Remove this Banner Ad

Universal Love 2019 Brownlow thread: kicks off 7.30pm, count 8.20pm.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Shell
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Who will win Chas


  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Weird how little some players can do to get 3 votes and, conversely, how much some players can do and not get 3 votes.

A lot of Fyfe’s votes would’ve been the umpires going “well, who was good today?, not sure, but Fyfe stood out I thought?. Yeah he did, give him some votes”.
 
Paddy the moral winner
I think he was more the moral tied winner in 2017 because he was rubbed out with a bullshit suspension and didn't get votes in a game he clearly dominated. Didn't think he was as good this year, so not surprised he didn't win it. Surprised it went to Fyfe, though.
 
Was always going to be tough for Paddy, in the end TK took way too many votes from him. Fyfe had nobody to contend with and is probably sleeping with a few of the umpires after some of those crazy vote getting rounds.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Can’t believe how many votes Fyfe got in losing sides, don’t watch Freo closely enough to really comment any further, but think Fremantle according to the umpires at least, meet the definition of one man side.
 
I think he was more the moral tied winner in 2017 because he was rubbed out with a bulls**t suspension and didn't get votes in a game he clearly dominated. Didn't think he was as good this year, so not surprised he didn't win it. Surprised it went to Fyfe, though.

I’m not sure he polled in games this year where we got beaten by 5 goals. Fyfe did it multiple times
 
Can’t believe how many votes Fyfe got in losing sides, don’t watch Freo closely enough to really comment any further, but think Fremantle according to the umpires at least, meet the definition of one man side.
Well Cripps also voted well and Carlton lost 2 more games than Freo.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

It used to be that you would have to have an *all-time great year* to reach 30+ votes. Dusty's 2017 votes tally I could understand because it was legitimately up there with one of the best midfield seasons ever.

Fyfe's year was nowhere near that level.
We are all Geelong supporters, but Fyfe is a totally deserving winner. None of us have seen all of his games, but every time I see him, he's a standout.
 
Fyfe winning is an absolute joke.

I could handle Neale, or Cripps, or Bont.

Fyfe had nowhere near a Brownlow winning season. He repeatedly got three votes in comfortable losses when he had sub-30 possessions.

I’m disappointed Danger didn’t win, but more angry that there were another 3-4 players more deserving than Fyfe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom