MRP / Trib. 2024 MRP Lotto thread II

[ChopChopDigDig]

Corr deserves weeks for stupidity

Was so dumb, cos the umps were bending us over up to this point, and we finally got a free back. Then Corr goes in and reverses it, resulting in a free kick in front of goal.

 

[The Nostradamus]

It’s not about whether Corr should get a week certain clubs do similar things get off . Our players get fines for things that aren’t even reportable

This

Lack of consistency and we cop the s**t end of it more often

 

[Roosurgence]

Corr deserves weeks for stupidity

Regardless of if it’s stupid or not, we have blokes that are elbowing players in the head that are receiving fines, yet an open hand shove (yes it was not a punch at all) is a suspension.

Let’s see if the Cox one from Sunday is graded as a suspension. If not you have all you need to assess that Christen operates with his biases.

I would have thought the club might want to test out this one given what’s been let go this year. It would be pretty easy to argue that it is an open hand push that slips off the shoulder and into the neck. If anything that would be enough to have graded from intentional to careless.

 

[giantroo]

 

[Carey4life]

He should go for this, although out doesn't look as bad as corrs. Corr's looks like a half open punch regardless of how you cut it.

Be angry about Jonas getting off for electing to bump and possibly causing facial fractures. That's as clear cut as it gets ...

 

[Roosurgence]

He should go for this, although out doesn't look as bad as corrs. Corr's looks like a half open punch regardless of how you cut it.

Be angry about Jonas getting off for electing to bump and possibly causing facial fractures. That's as clear cut as it gets ...

If you watch it it’s an open hand shove.

If he was intentionally trying to strike him, then it’s the worst striking technique I have ever seen as you can see him clearly move away from the player, which shows at intention to shove off more than strike.

Not sure how you would think Cox is not as bad? Cox actually makes contact even though Haynes isn’t even touching him. Totally uncalled for and the very definition of a deliberate act.

 

[Ashley B]

They pick and choose who they suspend that is the reality of it. And if we do anything at all we get punished in most cases. Golden Clubs have different rules.

 

[scottywiper]

It's semi scripted entertainment nowadays. Good guys, bad guys, crowd faves....
Reminds me of... I dunno.... WWE? Lol

 

[Roosurgence]

It's semi scripted entertainment nowadays. Good guys, bad guys, crowd faves....
Reminds me of... I dunno.... WWE? Lol

It’s all about their favourite saying now….. PROFIT MAXIMISATION.

The integrity as a pure football competition disappeared a long time ago.

The main issue I have with the concept is that by favouring teams that bring in the most money, pretty much consigns the rest of the competition into a doom loop of poor exposure and inequity.

It’s your classic the rich get richer, while the poor stay poor.

As soon as revenue became the AFL’s key metric and not the product itself, this was always going to be the result.

 

[Horizons_00]

How the * did Jonas get away with breaking Cam's jaw without even a report? How is that not high contact / went to bump. He even got surgery?!

I hate the AFL sometimes

 

[Roosurgence]

How the * did Jonas get away with breaking Cam's jaw without even a report? How is that not high contact / went to bump. He even got surgery?!

I hate the AFL sometimes

There is no way he reviews all incidents. I think half the time he looks up what has got the media up in arms and only reviews those incidents.

Jonas is lucky that Bull is one tough son of a b and not a sook like that Port snowflake that looked like he wanted to cry after Corr gave him a gentle bitch slap.

 

[Ashley B]

How the * did Jonas get away with breaking Cam's jaw without even a report? How is that not high contact / went to bump. He even got surgery?!

I hate the AFL sometimes

I pretty much hate them all the time lol

 

[giantroo]

 

[HTPunter]

I don’t actually even care what the end result is - if Jonas gets nothing and Zurhaar a fine so be it - but I just want some media attention to it.

EVERYONE else in footy gets slammed for being bad. Umpires especially. And then coaches. And players. List managers. Even ******* supporters cop it for not supporting the right way.

But Michael Christian is consistently an inconsistent deadshit and absolute ******* crickets.

I’m convinced he must have behind the goals footage of all these journos up to their eyeballs in some strippers crack doing Colombias finest. That’s why none of them even bother to comment on the bizarre inconsistency. For all his issues, Barrett is the only one who actually brings up the bizarreness of the MRO/tribunal decisions being so different.

 

[Ashley B]

It’s us , always us that gets this s**t and no coincidence either.

 

[nicko74]

That is out and out prejudism! So blatant it ain't funny. We should lobby the club to seek an explanation from the AFL

 

[Hojuman]

Just showed the Zurhaar / Jonas incident on 10news

Tucks his arm in, shoulder hits him square in the jaw !

Why is not one commentator asking the question ? ? ?

 

[hotchilli]

Just showed the Zurhaar / Jonas incident on 10news

Tucks his arm in, shoulder hits him square in the jaw !

Why is not one commentator asking the question ? ? ?

Taking a break from caring about head injuries.

 

[r_boy]

Just showed the Zurhaar / Jonas incident on 10news

Tucks his arm in, shoulder hits him square in the jaw !

Why is not one commentator asking the question ? ? ?

It's absolute rubbish mate just routine prejudice from the AFL.

Zurhaar needs to challenge and rock up in a jaw brace, just to make a point.

 

[Lomas]

Just showed the Zurhaar / Jonas incident on 10news

Tucks his arm in, shoulder hits him square in the jaw !

Why is not one commentator asking the question ? ? ?

Accidental collision apparently……

 

[The Nostradamus]

Accidental collision apparently……

Ah yes the old accidental chose to bump instead of tackle and broke your jaw

The afl is taking the piss

 

[Devington]

I don't really buy the narrative that we're always on the short end of the stick, you browse the umpiring/mrp threads for a while and you see almost every club saying that, but I will say that this particular instance is just ******* strange and the lack of questions or attention from the media is just serving to make me genuinely pissed off.

 

[Hojuman]

I don't really buy the narrative that we're always on the short end of the stick, you browse the umpiring/mrp threads for a while and you see almost every club saying that, but I will say that this particular instance is just ******* strange and the lack of questions or attention from the media is just serving to make me genuinely pissed off.

Insert;
. Danger
. Cripps
. Neale
. Heeney
. Dawson
. Roozee
. Daicos
. with a broken jaw

Different outcome ? Hell yeh !

 

[Kanga Glory]

Isn’t the head sackrasent , apparently not

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Logue braces for impact, collides with Day, no injury, Day gets straight up.

One week.

Jonas runs through Zurhaar, breaks his jaw, had other options.

Not cited.

Seems legit.