Analysis 2021 trade thread

[jackess]

Thoughts on possibly getting involved with Fremantle?
Cats apparently want a pick between 8 and 27 (freo’s picks)…. Could we move up the draft?

Freo trade 6 and 27 for 14 and Clark
Geelong trade Clark and 30 for 18
We trade 14 and 18 for 6, 27 and 30

We trade 27, 30 and later picks to the Bulldogs for pick 17

We end up with 6 and 17

 

[WhiteLionFeva]

The disrespect some people show Neale when he's the best player we've had for a long time is fairly bemusing to me. Let's trade out our best player by a long way so we can get some draft picks and maybe get a reward in 3 or 4 years.

Or worse, draft a couple of fails.

 

[jackess]

Or worse, draft a couple of fails.

Trade Neale, draft the best ruck with our first pick, premiers 2022-2030

 

[blueiris]

Best QLD kid at 17yo also

Are you talking about Fletcher ?

 

[brutus76]

no...............Will Ashcroft

Best QLD rep. (even though he is boarding in Melb.) at 15,16 and 17

 

[BangyBangy]

Whatever people think the game is a lot quicker. Black and Aker were such sublime ball handlers every time they went near it I sometimes wonder if it's possible to do so consistently the way the game is now. The current era great players Fyffe, Dangerfield ,Martin and now Petracca and Wines use power and strength to bludgeon their way through. Albeit Martin is a fantastic ball handler as well.

Did you see how clean Petracca was in the grand final? Albeit he wasn't as clean in the first quarter, but probably put that down to nerves.

I was impressed with the one grab from a centre clearance or one touch nature of his game on the weekend.

He's strong, and like oliver stands up in tackles to offload the ball, wouldn't go as far to say he uses strength & power to bludgeon his way through packs, there's a lot of skill and touch there.

 

[BangyBangy]

Freo trade 6 and 27 for 14 and Clark
Geelong trade Clark and 30 for 18
We trade 14 and 18 for 6, 27 and 30

We trade 27, 30 and later picks to the Bulldogs for pick 17

We end up with 6 and 17

I'm in. Take all my money.

 

[MacMum]

Are we able to still take Jarrod Cameron

39

Jarrod Cameron

Age

26

Ht

182cm

Wt

70kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

7.0

2star

K

4.7

2star

HB

2.3

2star

M

1.7

2star

T

3.6

5star

G

1.3

5star

D

5.0

1star

K

3.5

1star

HB

1.5

1star

M

0.5

1star

T

2.5

3star

G

0.5

4star

D

8.0

2star

K

5.6

3star

HB

2.4

3star

M

2.0

3star

T

4.2

5star

G

2.0

5star

if he's delisted? (if we want him)

 

[martinson]

Did you see how clean Petracca was in the grand final? Albeit he wasn't as clean in the first quarter, but probably put that down to nerves.

I was impressed with the one grab from a centre clearance or one touch nature of his game on the weekend.

He's strong, and like oliver stands up in tackles to offload the ball, wouldn't go as far to say he uses strength & power to bludgeon his way through packs, there's a lot of skill and touch there.

I think I said a while ago Petracca is the best player I've seen come along in a long time. Elite hands when he gets going. Can't stop him.

Very few players can individually change the course of big games. They win you flags. Hart ,Matthews , Carey ,Hodge , Martin , Petracca is just as talented, now needs to keep doing it.

Next level Matera, McCleod but not the consistent impact and presence of the others.

 

[BangyBangy]

I think I said a while ago Petracca is the best player I've seen come along in a long time. Elite hands when he gets going. Can't stop him.

Very few players can individually change the course of big games. They win you flags. Hart ,Matthews , Carey ,Hodge , Martin , Petracca is just as talented, now needs to keep doing it.

Next level Matera, McCleod but not the consistent impact and presence of the others.

Jarman was handy too

Reckon McCleod was my favourite non Lions player. Amazing footballer.

 

[WhiteLionFeva]

I think I said a while ago Petracca is the best player I've seen come along in a long time. Elite hands when he gets going. Can't stop him.

