List Mgmt. Trade & F/A - 2018/2019 - Part 3

[TradeDraft]

Well Crocker is contracted so they can't just delist him. Crocker may well get delisted next year but that's not just "being tough on McLarty," that's when the contracts expire.

Massive Mistake.

McLarty is way better then Crocker

 

[MagpieJoel]

Have I missed something?

Has he been delisted?

No idea.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Massive Mistake.

McLarty is way better then Crocker

I'm not disputing that, I'm saying that the reason why McLarty would be delisted before Crocker is due to the simple fact of when contracts expire, not because the club rates Crocker higher.

 

[CFC2010]

Seems to be the word.

Reckon it’s tough on him when spuds like Crocker are still on the list.

Weird decision if true.

 

[dansa]

But pick 18 is an unknown player, as is the second round pick next year.

We have a known player and we know what we are giving up. You can't have it both ways.

Yeah I'll tell you what is known. He's probably got 1 year left at elite, 1 year of good-very good and hopefully a 3rd year that is battling. That's the likely senario.

He's also more likely to miss periods with soft tissue injuries as he approaches and passes 30yrs.

We also know that Brisbane need to get this trade done asap because they have promised Neale they will get it done.

We don't need to give in.

 

[MagpieJoel]

Yeah I'll tell you what is known. He's probably got 1 year left at elite, 1 year of good-very good and hopefully a 3rd year that is battling. That's the likely senario.

You can tell the future?

 

[Crazy Tails]

I’m still trying to understand how we went from “Collingwood players have been told May is coming” to not even being in the conversation.

The only thing I can think of is that the Dayne Beams deal became more of a priority to the powers that be.

 

[unplugged]

Rumours circulating that the Monopoly Deal has got even more crazy!

Gold Coast
Gain: T Phillips, Coll 2019 First
Lose: S May

Collingwood
Gain: D Beams, S May, 11
Lose: 18, 2019 First, T Phillips, J Thomas

Melbourne
Gain: 5, 18
Lose: J Hogan

Fremantle
Gain: J Hogan
Lose: L Neale, 11

Brisbane
Gain: L Neale, J Thomas
Lose: D Beams, 5



Then we chase Jack Lonie as small forward depth

 

[BEEG]

Rumours circulating that the Monopoly Deal has got even more crazy!

Gold Coast
Gain: T Phillips, Coll 2019 First
Lose: S May

Collingwood
Gain: D Beams, S May, 11
Lose: 18, 2019 First, T Phillips, J Thomas

Melbourne
Gain: 5, 18
Lose: J Hogan

Fremantle
Gain: J Hogan
Lose: L Neale, 11

Brisbane
Gain: L Neale, J Thomas
Lose: D Beams, 5



Then we chase Jack Lonie as small forward depth

Couldn't fit Bruce in the trade?

 

[MoreMoore]

Let’s make a late play For Peter Wright!

4th round future

 

[unplugged]

Couldn't fit Bruce in the trade?

Pick 75 for Bruce and Lonie?

 

[MightyRoar]

From reading all the reports it makes mention that where not too keen on giving up 2 firsts, so I hope to hell this is true and we don't as we see Beams as a bonus and not a need.

 

[hellfire]

Rumours circulating that the Monopoly Deal has got even more crazy!

Gold Coast
Gain: T Phillips, Coll 2019 First
Lose: S May

Collingwood
Gain: D Beams, S May, 11
Lose: 18, 2019 First, T Phillips, J Thomas

Melbourne
Gain: 5, 18
Lose: J Hogan

Fremantle
Gain: J Hogan
Lose: L Neale, 11

Brisbane
Gain: L Neale, J Thomas
Lose: D Beams, 5



Then we chase Jack Lonie as small forward depth

Suns & Lions lose there and the Pies make out like bandits. No chance.

 

[dansa]

You can tell the future?

You do realise that knowing an outcome is more likely than another is not some magical gift of fortune tellers?

There is endless evidence that elite players usually pass their peak around 30. If you want to believe Beams is the exception to the rule, so be it.

 

[TW Sherrin]

Rumours circulating that the Monopoly Deal has got even more crazy!

Gold Coast
Gain: T Phillips, Coll 2019 First
Lose: S May

Collingwood
Gain: D Beams, S May, 11
Lose: 18, 2019 First, T Phillips, J Thomas

Melbourne
Gain: 5, 18
Lose: J Hogan

Fremantle
Gain: J Hogan
Lose: L Neale, 11

Brisbane
Gain: L Neale, J Thomas
Lose: D Beams, 5



Then we chase Jack Lonie as small forward depth

quick get it done before someone changes their mind.

 

[Crazy Tails]

The only thing that will cause up to pay massive overs for Beams is if the Lions and Dockers can orchestrate a move on Neale that cuts our pick 18 out of the equation.

Can't see that happening myself but if they did then we should be straight on the phone to Stephen May and see if we can tempt the Suns with 2 x firsts (2018 and 2019) with some nice picks coming back. Let Beams go if the price is too high (2 firsts and nothing back). Lions can deal with his apparent "Bulltish" for another year or two.

 

[unplugged]

Suns & Lions lose there and the Pies make out like bandits. No chance.

The whole idea of the trade period is for us to win and everyone else to lose out horribly...

 

[BEEG]

Pick 75 for Bruce and Lonie?

Take that, very unlike Collingwood to get such a cheap deal going our way.

 

[unplugged]

Reality is that worst case scenario we lose two first rounders for Beams without losing any players other than Fasolo.

Any other trades, or paying less than the above, is a bonus for mine.

Better than Richmond which lost about 6 players (one of which was best 22) for one player.

 

[MagpieJoel]

You do realise that knowing an outcome is more likely than another is not some magical gift of fortune tellers?

There is endless evidence that elite players usually pass their peak around 30. If you want to believe Beams is the exception to the rule, so be it.

The point is that you don't really know what's going to happen. It's an unknown at this stage how his body will go. Yes he will have less impact over time.

You can only properly judge a trade retrospectively.

 

[unplugged]

Take that, very unlike Collingwood to get such a cheap deal going our way.

Haha we know that deal won't happen. I'd be very surprised if we got Bruce. Seems like the type of player which isn't actually that good but would be expensive.

 

[Thefly38]

You can tell the future?

Lol I would say 1- 2 elite , 1- 2 very good

 

[Dynamics]

The club literally just released social media material with Josh Thomas saying he was really happy to sign for 3 years and have stability at the club.

He's not leaving.

 

[Jen2310]

 

[unplugged]

The club literally just released social media material with Josh Thomas saying he was really happy to sign for 3 years and have stability at the club.

He's not leaving.

Or is he! Maybe we want him to appear as a required player