Which player is/was better?

[captain subtext]

Who would you rather on your list, a young Wayne Carey or a Young Dustin Fletcher?

 

[Upgrayedd]

Carey. No brainer

 

[SouthSwans]

Carey. No brainer

Anyone who doesn't vote this way is either dumb or blind.

 

[Claude Balls]

Who would you rather on your list, a young Wayne Carey or a Young Dustin Fletcher?

If you were an essendon supporter I would understand why this poll is in existence. But you're not, so why are you asking such a stupid question?

Carey by the length of the Nile

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

carey 4 sure

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Stupid poll. Carey easily.

 

[captain subtext]

If you were an essendon supporter I would understand why this poll is in existence. But you're not, so why are you asking such a stupid question?

Carey by the length of the Nile

Because of this in another thread

Aint they 2 totally different type of players though in different positions ? Isnt this just like saying who is better ? Carey or Dustin Fletcher ?

Thought I'd ask the question because I thought there was a definitive answer.

 

[GYNO]

Melbourne supporters = Useless threads

 

[Claude Balls]

Because of this in another thread


Thought I'd ask the question because I thought there was a definitive answer.

Fair enough. You will now have to alert MrAaron to your clever debating tactics.

 

[captain subtext]

Fair enough. You will now have to alert MrAaron to your clever debating tactics.

Not clever at all, just being an idiot.

 

[Kings Army]

Because of this in another thread


Thought I'd ask the question because I thought there was a definitive answer.

I did not think anyone was debating Carey V Fletcher on the Rivers Fletcher poll?

This is so one side - worse than the Grant V Johnson poll!

 

[drew_j]

Carey>>>>Daylight>>>>>>Darkness>>>>>apha>>>>omega>>>>>Fletch

 

[Hawkamania!]

Carey. However I would ban him from using a bathroom without a club minder present (his teammates would thank me).

 

[nossi5]

Who would you rather on your list, a young Wayne Carey or a Young Dustin Fletcher?

Are you f**king joking? How could you put them in the same sentence.

Carey by the length of flemington straight. (if not more)

 

[Richo83]

Because of this in another thread


Thought I'd ask the question because I thought there was a definitive answer.

Don't listen to MrAaron, he's a grade A tool.

Carey is one of if not the best players ever. Fletcher isn't even the best defender of his era (Silvagni and Jacovich were in my opinion superior, Steven definitely).

 

[clackas]

Stupid poll. Carey easily.

Agree

 

[DapperDon]

pffttttt..... Fletcher easily.





































we are talking about who you'd rather leave your girlfriend alone in a room with, yeah?

 

[catman2006]

Carey by a country mile silly poll.

 

[Jeremias]

MrAaron is a moron, the quicker you learn that the better.

Carey by so much that it ain't even funny.

 

[sarah.13]

Compare Carey to Ablett or Mathews not to MR Gajet

 

[captain subtext]

Compare Carey to Ablett or Mathews not to MR Gajet

That's a good idea, would someone start a poll?

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Wow, it's gone from 20-0 to 46-2.

I wonder who the 2 are?

 

[topdon]

Stupid poll. Defenders never get accolades, no matter how good they are. In 1993, Fletcher was a Premiership full-back in a year when he was still doing his VCE and playing school footy for Essendon Grammar (his dad Ken was the coach). A lot for a young boy to have on his plate.

Carey was the youngest captain ever and had attacking talent in spades.

Carey was a phenomenon.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Being second to Carey is no shame. Unless it's in a nice-guy competition.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Wow, it's gone from 20-0 to 46-2.

I wonder who the 2 are?

Trolls