The AA team so far this season

[Big Cox]

Would look like

FB: T.Kennelly D.Glass B.Sewell
CHB: D.Fletcher C.Cornes A.McLeod
C: S.Thompson C.Judd J.Bartel
CHF: R.O Keefe S.Lucas G.Ablett
FF M.Pavlich M.Lloyd B.Johnson
R: A.Sandilands D.Kerr S.Black
I/C: N.Malceski D.Wirrpanda H.McIntosh J.Lewis

Scott West VERY unlucky

 

[Kenny Hunter]

Fev wouldn't be in it . Only one good game , where he would get 3 brownlow votes

Lloyd more consistent

 

[raskolnikov]

McPhee would have to be close.

 

[Wizard]

Pavlich FF.

 

[Big Cox]

Fev wouldn't be in it . Only one good game , where he would get 3 brownlow votes

Lloyd more consistent

No FF has really stood out have they. Lloyd hasnt ripped it apart either has he.

 

[The Mongrel Punt]

Fev wouldn't be in it . Only one good game , where he would get 3 brownlow votes

Lloyd more consistent

Yep, was going to add the same thing. Would having McPhee over Kinelly be acceptable?

 

[Impunity!]

Swap R. Jones for A. McLeod

 

[Dagless]

Why not rate how each of the 2006 class of AA have gone them suggest better fillers

 

[quidy]

I think Sandilands has been better then Macintosh somehow.

 

[Big Cox]

Okay seems that Lloyd will be in ahead of Fev then

 

[Wizard]

Okay seems that Lloyd will be in ahead of Fev then

Pav FF easily, thats where he is playing predominently now. He has been better than Fev and Lloyd.

 

[Big Cox]

I think Sandilands has been better then Macintosh somehow.

Nah McIntosh has been more consistent so far this season and has had less help. Awesome player

 

[jo172]

Rutten has done just as much if not more than Glass.

 

[Big Cox]

Rutten has done just as much if not more than Glass.

Thats nice but he hasnt done as much as Glass

 

[Wizard]

Rutten has done just as much if not more than Glass.

Agree Rutten easily over Glass. Has been much better and has stoped big names already.

 

[Impunity!]

Rutten has done just as much if not more than Glass.

Not quite.

 

[jefffff34]

Tarkyn Lockyer would be there.

 

[Quinz]

Agree Rutten easily over Glass. Has been much better and has stoped big names already.

Glass has only beaten Fev, Hall and Pavlich. Useless bunch of hacks.

Fev didn't kick one on him, Hall bagged one and Pav kicked 2.

 

[Strike Swiftly]

Pav FF easily, thats where he is playing predominently now. He has been better than Fev and Lloyd.

Nah Lloyd at FF. Pav has been playing too far up the ground for a traditional FF position.

 

[jo172]

Thats nice but he hasnt done as much as Glass

Please, Rutten has bitchslapped Lloyd, Tredera and Hall. He also bitchslapped McDougall but that's not quite as impressive

What's Glass's tally? Pavlich, Fevola, Hall and got beaten by Rocca. Pretty comparable really.

 

[Dagless]

Agree Rutten easily over Glass. Has been much better and has stoped big names already.

Rutten - Lloyd (Didnt really negate his impact), Macdougall(midfield ruined all of his chances to kick goals + what do you expect), Tredders (Back from injury) and Hall

Glass - Hall (Cancel each other out), Pav (Destroyed by Glass), Rocca (Played up field, and dragged Glass up there - wasnt really playing a FB in the game) and Fevola (Who kicked 1 goal when Glass want on the field)

Glass has been on harder opponents imo

But quite comparable

 

[Wizard]

Glass has only beaten Fev, Hall and Pavlich. Useless bunch of hacks.

Dont recall saying Glass wasnt a darn good footballer but he hasnt absolutely killed opponents like Rutten. Hall and Pav both started games well while he was helped by the weather against Fev.

Rutten is my choice. But as we can tell this is a West Coast love thread.

 

[mattdavies_03]

Stanton over Thompson and Rutten or McPhee over Kennelly

 

[Bollox]

Would look like

FB: T.Kennelly D.Glass B.Sewell
CHB: D.Fletcher C.Cornes A.McLeod
C: S.Thompson C.Judd J.Bartel
CHF: R.O Keefe S.Lucas G.Ablett
FF M.Pavlich M.Lloyd B.Johnson
R: H.McIntosh D.Kerr S.Black
I/C: N.Malceski D.Wirrpanda A.Sandilands J.Lewis

Scott West VERY unlucky

Good side...i'll make just a cpl of shifties.

McCleod....Glass....Sewell
Kennelly....Cornes...McPhee
R Harvey...Bartel....D Cross
OKeefe......Lucas....Gablett
B Johnson...Pavlich...Bock

Sandilands...Judd...Kerr

Lade....Lewis...West...Fletcher

 

[Power 4 Flag]

How bout Lade as the AA Ruckman? If you saw his taps on the weekend and the previous 3 games, they have been amazing and he is racking up possessions and goals as well. Why isn't he the AA Ruckman so far? And Shaun Burgoyne and Robert Harvey? Should easily make the team.