Another 2-3 week suspension for Maxwell?

[TerryWallet]

The skipper once again showed his incredible discipline and courage today.

Fist to the head of Mitch Robinson from behind....50 metre penalty paid...and probably another suspension coming up once the review panel meets.

What a leader

 

[Brent24]

Shouldn't have even been a 50.

 

[omit]

should have been sent off the ground, there is no place for that in our game. it was Barry Hallesque

 

[Pedro]

should have been sent off the ground, there is no place for that in our game. it was Barry Hallesque

Jeez. Cam Mooney to do a stint in Pentridge then?

 

[BLue_Bloys]

He treads a fine line....tbh I don't mind it.

Looked like he was going for the ball, hope he doesn't get suspended for it. Was on the other side of the ground to where I was though, so may be more in it.

 

[Bell Ringer]

Would be surprised if he gets rubbed out for it - not much in it, but def 50 metres. Yeah he might have intended to hit the ball and was probs looking at it but he wacked the guy in the head instead.

It is however, a perfect example of this rubbish footballers career - acts like a wannabe tough-guy, but just ends up looking like a fool. His misguided attempts to impose himself on the game are laughable. Needs to stick to zoning off his direct opponent and being the third guy up to help Presti out if he wants to earn his pay-check, cos that's about all he's good for.

 

[Consumed]

I've been paying attention to Maxwell this year, especially after all the BF abuse towards him.
Firstly, he is nowhere as bad as the posters on here make out. His footskills let him down sometimes, but I cannot fault much else wrong with him.
Secondly, the hit on Robinson today was slightly late, but there was no malice in it. 50m penalty paid and that should be it. Big credit to young Mitch though, bounced up and continued to play well. Took a ripper of mark with the flight of the ball not too long after. Gee, Carlton fans would like him. Could be a great player done the track.

Back to Maxwell, good leader, but a little clumsy. Not too bad a footballer though.

 

[CarltonSocialClub]

It's not worth missing games over at all, but I never understand the decisions of the MRP.

Maxwell is a very poor captain none the less. What a disgrace to the No.5. If he wants to be the "I'm not a good player but I'm a leader of men" captain, he should look to Brett Kirk.

 

[Smoky]

The skipper once again showed his incredible discipline and courage today.

Fist to the head of Mitch Robinson from behind....50 metre penalty paid...and probably another suspension coming up once the review panel meets.

What a leader

Way to over react.

 

[Black Flag]

What irks me is that Pies fans think of him as tough lol. In terms of toughness:

Mitch Robinson >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Maxwell.

 

[Mop]

It's not worth missing games over at all, but I never understand the decisions of the MRP.

Maxwell is a very poor captain none the less. What a disgrace to the No.5. If he wants to be the "I'm not a good player but I'm a leader of men" captain, he should look to Brett Kirk.

Kirk isn't a bad player at all if that's what you're alluding to.

 

[Invigoration]

Yeah 3 years in jail, do not pass go and do not collect $200.

Does anyone seriously think that was suspendable (I realise it is a troll thread). Honestly, people whinge about the game being to soft then it is the exact same people who came crawling out of their caves to label that sort of thing as a 2-3 week suspension?

A 50 metre penalty at most and a nice delicious glass of harden the **** up.

 

[Black Flag]

Yeah 3 years in jail, do not pass go and do not collect $200.

Does anyone seriously think that was suspendable (I realise it is a troll thread). Honestly, people whinge about the game being to soft then it is the exact same people who came crawling out of their caves to label that sort of thing as a 2-3 week suspension?

A 50 metre penalty at most and a nice delicious glass of harden the **** up.

The more Maxwell is involved in these types of incidents the closer he will be looked at.

He only has himself to blame really.

 

[marcus1232]

more in the hit on dal santo by davey in tonights twilight game

 

[Invigoration]

The more Maxwell is involved in these types of incidents the closer he will be looked at.

He only has himself to blame really.

The person in the incident is completely irrelevant if the incident isn't reportable in the first place.

 

[TerryWallet]

Yeah 3 years in jail, do not pass go and do not collect $200.

Does anyone seriously think that was suspendable (I realise it is a troll thread). Honestly, people whinge about the game being to soft then it is the exact same people who came crawling out of their caves to label that sort of thing as a 2-3 week suspension?

A 50 metre penalty at most and a nice delicious glass of harden the **** up.

If you realise it is a troll thread then why did you reply in this manner?

The OP was made to highlight "tough guy" Nick's pathetic discipline as Skipper and his "courage".

He seems to delight in sniping young players in the head.

 

[Kahuna]

Robbo is a tough nut, he wouldn't of felt a thing for the dog Maxwells fist.

 

[andypie]

The skipper once again showed his incredible discipline and courage today.

Fist to the head of Mitch Robinson from behind....50 metre penalty paid...and probably another suspension coming up once the review panel meets.

What a leader

e kick and 50, thats about it.
I reckon your the type of tool that will ring SEN tommorow and cry about how the rules committee have ruined the game, its now soft and players cant do anything.
The guy got a clip, got up and the game went on. let it go.
I cant handle tossers like you who say how many weeks for every little incident.
Winners should be grinners. get a life.
Fe

 

[jimmy35]

The skipper once again showed his incredible discipline and courage today.

Fist to the head of Mitch Robinson from behind....50 metre penalty paid...and probably another suspension coming up once the review panel meets.

What a leader

Hope it didn't ruin his good looks .

 

[Invigoration]

If you realise it is a troll thread then why did you reply in this manner?

The OP was made to highlight "tough guy" Nick's pathetic discipline as Skipper and his "courage".

He seems to delight in sniping young players in the head.

Who are you quoting on tough guy and courage?

It was a questionable 50 metre penalty, nothing worth chucking a tantrum over.

 

[TerryWallet]

Who are you quoting on tough guy and courage?

It was a questionable 50 metre penalty, nothing worth chucking a tantrum over.

What it was:

A) another example of Skipper Maxwells lack of discipline and leadership.

B) another example of ToughGuy Maxwells lack of courage in that he seems to have a distinct liking for belting young players head high from behind or when they are not looking.

way to go Nick

PS: it is always hilarious to see the contempt on his own teammates faces when he is berating them.

 

[Consumed]

What it was:

A) another example of Skipper Maxwells lack of discipline and leadership.

B) another example of ToughGuy Maxwells lack of courage in that he seems to have a distinct liking for belting young players head high from behind or when they are not looking.

way to go Nick

PS: it is always hilarious to see the contempt on his own teammates faces when he is berating them.

He was late.
He was clumsy.

Nothing to do with leadership. He was doing something at least.

 

[TerryWallet]

He was clumsy.

He seems to be rather consistently clumsy around the head area of opposing players who aren't looking at him(preferably young players).

 

[Godzke]

he's courageous and is improving as a player ... but collingwood could've done better for a captain. had they waited one more year then pendlebury would've been the obvious choice.

edit*: not that i'm suggesting hitting someone in the back of the head is courageous, gutless more like it, but rather in general play.

 

[Godzke]

well he got off ... so pie fans can relax