MRP / Trib. 2024 MRP Lotto thread II

[DuckYeah]

I can't work out what's the biggest joke Redman getting one week for push to the face or Sicily getting the same penalty for kicking.

Bad to worse.

Laura Kane explained it all on the couch last monday. Off the ball incidents are considered intentional and induce a week suspension. On the ball incidents are deemed careless

 

[DuckYeah]

So no fine for miers throwing a players boot away?
Guess that’s allowed now, I’d throw it 50 rows back into the crowd then

Yet Simpkin got fined for throwing away a gps

The boot was a work place hazard, he was eliminating the risk.

 

[SonofSamsquanch]

So no fine for miers throwing a players boot away?
Guess that’s allowed now, I’d throw it 50 rows back into the crowd then

Yet Simpkin got fined for throwing away a gps

At least Jy doesn't have to go through life with a head like Miers or the name "Gryan".

 

[DuckYeah]

I did find it piss funny that boot was tossed 30 metres away. Classic

 

[The Nostradamus]

I did find it piss funny that boot was tossed 30 metres away. Classic

I thought throwing the gps was funny also

But only one got a fine

At least we can instruct our players what to throw now

 

[hotchilli]

So no fine for miers throwing a players boot away?
Guess that’s allowed now, I’d throw it 50 rows back into the crowd then

Yet Simpkin got fined for throwing away a gps

Simpkin's isn't really comparable in the sense he was the one to remove the GPS to throw it away.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Simpkin's isn't really comparable in the sense he was the one to remove the GPS to throw it away.

yeah ok I’m happy with that logic

So if you find anything of a players on the ground we can throw it as far away as possible but we cannot remove it from the player then throw

 

[Wild Bill]

Funny Redman got a week. Ess posters are having a sook due to Hewett the week before.


Very similar - but 1 big difference. Hewett was in play - Redman wasn’t. It’s why 1 was graded as intentional and 1 was careless. Hewett a fine and Redman 1 week.

Ess posters are seeing red or on drugs and can’t work out the difference.

 

[Roosurgence]

Funny Redman got a week. Ess posters are having a sook due to Hewett the week before.


Very similar - but 1 big difference. Hewett was in play - Redman wasn’t. It’s why 1 was graded as intentional and 1 was careless. Hewett a fine and Redman 1 week.

Ess posters are seeing red or on drugs and can’t work out the difference.

It let’s be honest if one is worth a week so should the other.

Regardless if it being deemed in play or not Hewitt’s strike is exactly the same.

If you want the action out of the game, then suspend Hewitt as well.

A clip to the chin is a clip to the chin regardless of where the ball is.

 

[Wild Bill]

It let’s be honest if one is worth a week so should the other.

Regardless if it being deemed in play or not Hewitt’s strike is exactly the same.

If you want the action out of the game, then suspend Hewitt as well.

A clip to the chin is a clip to the chin regardless of where the ball is.

The teams and players were told. Punch to the head no where near play will be graded intentional.

They got it correct - it’s why ess didn’t challenge.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Punch to the head ANYWHERE should be a week.

Yet again, they create an issue for no valid reason.

 

[Harris 10]

So just to be clear, if you want to punch someone in the head do it in play?

 

[Roosurgence]

The teams and players were told. Punch to the head no where near play will be graded intentional.

They got it correct - it’s why ess didn’t challenge.

I’m not arguing with grading. I am
Just making a point both are strikes to the head, so why bother even making silly rules of if it’s in play or not? If you want the action gone, suspend both.

 

[Ashley B]

A punch or forearm to the head,in particular to the back of, is fine, if you are using the Carlton patented advanced tackling technique. How refreshing

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

A punch or forearm to the head,in particular to the back of, is fine, if you are using the Carlton patented advanced tackling technique. View attachment 1932222How refreshing

Ahh yes.

The Kick Accuracy Interference Technique.

If that sounds like complete and utter bullshit, it’s only because it is.

 

[Ashley B]

Ahh yes.

The Kick Accuracy Interference Technique.

If that sounds like complete and utter bullshit, it’s only because it is.

But funnily enough he got off, how surprising . This competition isn't compromised much lol

 

[tazaa]

But funnily enough he got off, how surprising . This competition isn't compromised much lol

Andrew Woods is a Carlton supporter.
He represents the AFL Tribunal.

The amount of times Carlton players have been let off at the Tribunal because they ‘won’ their cases is bullshit.

 

[Ashley B]

In fairness the majority of the competition is now bullshit. Whoever they want to succeed get the ultimate red carpet treatment.

 

[Roostorm]

Well 3o mins and case thrown out…




this aged well ..has anyone checked on the wine volcano

 

[DuckYeah]

It let’s be honest if one is worth a week so should the other.

Regardless if it being deemed in play or not Hewitt’s strike is exactly the same.

If you want the action out of the game, then suspend Hewitt as well.

A clip to the chin is a clip to the chin regardless of where the ball is.

Accidental contact is going to happen in a contact sport. Pushing and shoving in the contest is part of the game. Sometimes they go high. Off the ball there is zero need to chin anyone….

Edit: unless its Jimmy Webster..

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Love how the AFL dragged out their favourite engineered outcome clause ‘potential to cause injury’.

There is absolutely no way Sicily’s action had the potential to cause a scratch, let alone an injury.

 

[gokangas]

Love how the AFL dragged out their favourite engineered outcome clause ‘potential to cause injury’.

There is absolutely no way Sicily’s action had the potential to cause a scratch, let alone an injury.

It deserved a week. Disgraceful decision.

 

[Ashley B]

It’s more the act he should have got a week. However, in all fairness he was using the Hawthorn patented advanced kicking technique. So I understand why it was dismissed

 

[giantroo]

 

[DuckYeah]

As much as I hate the cheating dogs. Wright doesn’t deserve to be suspended.