2018 Rate My Team (Post JLT)

[WaynesWorld19]

honestly nfi.

View attachment 470324

Nothing wrong with that team ......maybe swing Sicily FWD & put Doedee on the field ......but you'd be happy with that team

 

[Leftyitis]

So many teams with Devon Smith! I feel like he's a Sam Gray shaped trap, convince me otherwise.

Seems to be the same year I took (along with Grey) T Sheridan and J Lonergan. I have Smith. Hold me.

 

[Test Tickle]

Whats with petracca being in so many teams?

I rate him too, but not this year for me.
He still looks to heavy.

 

[Keg on legs]

I think I've found the one...

$32,200 in the bank
View attachment 470265

Nice.

Quite similar to my 50k winning side

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Makes sense to me.

Third premo defender is hard to pick after Laird and Hibberd imo.

There seems to be no real standout.

Our teams are scarily similar. Particularly if you do what I did and downgrade Sav > Bray

 

[Sir Hugh Percy]

Seems to be the same year I took (along with Grey) T Sheridan and J Lonergan. I have Smith. Hold me.

Haha, yes the old Jesse Lonergan scam. I had him too.

 

[stevebbb]

Lol Dollhouse

Huh?

Did you trade him in mid season last year? Poor thing still offended

 

[SavDog23]

Danger ownership down to 22%. It's also looking like i'm one of the only ones actually starting him.
IMO, there is more downside to not starting him, then there is to starting him.

If he comes out and only goes 120-130, even 110, for a few rounds, and he drops to ~$650k, you've only really saved around $100k. But is that really worth 1, possibly 2 trades to get him back in? I'm not sure.

If he does start the season with a 130-160 average, then i'm safe and everyone else is ******.

Could make or break a lot of peoples seasons, but I'm more confident just having him in the side if he is named RD 1.

 

[JDWCE]

Danger ownership down to 22%. It's also looking like i'm one of the only ones actually starting him.
IMO, there is more downside to not starting him, then there is to starting him.

If he comes out and only goes 120-130, even 110, for a few rounds, and he drops to ~$650k, you've only really saved around $100k. But is that really worth 1, possibly 2 trades to get him back in? I'm not sure.

If he does start the season with a 130-160 average, then i'm safe and everyone else is ******.

Could make or break a lot of peoples seasons, but I'm more confident just having him in the side if he is named RD 1.

Does a late out worry you? Or the chance of reinjury? Personally I think I’m still going to start with him as it’ll be too hard to get him in but goddamn those two things concern me still

 

[SavDog23]

Does a late out worry you? Or the chance of reinjury? Personally I think I’m still going to start with him as it’ll be too hard to get him in but goddamn those two things concern me still

If he is a late-out, I'll probably trade him to Selwood or Parker, who should both make a bit of $$$ before Round ~6 which is when i'd like to get him in.

 

[JDWCE]

If he is a late-out, I'll probably trade him to Selwood or Parker, who should both make a bit of $$$ before Round ~6 which is when i'd like to get him in.

Yeah can see both of them going bang in round 1

 

[Keg on legs]

Does a late out worry you? Or the chance of reinjury? Personally I think I’m still going to start with him as it’ll be too hard to get him in but goddamn those two things concern me still

Im 50/50 at the moment, but if do swap him to someone else my plan would be to hold the left over cash so i can get him back asap

I guess it's a personal decision on how much they value a trade at

 

[JDWCE]

Im 50/50 at the moment, but if do swap him to someone else my plan would be to hold the left over cash so i can get him back asap

I guess it's a personal decision on how much they value a trade at

Yeah that idea sounds the most ideal I think. Less downside in having a bit of spare cash in case he does fire

 

[JDavey]

Danger ownership down to 22%. It's also looking like i'm one of the only ones actually starting him.
IMO, there is more downside to not starting him, then there is to starting him.

If he comes out and only goes 120-130, even 110, for a few rounds, and he drops to ~$650k, you've only really saved around $100k. But is that really worth 1, possibly 2 trades to get him back in? I'm not sure.

If he does start the season with a 130-160 average, then i'm safe and everyone else is ******.

Could make or break a lot of peoples seasons, but I'm more confident just having him in the side if he is named RD 1.

Is getting the #1 player for 100k cheaper then his starting price good

I was never starting Danger even when he was healthy - so I'm probably not able to be convinced. I just don't see how you ever end out ahead on points or $ (or even trades) if you started him. Let alone if he misses a round

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Huh?

Did you trade him in mid season last year? Poor thing still offended

No... I had him from the start! Even more offended!

 

[stevebbb]

H

No... I had him from the start! Even more offended!

He played 22 games and averaged 91, it really wasn't that bad...

 

[Better Loosen Up]

H

He played 22 games and averaged 91, it really wasn't that bad...

He's just sooo meh! I would think there are other players with far more upside than him.

 

[Sydney Kicker]

Ive got 200k spare. Any advice on where to spend it? Its not enough to upgrade a mid rookie and I don't really want a premium at F5. I guess i could keep it as a danger fund but I dont like having 200k sitting there

View attachment 470193

Mitchell down to Luke Parker and Naughton up to a premo?

 

[stevebbb]

He's just sooo meh! I would think there are other players with far more upside than him.

I see this...



... and I see

20-22 games
90 average min
105 average max

For $500k, I'm pretty keen

I am not 100% taking Dahl, I still might take McLean for example. I can see McLean averaging 90, but I highly doubt he'll go over 90 or 91. Dahl has the much higher ceiling

 

[Better Loosen Up]

I see this...

View attachment 470366

... and I see

20-22 games
90 average min
105 average max

For $500k, I'm pretty keen

I am not 100% taking Dahl, I still might take McLean for example. I can see McLean averaging 90, but I highly doubt he'll go over 90 or 91. Dahl has the much higher ceiling

I was more interested in trying to put you off your team that your were so confident with!

But yes, Dahl sucks a fat one and I won't be picking him. Enjoy!

 

[Jars458]

A couple of minor changes.

O'Meara out and Hibberd in.

15 proper keepers now.

$77,900 left over.

View attachment 470309

good side. Don't like Hibberd but that's just a weird idiosyncrosy. I think Barry and Garlett won't score high enough or have JS in Barry's case.

 

[00Stinger]

Pretty much locked and loaded with my team

 

[Mitchell54]

What do you guys think of this team?

Gone pretty deep in the forward-line.

I might change Cogs & JOM to a rookie & premo depending on what rookies there are round 1.

 

[Jars458]

Get rid of Bell .....put Sicily down at F5 ....shift Keefe to DEF .....get another D3 (Savage, Lloyd ect) .....that'll be great then

Don't get the Sicily love to be honest. Surely his consistency is a huge worry?

 

[Plugger Mcnally]

After some harsh assessments and good advice, I have changed my team around a bit although I have kept some players that I think are ready for a breakout year.