Banter Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Collingwood Part 5

[PerthBoy86]

It is what it is. The day people across the board start treating us as a charity/sympathy case, is the day we may as well fold the club up imo.

Yeah not what you want to be. You could imagine after the 1999 prelim final and grand final, and Essendon's loss to Brisbane that these two powerhouses would go 25 and 30 years respectively without a flag, with no hope in side.

Meanwhile the Pies contend in 6 grand finals winning 2. Even Hawthorn with their premierships may match and exceed those 2 clubs 16 flags, despite entering 30 years later and being a cellar dweller for many decades. Not to rub it in but I guess dynasties rise and fall.

Im a bit worried about my own club. This patch will hurt our overall win/loss record, and Derby record. Not that I care that much but its a little annoying.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Remember the last couple of years when you kept complaining that Hawthorn supporters were saying that we were winning the clearances, that we were top two in clearances, and that's the reason why thought midfield had improved, while you thought Sam Mitchell was an idiot for getting rid of O'Meara and Mitchell.

Now you're talking about pressure acts.

Literally have no idea what you're referring to

 

[Pistol Night]

Is there a point where Pies fans just feel sorry for Blues fans and ease off a little? Maybe after another 30 year drought?

Never particularly liked Carlton but I just pity them and their supporters. They're almost in St Kilda territory. Part of me wants them to have success due to that but I can never really hope a big Vic club has more success.

It went from hatred to pity around 2022

 

[PerthBoy86]

Do you feel sorry for Freo

At times. I feel ambiguous about them. Like part of me actually does want them to taste some success, but other times I feel like a sadistic nuff and I enjoy it wjen they lose. Partly due to some posters here. But ultimately the many loyal Freo supporters deserve something. I grew up close to Fremantle and prefer it to the Perth CBD, so sometimes I think had I been born say 5 years later I'd probably have gone for the purples. Was too loyal to the blue and gold to switch when they came in.

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Yeah not what you want to be. You could imagine after the 1999 prelim final and grand final, and Essendon's loss to Brisbane that these two powerhouses would go 25 and 30 years respectively without a flag, with no hope in side.

Meanwhile the Pies contend in 6 grand finals winning 2. Even Hawthorn with their premierships may match and exceed those 2 clubs 16 flags, despite entering 30 years later and being a cellar dweller for many decades. Not to rub it in but I guess dynasties rise and fall.

Im a bit worried about my own club. This patch will hurt our overall win/loss record, and Derby record. Not that I care that much but its a little annoying.

We're going through a barren period the worst in our history actually, but we'll rise again at some point and so will Essendon.

For two clubs that have been crap for two decades, both the Blues and Bombers still put the bums on the seats.

Although that is part of the problem i think. The powers that be at both clubs take the fans loyalty for granted at times i think.

 

[beerbandit]

I don't have to imagine it mate.

Nothing like imagining.

 

[nahnah]

At times. I feel ambiguous about them. Like part of me actually does want them to taste some success, but other times I feel like a sadistic nuff and I enjoy it wjen they lose. Partly due to some posters here. But ultimately the many loyal Freo supporters deserve something. I grew up close to Fremantle and prefer it to the Perth CBD, so sometimes I think had I been born say 5 years later I'd probably have gone for the purples. Was too loyal to the blue and gold to switch when they came in.

oh ok, well no, Carlton fans deserve nothing but misery

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Are you actually having a go at someone for defending their club?

It appears all of the nuffs are

 

[PerthBoy86]

We're going through a barren period the worst in our history actually, but we'll rise again at some point and so will Essendon.

For two clubs that have been crap for two decades, both the Blues and Bombers still put the bums on the seats.

Although that is part of the problem i think. The powers that be at both clubs take the fans loyalty for granted at times i think.

Yes that's true. And at least in our league every team gets their day eventually. I dont get why people follow those European football leagues where a few teams dominate and win most everything. I think we are right to be cynical about how corporate it's become. Sure success is nice, but the WCFC won't be alarmed until you see a lot of empty seats at Optus.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I gave them plenty of time too. I was on their case as early as last season. Way even before Meow and Fadge.

Before Fadge??? U come in here once every couple of months normally, Fadge has been in here throwing punches for 5 years pal

 

[Scritchyscroony]

You're not half as good as Fadge old mate

Bloody hell. Now you're heaping praise on Fadge!
I've heard it all now.

It's official. The final straw. Carlton posters have finally snapped.

 

[Ctracks]

Seriously, there were 12 votes for Carlton last night/this morning. It’s now at 13. Name and shame!

 

[Pistol Night]

Before Fadge??? U come in here once every couple of months normally, Fadge has been in here throwing punches for 5 years pal

Are you blokes that broken that you're defending Fadge? This is severe Stockholm Syndrome, please seek help ASAP.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Seriously, there were 12 votes for Carlton last night/this morning. It’s now at 13. Name and shame!

There was 11 before he game. Things are looking up for the good old Blue Baggers!

 

[Pistol Night]

Seriously, there were 12 votes for Carlton last night/this morning. It’s now at 13. Name and shame!

I changed mine to be a good sport

 

[Scritchyscroony]

The only team dumb enough to trade for a VFL plodder on such big money is Carlton.

Guess they are stuck with him.

Saints would take him as long as Blues pay $300k or so of his wage.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Are you blokes that broken that you're defending Fadge? This is severe Stockholm Syndrome, please seek help ASAP.

We've all said many a time, Fudger is the biggest idiot on here, but we still enjoy the back and forth.

Otherwise we just wouldn't bother with the thread

 

[Robertio]

Bloody hell. Now you're heaping praise on Fadge!
I've heard it all now.

It's official. The final straw. Carlton posters have finally snapped.

Where did i heap praise there mate, i said he wasn't half as good as him, get your hands out of your pants.

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Are you blokes that broken that you're defending Fadge? This is severe Stockholm Syndrome, please seek help ASAP.

I knew they all secretly loved him. You could just tell from the obsessions.

 

[Delisted]

I was barracking for Motlop for the lolz on here. Great Odin's raven never again. Ffs his teammates looked like they didn't want to dish him the ball.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Any other brain dead fake Hawk fans are deranged Catters still to come? Feel like we've swatted off most of them Robertio

Feel a bit bad going back at old mate Pancakes calling all of our players shite despite having the worst team in footy the last 3-4 years

 

[Irish BlueBagger]

Seriously, there were 12 votes for Carlton last night/this morning. It’s now at 13. Name and shame!

I just voted for Carlton on the poll there. I'm staying aboard the sinking ship right until the very end!

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I was barracking for Motlop for the lolz on here. Great Odin's raven never again. Ffs his teammates looked like they didn't want to dish him the ball.

I told you he was utterly useless campaigner. The biggest hack in the league and that includes McNuggets

 

[Pistol Night]

I told you he was utterly useless campaigner. The biggest hack in the league and that includes McNuggets

Lucky we didn't listen to all the experts regarding Schultz being shit

 

[Delisted]

Any other brain dead fake Hawk fans are deranged Catters still to come? Feel like we've swatted off most of them Robertio

Feel a bit bad going back at old mate Pancakes calling all of our players shite despite having the worst team in footy the last 3-4 years

Aww what did I do Walshy? Also who's Mcnuggies?