A. Cooney vs. A. Walker

[K.Simpson]

So who would you rather?

 

[SeymourLions]

umm.......your taking the **** surely?

 

[demondude]

god walker was good on robbo..id have to say walker just

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

This thread is being started at a time when Cooney is in a slump and Walker is going alright by his standard.

If you look at what they've done so far, and what they have the potential to do, it has to be Cooney quite easily. Cooney has far more class, uses it better, runs with the ball and kicks goals. Walker tags Cooney's

 

[davey_magik]

Brock McLean. But in seriousness Cooney will sh1t all over Walker in a few years.

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Walker isn't proven from that at all, Cooney needs to get it together consistantly.
Cooney atm.

 

[Thrawn]

If you look at what they've done so far, and what they have the potential to do, it has to be Cooney quite easily

Cooney has had the better start to his career, but that doesn't mean he has more potential.

You can't be sure that player A has more potential than player B, it is all prediction. Cooney is ahead at this stage - but saying "Cooney quite easily" based on potential is a load of rubbish.

Unless you are a time traveller. Are you?

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Still Cooney, but I was damn impressed by Walker on the weekend.

 

[rick James]

McLean over both of them, then Cooney, then Walker. Sylvia after that.

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

McLean over both of them, then Cooney, then Walker. Sylvia after that.

Farren Ray is doing significantly better than Sylvia is right now. Sylvia is tough and all, and that is great, but he doesn't get the ball. Sylvia has got 15 or more disposals 3 times this season, Rays done it for the last 9 weeks. And Ray is running with it, taking people on and has good disposal

 

[gandaal]

McLean over both of them, then Cooney, then Walker. Sylvia after that.

Did McLean play on the weekend?

I didn't see much of him.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

So who would you rather?

The one who can kick.

 

[CrazyQ]

Did McLean play on the weekend?

I didn't see much of him.

Where has Walker been this year when compared to McLean.

Dont try and belittle McLean to make Walker look good.

McLean is miles away better than him this season.

 

[Silvagnis]

The one who can kick.

This isn't about Thomas and Pendlebury.

 

[CrazyQ]

This isn't about Thomas and Pendlebury.

I;d rather Pendulbury than Walker.

But I'll give you Thomas for free

 

[Silvagnis]

I;d rather Pendulbury than Walker.

But I'll give you Thomas for free

Did you see Pendlebury pull out of a contest against the Hawks?

Walker is better than Pendlebury and Thomas, but you can have Trotter for a top ten pick.

 

[gandaal]

Where has Walker been this year when compared to McLean.

Dont try and belittle McLean to make Walker look good.

McLean is miles away better than him this season.

How would you know, you haven't seen Carlton play once this year.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

This isn't about Thomas and Pendlebury.

So you're admitting Thomas and Pendles can both kick?

Its a shame all Walker can do is kick floaters

 

[CrazyQ]

Did you see Pendlebury pull out of a contest against the Hawks?

Walker is better than Pendlebury and Thomas, but you can have Trotter for a top ten pick.

I'd rather Trotter than Russell

Pendulbury will be a much better footballer than Walker, he didnt pull out, he let Clement get the ball, I would too.

 

[CrazyQ]

How would you know, you haven't seen Carlton play once this year.

Are you saying Walker has played better than McLean?

 

[gandaal]

Did you see Pendlebury pull out of a contest against the Hawks?

Walker is better than Pendlebury and Thomas, but you can have Trotter for a top ten pick.

Why take Trotter when you can pick up Dylan Smith instead?

 

[CrazyQ]

Why take Trotter when you can pick up Dylan Smith instead?

Or Livingston.

Wait, the funny thing is he is still at your club

 

[gandaal]

Are you saying Walker has played better than McLean?

Since one player was man of the match and the other barely rated a mention all game... I would say yes Walker had a better game than McLean.

I can say that because I actually watched the game and judged for myself, unlike yourself who seems to base what you say on the opinions of others.

 

[gandaal]

Or Livingston.

Wait, the funny thing is he is still at your club

The difference is that Livo has actually had one or two good games during his career, and at one point was actually chased by Melbourne, while Dylan got delisted ASAP. Dylan Smith was such a complete hack he couldn't even last a year on Freo's rookie list after your club desperately got rid of him.

 

[CrazyQ]

The difference is that Livo has actually had one or two good games during his career, and at one point was actually chased by Melbourne, while Dylan got delisted ASAP. Dylan Smith was such a complete hack he couldn't even last a year on Freo's rookie list after your club desperately got rid of him.

A hack we delisted.

You have a hack still on your list.

See the difference?