Very few players can individually change the course of big games. They win you flags. Hart ,Matthews , Carey ,Hodge , Martin , Petracca is just as talented, now needs to keep doing it.

Next level Matera, McCleod but not the consistent impact and presence of the others.

So you really rate Stef then?

 

[martinson]

So you really rate Stef then?

I've always got a place for Stef in there somewhere.

 

[knaf]

“McLeod” I think.

 

[Fagenslions36]

I’d definitely be looking to get starcevich and Rayner into that midfield next year . Would give our midfield a real boost of power and athleticism with Bailey . Neale and Lyons are your accumulators and clugga is the silk . Kiddy goes straight into birchyl roll and then you can have answorth to play lockdown small defender or madden to add some extra run .

 

[Simba Moyo]

Casboult just interviewed on SEN. Didn't give away much, but alluded to a potential move up north more than once. Feels as though he still has a lot to give and is keen to play footy at any level next year.

 

[jackess]

Not a fan of Casboult (because of injury rumours and anti-vaxxer wife) or Cox because he's too similar to Oscar not mobile enough or good enough in the ruck.

Fort is a bit older than I would've like but probably has similar ability to Fullarton as a forward but is a much better ruck.

Oscar/Fort would be a decent ruck combination until Hippy is fit.

 

[Nuggo]

Not a fan of Casboult (because of injury rumours and anti-vaxxer wife) or Cox because he's too similar to Oscar not mobile enough or good enough in the ruck.

Fort is a bit older than I would've like but probably has similar ability to Fullarton as a forward but is a much better ruck.

Oscar/Fort would be a decent ruck combination until Hippy is fit.

Guess the question remains what is the ruck combination when Hippy is back. I don't think Fort can sit on the bench.

 

[jackess]

Guess the question remains what is the ruck combination when Hippy is back. I don't think Fort can sit on the bench.

I'd assume back to Daniher, although I'd like to try McStay. I'd also hope with 2 rucks we can manage Oscars load so he can finish the year strongly when Hippy is back

 

[Cubs2Lions]

Casboult just interviewed on SEN. Didn't give away much, but alluded to a potential move up north more than once. Feels as though he still has a lot to give and is keen to play footy at any level next year.

 

[briztoon]

Guess the question remains what is the ruck combination when Hippy is back. I don't think Fort can sit on the bench.

I’ll be surprised if we see Hipwood at all next season.

 

[Daniels Riches]

I’d definitely be looking to get starcevich and Rayner into that midfield next year . Would give our midfield a real boost of power and athleticism with Bailey . Neale and Lyons are your accumulators and clugga is the silk . Kiddy goes straight into birchyl roll and then you can have answorth to play lockdown small defender or madden to add some extra run .

I don't get this line of thinking. Why would we want to move Starce into the midfield when he had just shown that he is close to an AA level small defender? Should only continue to master this position. Keep him where he is shining imo.

On moto g(30) using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[mattsmob]

I don't get this line of thinking. Why would we want to move Starce into the midfield when he had just shown that he is close to an AA level small defender? Should only continue to master this position. Keep him where he is shining imo.

On moto g(30) using BigFooty.com mobile app

That’s how I felt once our season ended but I’ve come around to thinking we need to try and get a point of difference in our midfield and someone like Starce could be that. I know it’s very unlikely but having watched Petracca and Oliver during this finals series if we have even the slightest chance to have someone like Starce develop into that we need to at least try it. I also think a fully fit Answerth, Coleman and Prior could and should be in our best 22 and this move opens more spots in their preferred position.

 

[twhowler]

I'd assume back to Daniher, although I'd like to try McStay. I'd also hope with 2 rucks we can manage Oscars load so he can finish the year strongly when Hippy is back

McStay really could be very good in there. He is undersized but not tiny and a good leap. A great field kick when he gets it too.

 

[jackess]

McStay really could be very good in there. He is undersized but not tiny and a good leap. A great field kick when he gets it too.

Can probably follow up better at ground level and tackle. Plus he's not as dangerous forward so we don't lose as much from our forward line

 

[Nuggo]

I’ll be surprised if we see Hipwood at all next season.

Total unknown at this stage.