didaksrightfoot
Premiership Player
- Sep 12, 2013
- 4,902
- 5,555
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- SA Spurs, Juventus
Unpopular opinion.
Joel Selwood and Sam Mitchell have had better careers than Chris Judd, and were/are better all-round footballers.
Chris Judd is the most overrated midfielder of all-time when people mention him with Carey, Mathews and Ablett as one of the games "Greatest" players.
Albett Snr or Jnr?
If its Snr - I agree... but then I dont think Judd is realistically rated with that lot.
If its Jnr - then No, he definitely deserves to be rated alongside him.
You are grossly overating Selwood - and Mitchell I think deserves to be in the conversation with Judd and GAJ given his better longevity. All of Swan, Fyfe, Danger and Martin were/are also in that range at their peaks.
Selwood is a rung (2?) below those guys. Probably similar to Pendles - both very good players who are each missing some all round characteristics that keep them from that group - ironically though both would probably complement each other extremely well if on the same team.