Autopsy Roast & Toast - Round 2 v Collingwood & changes for GWS Rd 3

[guruisatiger]

with a port power butt plug up his arse

Oh baby that's scary good

 

[Tiges1229]

Oh baby that's scary good

From the paint drowned in honey .

 

[Tiges1229]

Wankley watching the new 666 rules .

 

[Tiges1229]

Can we make top for from 1-3 start ?

 

[mopsy]

Said this on another site but i would be happy with 8 changes and in all honesty you could justify all 8 changes and inclusions

Out -
Grimes inj,
Riewoldt inj,
Butler horrid,
Ellis ordinary and scared,
Weller ordinary list clogger,
Castagna ordinary lacking skill,
Markov ordinary failed to grasp yet another opportunity,
Short ordinary just too soft.

IN-
Balta to play in Rances role should have happened this week.common sense comes in for Butler.
Garthwaite for Grimes common sense.
Moore for Riewoldt has earnt it common sense.
Houli for Short no brainer imo.
RC-D for Weller play him fwd in the Caddy role with some short stints thru the middle.
Bolton for Castagna far better skills and he can help out with midfield rotations. has been good of season and practice games
Ross for the insipid Ellis kid has definately earnt it
Stack for Markov another kid who has done more than enough to warrant a game.

 

[Hoos]

Said this on another site but i would be happy with 8 changes and in all honesty you could justify all 8 changes and inclusions

Out -
Grimes inj,
Riewoldt inj,
Butler horrid,
Ellis ordinary and scared,
Weller ordinary list clogger,
Castagna ordinary lacking skill,
Markov ordinary failed to grasp yet another opportunity,
Short ordinary just too soft.

IN-
Balta to play in Rances role should have happened this week.common sense
Garthwaite for Grimes common sense.
Moore for Riewoldt has earnt it common sense.
Houli for Short no brainer imo.
RC-D for Weller play him fwd in the Caddy role with some short stints thru the middle.
Bolton for Castagna far better skills and he can help out with midfield rotations. has been good of season and practice games
Ross for the insipid Ellis kid has definately earnt it
Stack for Markov another kid who has done more than enough to warrant a game.

I cannot disagree with any of these.

Unfortunately, we'll be lucky if half of them happen.

 

[Tiges1229]

When is someone gonna resurrect the sack Dimma thread. My bet is after round 5 when we are1-4.

Or one of those ****ing imbecile mb threads “ Has Hardwick been found out “

 

[This Is Anfield]

Oh no! Mark has been cucked!

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Said this on another site but i would be happy with 8 changes and in all honesty you could justify all 8 changes and inclusions

Out -
Grimes inj,
Riewoldt inj,
Butler horrid,
Ellis ordinary and scared,
Weller ordinary list clogger,
Castagna ordinary lacking skill,
Markov ordinary failed to grasp yet another opportunity,
Short ordinary just too soft.

IN-
Balta to play in Rances role should have happened this week.common sense comes in for Butler.
Garthwaite for Grimes common sense.
Moore for Riewoldt has earnt it common sense.
Houli for Short no brainer imo.
RC-D for Weller play him fwd in the Caddy role with some short stints thru the middle.
Bolton for Castagna far better skills and he can help out with midfield rotations. has been good of season and practice games
Ross for the insipid Ellis kid has definately earnt it
Stack for Markov another kid who has done more than enough to warrant a game.

You should have copied and pasted what you said on the other site where you had Butler in both the ins and out.

 

[mopsy]

You should have copied and pasted what you said on the other site where you had Butler in both the ins and out.

Typical of some nothing to add but smart arse comments.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Typical of some nothing to add but smart arse comments.

In seriousness 8 changes in round too imo is excessive. You need consistency and 8 changes with most unforced screams a team that is giving up.

 

[parmy2balmey]

Oh no! Mark has been cucked!

was probably treloar

 

[Waca Jr]

Said this on another site but i would be happy with 8 changes and in all honesty you could justify all 8 changes and inclusions

Out -
Grimes inj,
Riewoldt inj,
Butler horrid,
Ellis ordinary and scared,
Weller ordinary list clogger,
Castagna ordinary lacking skill,
Markov ordinary failed to grasp yet another opportunity,
Short ordinary just too soft.

IN-
Balta to play in Rances role should have happened this week.common sense comes in for Butler.
Garthwaite for Grimes common sense.
Moore for Riewoldt has earnt it common sense.
Houli for Short no brainer imo.
RC-D for Weller play him fwd in the Caddy role with some short stints thru the middle.
Bolton for Castagna far better skills and he can help out with midfield rotations. has been good of season and practice games
Ross for the insipid Ellis kid has definately earnt it
Stack for Markov another kid who has done more than enough to warrant a game.

How tall is Stack out of Interest?

 

[Shazza_]

Can we make top for from 1-3 start ?

nochance

 

[mopsy]

How tall is Stack out of Interest?

hes a small around 178 180cm i believe.He is quick hard at it lays tackles and uses it well.imo we could give him a job on a small fwd and rely on him to give us some drive as well.
From everything i can gather his off season has been very good to date.

 

[Tiges1229]

nochance

Poor Tom Lunch

 

[Tiges1229]

if Martin has another stinker he would need to be looked at being dropped wouldn’t he ? Or if not how many games do we let him go playing crap ?

 

[Hoos]

if Martin has another stinker he would need to be looked at being dropped wouldn’t he ? Or if not how many games do we let him go playing crap ?

46.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

if Martin has another stinker he would need to be looked at being dropped wouldn’t he ? Or if not how many games do we let him go playing crap ?

don’t really see Hardwick dropping a star player regardless of whether they deserve it.

 

[DontArgue4]

Out: Jack, Grimes, Markov, Ellis
In: Caddy, Garthwaite, Houli, Ross

 

[Grrr]

Said this on another site but i would be happy with 8 changes and in all honesty you could justify all 8 changes and inclusions

Out -
Grimes inj,
Riewoldt inj,
Butler horrid,
Ellis ordinary and scared,
Weller ordinary list clogger,
Castagna ordinary lacking skill,
Markov ordinary failed to grasp yet another opportunity,
Short ordinary just too soft.

IN-
Balta to play in Rances role should have happened this week.common sense comes in for Butler.
Garthwaite for Grimes common sense.
Moore for Riewoldt has earnt it common sense.
Houli for Short no brainer imo.
RC-D for Weller play him fwd in the Caddy role with some short stints thru the middle.
Bolton for Castagna far better skills and he can help out with midfield rotations. has been good of season and practice games
Ross for the insipid Ellis kid has definately earnt it
Stack for Markov another kid who has done more than enough to warrant a game.

I think in sentiment I agree with most of these, but in practicality, some are not likely.

RC-D is probably a bit premature. Worth a punt, but that is what it would be.
Stack for Markov is a possibility, but Markov probably deserves another week just for his confidence. He may be a bust, but I'm not sold on dropping blokes after 1 match, especially when some get way more leverage than they deserve.
Stack for Short maybe.
Doubt they will drop Weller. Looks like a list clogger as you said, but dropping him after 2 weeks will make the selection/recruitment people look like dills. They don't like that. Besides he wasn't the worst last week and he is playing in a new side. I never wanted him in the first place for exactly the reason that he will take the place of developing mids, although truth be known we don't have a lot of starved mids in our VFL. He might get the Markov treatment, one more week.

 

[Bojangles17]

Can’t see anymore than three changes , this is a deadset danger game , gotta play our cards right

 

[Bojangles17]

if Martin has another stinker he would need to be looked at being dropped wouldn’t he ? Or if not how many games do we let him go playing crap ?

Review the patience we ve had with small forwards then reload, on that basis I’d say +150
Seriously how big are dimmas problems when all he gotta do is get dusty to fire and then the tigers go bangggggg

 

[Waca Jr]

hes a small around 178 180cm i believe.He is quick hard at it lays tackles and uses it well.imo we could give him a job on a small fwd and rely on him to give us some drive as well.
From everything i can gather his off season has been very good to date.

Cheers.

 

[Cdog71]

Stacks gonna get bigger than his 177 and less than 80 kilo.
I hope he gets a few games this year, it’d be awesome if he could.
I’m not sure the weight would be as a big a disadvantage as a H/B as it would if we was a Mid
Neville Jetta is just 1.8 and 77 kilo