman. I think Brown needs to get a bit more physical.
- Mar 9, 2014
- 1,436
- 2,942
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Oh of course people can have their own opinions… I was more referring to how anyone could think that match committee doesn’t have brown ahead as they obviously currently do
Well it's a week by week thing now that games have started. Preseason's don't mean that much but a general gauge, match form should count for more, not that there is much between the two. Lower draft pics nearly always get preference also.
Over stated I reckon. Big step up from country footy to VFL, took some time to settle in.
I tend to agree.
Not sure what it is about Brown, but he seems to me like a guy that would benefit from a soft transition into the Seniors with the system well set up around him.
With no Balta, Gibcus, even Young down back, then Grimes and Broad in questionable form, and Miller likely to be our main defender for the first time ever, I feel that Trezise would cope better with what could be a "thrown to the wolves" type role against the Port forward line.
hope he is in instead of brown- harder edge gonna be needed with our bl under the pump
Kicking wasn't Trezise's strength even at country footy level. No doubt as a full time footballer he should be improving his disposal skills.
His aerial presence and tackling seem first class. I am quietly confident he will be a 100+ gamer for us, but not shocked if his kicking is a bit dodgy for AFL level at least in the early days.
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
Mate we even saw his kicking last year in the AFL was shaky at best.
We cant even shaky kicks coming out of D50 IMO.
I agree with you earlier, HFF, great marking and tackling ability with some nice speed.
Thing is then do you recruit Broad, Grimes, Rance, and plenty of others who were cornerstones in our great teams? Players can improve their disposal over time. Kicking is ultimately crucial but we don't want to start recruiting a lot of soft players who can kick but have other deficiencies.
Similar threads
- Locked
