Analysis 2023 All Australian Team Awards Night

Corn Cobbers · Jul 30, 2023

Can put a line through Taranto who has dropped right off, don't see any Tigers making it this year

RUNVS · Jul 30, 2023

eth-dog said:
Averages don't really mean that much for forwards. They look at totals.

Averages though are actually a better way of doing it, with exceptions of course as a player who only played 11 games across the season can't make the AA team but it does not seem fair that a player who played 22 games makes the AA team over someone who played 18 games just because the player who played 22 games kicked more goals, even though the player who played games kicked more goals per game.

Daka · Jul 30, 2023

Corn Cobbers said:
Can put a line through Taranto who has dropped right off, don't see any Tigers making it this year

Who cares it's a crap award anyway, I bet the AA selectors even go through these threads to see what the public thinks.

Collingwood only have 1 lock and it's Daicos.

TARANTULA · Jul 30, 2023

Gawn > English???

Elmer_Judd · Jul 30, 2023

TARANTULA said:
Gawn > English???

Yep. Absolutely

Toump Ass · Jul 30, 2023

Harry Petty.

Full forward, full back, doesn’t matter.

BIG game today!!!! Six Fat Sausage, even did the classic Hulk Hogan ear to the crowd!!!!

adammania9 · Jul 30, 2023

Squad outs: Aaron Naughton, Josh Kelly, Aliir Aliir
Squad ins: Max Gawn, Rory Laird, Sam Taylor

DEF: Harris Andrews, Jacob Weitering, Darcy Moore, Isaac Quaynor, Nick Daicos, Tom Stewart, Charlie Ballard, Sam Taylor, James Sicily, Dan Houston, Jack Sinclair, Callum Wilkie
MID: Jordan Dawson, Rory Laird, Lachie Neale, Josh Dunkley, Adam Cerra, Jordan De Goey, Josh Daicos, Zach Merrett, Caleb Serong, Noah Anderson, Stephen Coniglio, Christian Petracca, Connor Rozee, Zak Butters, Tim Taranto, Errol Gulden, Marcus Bontempelli, Tom Liberatore
RUC: Max Gawn, Rowan Marshall, Tim English
FWD: Taylor Walker, Joe Daniher, Charlie Cameron, Charlie Curnow, Kyle Langford, Jeremy Cameron, Tom Hawkins, Toby Greene, Nick Larkey, Dustin Martin, Shai Bolton

Team:
B: Tom Stewart - Darcy Moore - James Sicily
HB: Nick Daicos - Charlie Ballard - Jack Sinclair
C: Errol Gulden - Jordan Dawson - Zach Merrett
HF: Christian Petracca - Taylor Walker - Kyle Langford
F: Toby Greene - Charlie Curnow - Joe Daniher
R: Tim English - Marcus Bontempelli - Zak Butters
I: Lachie Neale - Connor Rozee - Tim Taranto - Dan Houston

Second team:
B: Sam Taylor - Harris Andrews - Callum Wilkie
HB: Isaac Quaynor - Jacob Weitering - Adam Cerra
C: Josh Daicos - Tom Liberatore - Noah Anderson
HF: Jordan De Goey - Tom Hawkins - Shai Bolton
F: Charlie Cameron - Nick Larkey - Dustin Martin
R: Max Gawn - Josh Dunkley - Stephen Coniglio
I: Rory Laird - Rowan Marshall - Jeremy Cameron - Caleb Serong

eth-dog · Jul 30, 2023

RUNVS said:
Averages though are actually a better way of doing it, with exceptions of course as a player who only played 11 games across the season can't make the AA team but it does not seem fair that a player who played 22 games makes the AA team over someone who played 18 games just because the player who played 22 games kicked more goals, even though the player who played games kicked more goals per game.

Would someone who's played 15 games, kicked 45 goals and 18 assists be more deserving than someone who played 23 games, kicked 60 goals and had 20 assists?

boncer34 · Jul 30, 2023

eth-dog said:
Would someone who's played 15 games, kicked 45 goals and 18 assists be more deserving than someone who played 23 games, kicked 60 goals and had 20 assists?

Yes

HarryBeef · Jul 30, 2023

Surely Nic Newman gets in ahead of Quaynor. Beating him in every possible metric.

Gysberts2Bate · Jul 30, 2023

I wonder how many rucks have polled nine votes in three games before

hawkman · Jul 30, 2023

Breust could end up with 50 goals as a small forward in a rubbish team. Could potentially make the squad as apart from Greene the other small forwards aren't going that great

g_TRAIN · Jul 30, 2023

TARANTULA said:
Gawn > English???

3 weeks ago Gawn was absolutely belted by Rowan Marshall.

Still think English is ahead

On Pixel 6a using BigFooty.com mobile app

eth-dog · Jul 30, 2023

boncer34 said:
Yes

No

Trav 20 · Jul 30, 2023

g_TRAIN said:
3 weeks ago Gawn was absolutely belted by Rowan Marshall.

Still think English is ahead

On Pixel 6a using BigFooty.com mobile app

Marshall was terrific around the ground but beaten in the ruck. That hardly equates to a ''belting''.

If Max went head to head with Marshall without Grundy I think we all know what the result would have been.

But yeah, Marshall was great that day.

g_TRAIN · Jul 30, 2023

Trav 20 said:
Marshall was terrific around the ground but beaten in the ruck. That hardly equates to a ''belting''.

