MRP / Trib. 2013 MRP thread

[eth-dog]

If the little shit challenges does he get 2?

 

[Lance Uppercut]

If the little shit challenges does he get 2?

I think so.

Yep:

Stephen Milne, St Kilda, has been charged with a Level Two misconduct offence (225 demerit points, two-match sanction) for misconduct in that he made unnecessary contact to the face of Courtenay Dempsey, Essendon, during the fourth quarter of the Round Four match between St Kilda and Essendon, played at Etihad Stadium on Saturday April 20, 2013.

 

[eth-dog]

Please let him challenge and get rubbed out for 2, watch the dawks destroy the aint's from the sideline

 

[astrowizzle]

can someone please explain to me how Steve Morris managed to get away with 1 week suspension for 2 head high bumps. One of which was at least the equal of what Ryder did. The ****ing ass bags in that panel aare absolutely clueless. We seem to wear maximum penalties compared to most if not all other team in this competition

 

[VelvetSledge]

That's a lot of sanctions. Milne getting a week. Cop that you dirty f*cking rat.

 

[daffo]

AFL hate anything do to with the head. Milne was silly.

 

[eth-dog]

Can somebody explain how Morris' was "negligent" and Kommer's "reckless"? If Kommer's was reckless, then there's no doubt Morris' was too

 

[Lance Uppercut]

yeah Morris getting just one is a joke

 

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Can somebody explain how Morris' was "negligent" and Kommer's "reckless"? If Kommer's was reckless, then there's no doubt Morris' was too

You're forgetting the 'roll of the dice' activation point component.

They rolled a double six for Kommer and only a five (two and three) for Morris.

 

[Lavender Gooms]

How is Milne's incident seen as reckless not intentional? He had his hand in his mouth pushing down. Seemed pretty intentional to me.

 

[Lord Nicholson]

As Whateley pointed out, don't worry folks. Mark Fraser has his finger on the button. He's got this; chill.

 

[astrowizzle]

honestly the MRP needs to be over hauled totally. Richmond are obviously the flavour of the month with refs and MRP

 

[KeepOnKeepingOn]

How is Milne's incident seen as reckless not intentional? He had his hand in his mouth pushing down. Seemed pretty intentional to me.

I don't understand this either

 

[Pweter]

Also pissed off Neville Jetta got only 2 weeks with a bad record thrown in when Ryder got 3 with his early plea.

Ryder was going into a contest, both he and McPharlin were charging like rhino's, McPharlin taps the ball forward meaning Ryder is out of the contest but contact could not be avoided. Ryder stops and braces himself and the inevitable collision happens, just that McPharlin had left himself wide open due to reaching for the ball.

Jetta's hit was from another era, it was a dog act. He left the ground and if it wasn't for Whitfield's awareness where he propped then Jetta would've taken his head off. Jetta ran up to him and leapt off the ground clipping his head whereas if Whitfield had've kept on going it would've been lights out.

The fact it didn't KO him is neither here nor there in my opinion. It was a dog act and worse than Ryder's.

 

[Lavender Gooms]

Also pissed off Neville Jetta got only 2 weeks with a bad record thrown in when Ryder got 3 with his early plea.

Ryder was going into a contest, both he and McPharlin were charging like rhino's, McPharlin taps the ball forward meaning Ryder is out of the contest but contact could not be avoided. Ryder stops and braces himself and the inevitable collision happens, just that McPharlin had left himself wide open due to reaching for the ball.

Jetta's hit was from another era, it was a dog act. He left the ground and if it wasn't for Whitfield's awareness where he propped then Jetta would've taken his head off. Jetta ran up to him and leapt off the ground clipping his head whereas if Whitfield had've kept on going it would've been lights out.

The fact it didn't KO him is neither here nor there in my opinion. It was a dog act and worse than Ryder's.

The MRP punish the result not that act. Not the best way to operate.

 

[Phone]

Can somebody explain how Morris' was "negligent" and Kommer's "reckless"? If Kommer's was reckless, then there's no doubt Morris' was too

haven't seen Morris's one, but Kommer not slowing down or trying to change his arm position or pull out of the bump means he got reckless. if kommer had tried to put on the brakes but still made contact he would have got negligent.

 

[Kong]

haven't seen Morris's one, but Kommer not slowing down or trying to change his arm position or pull out of the bump means he got reckless. if kommer had tried to put on the brakes but still made contact he would have got negligent.

He clearly changed his running direction to minimise the damage.

 

[Phone]

btw that was from memory and i'm not so sure about that post now in terms of that being the difference between reckless and negligent.

 

[yaco55]

Jetta with a bad record gets two weeks and Kommer with no record gets two weeks.

And neither caused damage to the player.

The MRP is a lottery.