Ins & Outs vs West Coast.

[BomberAce7]

In - Nil
Out - Nil
Unchanged.

A number of players tonight had little impact (Bellchambers, Myers, Pears, Reimers e.t.c) but keep playing them imo. Unless Dustin doesnt come up bring in Mal?

 

[bomberbill22]

In - Nil
Out - Nil
Unchanged.

A number of players tonight had little impact (Bellchambers, Myers, Pears e.t.c) but keep playing them imo. Unless Dustin doesnt come up bring in Mal?

Myers killed it

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Out- McPhee
In- Gumbleton

McPhee was dead set horrid

 

[S.C[BANKS]]

Myers killed it you downer

Myers played well (considering his experience).

OUT - Bellchambers, Flecther, Lloyd
IN - Watson, Neagle, Micheal

 

[LukeParkerno1]

If you drop Bellchambers, and I am not saying yes or no, Laycock has to come in as WC have a good set of ruckmen. Ryder against Cox will be laughable in the ruck!

 

[bomberstomake8]

Out- McPhee
In- Gumbleton

McPhee was dead set horrid

your dead set horrid
he was not as clean as he should have been but was still solid. a number of player should be dropped instead of him.
he cops a lot of unfair cristisism from people like you who obviously dont realise how much he contributes

for my ins and outs

outs: bellchambers, fletcher (if injured)
ins: laycock, mal (if fletcher is injured)

 

[Sigmund]

In - Nil
Out - Nil
Unchanged.

A number of players tonight had little impact (Bellchambers, Myers, Pears e.t.c) but keep playing them imo. Unless Dustin doesnt come up bring in Mal?

ACE7 - can not agree with you at all here. Myers was solid - not brilliant but solid. I felt Pears also fell in this category. He is very sure in 1:1 situations and kept Boyle very quiet. I thought it was probably his best game so far.

Love to see Neagle come back if fit.. Not sure on Gumby - see how his body is going. Maybe one more at VFL level.

People will probably get on Jetta's case- perhaps rightly so. One stat was that all of his 5 possies were inside 50's - second most in the team.. I would keep playing him.

 

[Sigmund]

your dead set horrid
he was not as clean as he should have been but was still solid. a number of player should be dropped instead of him.
he cops a lot of unfair cristisism from people like you who obviously dont realise how much he contributes

for my ins and outs

outs: bellchambers, fletcher (if injured)
ins: laycock, mal (if fletcher is injured)

Spot on I can not understand why he cops so much. He is one of the guys who gives a consistent effort (not always form) every week.

 

[bomberstomake8]

Myers played well (considering his experience).

OUT - Bellchambers, Flecther, Lloyd
IN - Watson, Neagle, Micheal

once again unfair critisism on lloyd
can someone find the number of times we actually went inside 50, better yet the times we went inside 50 and kicked it to lloyd

there was not much that lloyd coul dhave done tonight he simply didnt get it kicked to him.

 

[bomberbill22]

ACE7 - can not agree with you at all here. Myers was solid - not brilliant but solid. I felt Pears also fell in this category. He is very sure in 1:1 situations and kept Boyle very quiet. I thought it was probably his best game so far.

Love to see Neagle come back if fit.. Not sure on Gumby - see how his body is going. Maybe one more at VFL level.

People will probably get on Jetta's case- perhaps rightly so. One stat was that all of his 5 possies were inside 50's - second most in the team.. I would keep playing him.

send Jetta back to the WAFL he is useless.

 

[Blind Blink]

Yeh I reckon Gumby needs at least 2 in the VFL.

 

[Sigmund]

Myers played well (considering his experience).

OUT - Bellchambers, Flecther, Lloyd
IN - Watson, Neagle, Micheal

Never ever going to happen - never

 

[S.C[BANKS]]

If you drop Bellchambers, and I am not saying yes or no, Laycock has to come in as WC have a good set of ruckmen. Ryder against Cox will be laughable in the ruck!

Them let him learn. Besides Hille will do 80% of that ruck work anyway.

 

[BomberAce7]

ACE7 - can not agree with you at all here. Myers was solid - not brilliant but solid. I felt Pears also fell in this category. He is very sure in 1:1 situations and kept Boyle very quiet. I thought it was probably his best game so far.

Love to see Neagle come back if fit.. Not sure on Gumby - see how his body is going. Maybe one more at VFL level.

People will probably get on Jetta's case- perhaps rightly so. One stat was that all of his 5 possies were inside 50's - second most in the team.. I would keep playing him.

The players i mentioned didnt have much impact on the game really. Like i said i dont want any of them omitted. Keep playing them.

 

[bomberstomake8]

ACE7 - can not agree with you at all here. Myers was solid - not brilliant but solid. I felt Pears also fell in this category. He is very sure in 1:1 situations and kept Boyle very quiet. I thought it was probably his best game so far.

Love to see Neagle come back if fit.. Not sure on Gumby - see how his body is going. Maybe one more at VFL level.

People will probably get on Jetta's case- perhaps rightly so. One stat was that all of his 5 possies were inside 50's - second most in the team.. I would keep playing him.

exactly, jetta doesnt get much of it but when he does things happen. and when he doesnt have it he works very hard off the ball... is a must in our side...

 

[Sigmund]

send Jetta back to the WAFL he is useless.

Bill - can see you are passionate my friend but I wonder if you are being a little harsh here. He has played 12 games

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

your dead set horrid
he was not as clean as he should have been but was still solid. a number of player should be dropped instead of him.
he cops a lot of unfair cristisism from people like you who obviously dont realise how much he contributes

Agree. I'm not sure what goes through people's minds when they have a hatred towards a player.

I though McPhee was one of our best in the first half. Was presenting well took a few marks and kicked an important goal.

Got less of it later on and made a few mistakes but you could say that about the whole side.

 

[BomberAce7]

Them let him learn. Besides Hille will do 80% of that ruck work anyway.

Agree.

 

[Sigmund]

The players i mentioned didnt have much impact on the game really. Like i said i dont want any of them omitted. Keep playing them.

Yep

 

[bomberbill22]

Bill - can see you are passionate my friend but I wonder if you are being a little harsh here. He has played 12 games

12 games too many.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

your dead set horrid
he was not as clean as he should have been but was still solid. a number of player should be dropped instead of him.
he cops a lot of unfair cristisism from people like you who obviously dont realise how much he contributes

for my ins and outs

outs: bellchambers, fletcher (if injured)
ins: laycock, mal (if fletcher is injured)

McPhee did nothing all night, why should he be free from criticism. He was ordinary, disposal was poor..and we won't talk about the sitter he missed!

 

[BomberAce7]

McPhee did nothing all night, why should he be free from criticism. He was ordinary, disposal was poor..and we won't talk about the sitter he missed!

Monfries' sitter was as bad too!

 

[THOMO_31]

12 games too many.

goose

 

[Merv]

Out- McPhee
In- Gumbleton

McPhee was dead set horrid

Just when i thought i had heard it all

 

[THOMO_31]

McPhee did nothing all night, why should he be free from criticism. He was ordinary, disposal was poor..and we won't talk about the sitter he missed!

he dropped one mark, apart from that thought he was alrite. well lucas kicked 3 in 2nd quarter, did he touch it at all for the whole game