If Max went head to head with Marshall without Grundy I think we all know what the result would have been.

But yeah, Marshall was great that day.

That's true Marshall gets beaten in the hit outs most weeks. Gawn would have beaten him there but around the ground Marshalls influence is second only to English. Gawn would have had a tough time matching him in that regard.

Trav 20 · Jul 30, 2023

g_TRAIN said:
That's true Marshall gets beaten in the hit outs most weeks. Gawn would have beaten him there but around the ground Marshalls influence is second only to English. Gawn would have had a tough time matching him in that regard.

English and Marshall should be the AA rucks.

longdonkey · Jul 30, 2023

longdonkey said:
Missed a week due to lack of interest but back again

Here's my update for Round 19

B Sicily Andrews Quaynor
HB Houston Moore Vlaustin
C Dawson N Daicos Merrett
HF Bontempelli Walker Petracca
F Greene Curnow Rozee

Ruck English Taranto Butters

INT Neale, Liberatore, Sinclair, J Daicos

IN Sicily, Quaynor, English J Daicos
OUT Aliir, Ryan, Darcy, Anderson

Witts, Anderson, Ballard, Redman, Dunkley, Blicavs, Pendlebury, Aliir, Ryan, Darcy, Nankervis, C Cameron, De Goey, Haynes, Bolton, J Cameron, Finlayson, Parker, Hawkins, Gulden, J Kelly, Parish, Serong, Gawn, Blakey, Stewart

Here's my update for Round 20

B Sicily Andrews Ryan
HB Houston Moore Sinclair
C Anderson N Daicos Gulden
HF Bontempelli Walker Petracca
F Greene Curnow Rozee

Ruck English Dawson Liberatore

INT Neale, Butters, Merrett, Gawn

IN Ryan, Anderson, Gawn, Gulden
OUT Quaynor, Vlaustin, J Daicos, Taranto

Witts, Ballard, Redman, Dunkley, Blicavs, Pendlebury, Aliir, Quaynor, C Cameron, De Goey, Bolton, J Cameron, Hawkins, Taranto, J Kelly, Parish, Serong, J Daicos, Blakey, Stewart, Taylor, Langford, Vlaustin

Aristotle Pickett · Jul 30, 2023

People that want Grian Miers in b4 Dustin Martin need their head read.
Martin's display today was incredible to watch.

eth-dog · Jul 30, 2023

Aristotle Pickett said:
People that want Grian Miers in b4 Dustin Martin need their head read.
Martin's display today was incredible to watch.

Neither of them are in. So pretty irrelevant.

Nat Fyfe · Jul 30, 2023

Richmond posters talking about literally any opposition player Challenge (Impossible)

eth-dog · Jul 30, 2023

Goals and assists round 20:

1. Charlie Curnow 79 (67/12)
2. Taylor Walker 73 (61/12)
3. Toby Greene 67 (49/18)
4. Tom Hawkins 65 (47/18)
5. Kyle Langford 58 (40/18)
6. Jeremy Cameron 56 (44/12)
7. Nick Larkey 55 (50/5)/Joe Daniher (43/12)
9. Charlie Cameron 53 (42/11)/Aaron Naughton (37/16)

Lingsface · Jul 30, 2023

Aristotle Pickett said:
People that want Grian Miers in b4 Dustin Martin need their head read.
Martin's display today was incredible to watch.

This is one thing I agree with you on will be a chance to make the side and it helps having a good cv to gain selection.

Ads734 · Jul 30, 2023

267Hacksaw said:
Current absolute locks: N Daicos, Bont, Petracca, Gulden, Curnow, Walker, Greene, Moore, English, Butters, Dawson.

Leaves 11 spots in arguably the following: 1/2 key back, 4/5 backs, 1 wing, about 4 mids, maybe 1 key forward, 3 forwards. Interesting last few round.

I'd have Taylor, Merrett, Houston, Sicily, J Daicos all on the cusp of locks

Sinclair’s has had the HB spot locked up since rd 4

Mr Meow · Jul 31, 2023

eth-dog said:
Goals and assists round 20:

1. Charlie Curnow 79 (67/12)
2. Taylor Walker 73 (61/12)
3. Toby Greene 67 (49/18)
4. Tom Hawkins 65 (47/18)
5. Kyle Langford 58 (40/18)
6. Jeremy Cameron 56 (44/12)
7. Nick Larkey 55 (50/5)/Joe Daniher (43/12)
9. Charlie Cameron 53 (42/11)/Aaron Naughton (37/16)

Langford should have enough time to climb past the injured Hawkins and take that third tall spot but as a medium.

C.Cameron still remains in the frame. I hope they pick at least one other small forward besides Greene. Rankine would still be in my team but his injury came at an unfortunate time.

Rd 7 Saturday + Club boards

Rd 7 Reviews + Club boards »

Rd 7 Games + Your Club Board

EPL Matchdays 34, 35, & 36 ⚽ Tip Now

Analysis 2023 All Australian Team Awards Night

Norm Smith Medallist

TheBrownDog

Premium Platinum

Club Legend

Everyone's favourite grouch

The Big Deal

Brownlow Medallist

Tier 1 WW Player

Formerly "Dos23"

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Near a spoon

Tier 1 WW Player

Brownlow Medallist

Near a spoon

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

Tier 1 WW Player

Cancelled

Tier 1 WW Player

Premiership Player

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads