Josh Caddy - The one that got away

[Skeppersap]

He wasn't alone 21 other Tigers stank up the MCG.

He has a premiership medal, while your other high profile recruits like Dangerfield and Ablett (since he returned . Not counting the 2000's era) are yet to win one......

Why do you not count the '2000s era'? Because it suits your agenda?

 

[TEDDY24INC]

Struggles when his side isn’t on top. Have yet to see him do anything significant when his side is down

In fairness, played a heck of a cameo when subbed on in the 2013 prelim

 

[TEDDY24INC]

Why do you not count the '2000s era'? Because it suits your agenda?

He’s a tool, move along

 

[Xtreme]

Why do you not count the '2000s era'? Because it suits your agenda?

Because he hasn't won one under the Scott regime

Caddy has only blossomed since being set free of the shackles of the Geelong Football Club.

 

[tazaa]

He was good tonight







For Collingwood

 

[mike123]

In fairness, played a heck of a cameo when subbed on in the 2013 prelim

Kicked a nice goal iirc

 

[Skeppersap]

Missed the first half... Was he lippy like he has been lately??

 

[Cicatriz]

His first half of the year was great, second half was average. There was a big drop off. He averaged 19 possessions and 3 goals per game in the first half of the year and 14.8 and 1.5 in the last 13 games.
Could it be that he was a flash in the pan?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[tigertigertiger]

worst I've seen him play last night

 

[Jonno94]

Had a poor game but laying into a bloke that kicked 46 goals for the season, really?

 

[giggler99]

Because he hasn't won one under the Scott regime

Caddy has only blossomed since being set free of the shackles of the Geelong Football Club.

lol Caddy has been no different at Richmand than when he was at Geelong. He still only has three to four standout games per season. Just an average good player will never be anything more despite winning a premiership medal.

 

[Off The Couch]

Missed the first half... Was he lippy like he has been lately??

He also missed the first half so he didn’t get the opportunity to get mouthy.

He’s a front runner, pure and simple

 

[DrEvil_]

Shown up to be the downhill skier that he is. Jack stood up, Caddy went Leon Davies.

 

[DrEvil_]

Does he have to give his premiership medal back ?

He has to give it to Bob Murphy.

 

[SterlingArcher]

lol Caddy has been no different at Richmand than when he was at Geelong. He still only has three to four standout games per season. Just an average good player will never be anything more despite winning a premiership medal.

Which forwards have more than 3-4 standout games per season?

Caddy kicked 4+ in 6 games this year, had 20+ touches in 4 of them. Had another game of 19 and 3.

Considering the Coleman winner barely averaged 3 goals a game, I`d say those games are all close to standouts.

 

[DanA]

I still think he's the same player he was at Geelong. A good mid-tier player that can cause headaches in the right system and with the right matchup. Richmond is the right setup.

 

[thecatattack]

Which forwards have more than 3-4 standout games per season?

most of the good ones lol

menzel had 3 games of 4+ and another 3 of 3

and he's injury prone as ****

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Has this bloke had his papers stamped yet?

Fooled some people for a while, but continues to show why most Cats fans weren't fussed about him leaving.

 

[Ron The Bear]

Just about done as a winger, and Hardwick won't play him forward. So just about done.

Has two premiership medals to show for his club switch. I'm sure he has no regrets.

 

[Coach_Required]

Has this bloke had his papers stamped yet?

Fooled some people for a while, but continues to show why most Cats fans weren't fussed about him leaving.

Dude, seriously he helped win 2 flags.

Stop trying to fight that it meant nothing, the game does eventually catch up with everyone at some stage

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Has this bloke had his papers stamped yet?

Fooled some people for a while, but continues to show why most Cats fans weren't fussed about him leaving.

Fooled some people?? He was a good player in multiple premiership teams

 

[dean33]

Has this bloke had his papers stamped yet?

Fooled some people for a while, but continues to show why most Cats fans weren't fussed about him leaving.

Probably, still 2 premierships later I’d say it’s been a successful trade for us. Bit too slow for the modern game though unfortunately.

 

[Morro]

Being played out of position.

 

[Xtreme]

Has this bloke had his papers stamped yet?

Fooled some people for a while, but continues to show why most Cats fans weren't fussed about him leaving.

Even if he gets shown the door, he'll have more premiership medals than Patrick Dangerfield and that is a very good story to tell

 

[Sky]

Dude, seriously he helped win 2 flags.

Stop trying to fight that it meant nothing, the game does eventually catch up with everyone at some stage

Don’t worry mate, we have one of those too. His name is Luke Dahlhaus except one flag and not with us.

Even if they accomplished nothing they’ve been in the system for 11 years now so nice bank made even as role players.