Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy AFL 2025 Second Qualifying Final - Cats v Lions Fri Sept 5th 7:40pm AEST (MCG)

Who will win and by how much?

  • Cats by a goal or less

    Votes: 8 5.3%
  • Lions by a goal or less

    Votes: 12 7.9%
  • Cats by 7 - 20

    Votes: 42 27.6%
  • Lions by 7 - 20

    Votes: 64 42.1%
  • Cats by a lot

    Votes: 10 6.6%
  • Lions by a lot

    Votes: 14 9.2%
  • Draw

    Votes: 2 1.3%

  • Total voters
    152
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

You can’t lie that you’ve underachieved big time in the last 10 years based on final round ladder positions
We don't play home finals and 3 of those finals losses have been to MCG teams at that ground. You could say we're one flag short in that time, but are usually about the 3rd or 4th best team (which years were Geelong clearly the best and didn't win it?). This is where you get to say soft kills at GMHBA elevate us from 4th or 3rd to 2nd or 1st some seasons when we've had a good, but not spectacular side.
 
We don't play home finals and 3 of those finals losses have been to MCG teams at that ground. You could say we're one flag short in that time, but are usually about the 3rd or 4th best team (which years were Geelong clearly the best and didn't win it?). This is where you get to say soft kills at GMHBA elevate us from 4th or 3rd to 2nd or 1st some seasons when we've had a good, but not spectacular side.
2016 was the one that got away imo.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

You can’t lie that you’ve underachieved big time in the last 10 years based on final round ladder positions
What do you expect them to do, win 6 grand finals? Lol

For a team that’s never bottomed out in recent times, they’re what every fan would want out of their club. Always around the mark and can pinch a flag any year.

It’s what I hoped the Lions would develop into when we were shit. 7 years of finals now for the same flags as Geelong in that time and I am more than happy, Cats fans would be too.
 
You go for afl love childs. How Pathetic. But thats saints fans to a tee.

How are we the AFL love child? We get screwed with the umpiring, fixturing, drafting etc, we're the opposite of an AFL love child.

You’ve got the two highest paid players in the league M8, be happy and rejoice.

Hopefully we will be back playing finals again next year to give Collingwood and Geelong a proper fight so enjoy it while it lasts.
 
Just saw the tape of the double free.

Gotta wonder what is going through the umpires head to call a free like that with the “offending team” taking a shot at goal at the other end of the ground.

Absolutely zero feel for the game, before you even consider that the free wasn’t there. And then to follow up with another nothing free… just wow.

I thought Cam Rayner embarrassed himself to be honest. You’d expect a small forward to play up those two incidents, but I thought arrogantly getting in his opponent’s face with “tough man” antics afterwards was a bad look given he just flopped twice. I don’t like it when Papley acts like that, but this looked like another level.

It’s hard to feel too bad for Geelong given its history of playing for frees, plus they completely outplayed the Lions so no real impact.

We have a few players who’ve been done for it: Dempsey got fined for it and he’s seemingly learned his lesson and it’s drifted out of his game.

He was one. Selwood obviously had a technique that he adhered to and as most cats fans acknowledge he trod a line between trying to actually win the ball and break tackles but also force the opponent to take him high and give away a free.

I don’t think we have others that are ‘notable’ for it as such. Most players probably ham it up to some degree but that from Rayner tonight was pretty abysmal. The first one was just a joke.

The second one was there - ironically Zac Guthrie is a player who should not have come rushing in but is one guy who would never feign for a free in a situation like that, though he DID push Rayner pretty hard. His action was just silly. But it shouldn’t have come to that in the first place
 
I don’t think we have others that are ‘notable’ for it as such. Most players probably ham it up to some degree but that from Rayner tonight was pretty abysmal. The first one was just a joke.

Hawkins had a dive against Hawthorn in 2022 that was at least as abysmal as Rayner's.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Geelong fatigue in full effect, everyone is so over Geelong, applauding flopping in hope it helps Geelong lose, beautiful to see.
Why would any non Geelong fan would want to see them up there year after year. Or any other team other than one's own. It's like those European football leagues where the same few teams always win because some Russian or Saudi billionaire owns them and buys the best players, managers etc. Don't get why fans of other clubs still watch or care.
 
What do you expect them to do, win 6 grand finals? Lol

For a team that’s never bottomed out in recent times, they’re what every fan would want out of their club. Always around the mark and can pinch a flag any year.

It’s what I hoped the Lions would develop into when we were shit. 7 years of finals now for the same flags as Geelong in that time and I am more than happy, Cats fans would be too.
Win more than one. They’ve had more opportunity than anyone else whilst also getting a dream fixture every year, yet still aren’t close to the most successful side of the last 15 years
 
Hawkins had a dive against Hawthorn in 2022 that was at least as abysmal as Rayner's.

Perhaps, but I think over 360 games with 1-2 defenders hanging off you, you can probably be forgiven for one that’s equitable with one that’s 150 metres away from an opponent taking a shot on goal.
 
Win more than one. They’ve had more opportunity than anyone else whilst also getting a dream fixture every year, yet still aren’t close to the most successful side of the last 15 years

What dream fixture? Does that somehow apply in the finals? Do we get to play you guys in the finals? Boy that would make things easy.

And yeah actually we are close to the most successful side of the last 15 years. We are 1 premiership behind that title. We’ve won 2 in that time, remember? The most successful side in that time has won 3. We’ve won 2. And we were leading a grand final by 20 points as well. So I’d say ‘not even close to being to most successful’ of the last 15 years is…. Well it’s probably a slight exaggeration. We are the 3rd most successful side of the last 15 years.
 
Win more than one. They’ve had more opportunity than anyone else whilst also getting a dream fixture every year, yet still aren’t close to the most successful side of the last 15 years
We pissed away a GF at the GABBA, straight sets and a GF loss as well. We’re easily comparable, yet I’d rather that then whatever we had from 2010-2018.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Autopsy AFL 2025 Second Qualifying Final - Cats v Lions Fri Sept 5th 7:40pm AEST (MCG)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top