- Thread starter
- #26
One punched the other was a light slap? Plus it’s Rachele.
News Rioli slap cops a 2 week ban.
- Thread starter PowerBaz
- Start date
- Tagged users None
One punched the other was a light slap? Plus it’s Rachele.
Power Raid
We Exist To Win Premierships
it was soft but an action we shouldn't have in our game
one week for the action and one week for the stupidity of the action
one week for the action and one week for the stupidity of the action
It wasn't a "light" slap. He flushed Murphy right in the jaw, which is dangerous against a player who has a concussion history.
It's clearly 'medium' impact.
Intentional, Medium Impact and High/Groin is 2 weeks.
- Thread starter
- #30
If it was Daicos or Dusty slapping it’s not two weeks - the VFL wouldn’t have it, we all know that.
How is the 2 weeks then?
- Jul 15, 2022
- 2,382
- 2,351
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #31
Murphy has history of instigating then flops. Zero respect.
For mine, Pickett should have got more that 2 weeks, as it was deemed "Careless" by the MRO, which was a soft call IMHO. Should be "Intentional" (feet off ground and flung himself at Smith) which is 3 weeks (with High Impact and High Contact).
Had Smith have been knocked out, it would have been 4+ weeks and probably 6.
Pointing out one dodgy classification by the MRO doesn't mean that you should get a precedent-discount for a physical strike to the head.
Dunno how he "flopped" a concussion that saw him miss ANZAC Day...
- Jul 15, 2022
- 2,382
- 2,351
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #34
You throw them stand up when you get one back.
- Thread starter
- #35
Dusty elbow to the guts a week or so back, nothing to see here. It was a harder hit than a slap.
Rustin Cohle
Flat Circle
Being hit in the jaw from a swinging arm with this part of the palm is not a ******* slap.
And if you think it wouldn't stun you when you're not expecting it then I suggest you get someone to do it to you and see how you go.
- Jul 15, 2022
- 2,382
- 2,351
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Banned
- #37
Why wasn't he expecting it? He had two hands up around Riolis jaw. The same against StKilda where he was throwing hands.
theouthouse
Team Captain
- Oct 4, 2021
- 412
- 590
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
Murphys also given Rioli a decent whack to the lower neck area in the exact same incident, yet doesn't get cited.
It was at worst technically a free kick for jumper holding and was most definitely not reportable in any way.
Rioli's action was an intentional strike to the head and worth every bit of 2 weeks.
You Port supporters need to stop whinging, but then I sense that is your natural collective disposition on a host of issues. You're the English cricket supporters of the AFL!
For me it is a week for Martin based on the MRO calculations. Again, pointing out bad classifications by the MRO doesn't mean that an intentional and forceful slap to someone's jaw that decked them isn't worth 2 weeks. It's worth 2 weeks all day every day!
- Thread starter
- #41
Chadwiko
@ChadwikoTWW
- Sep 25, 2004
- 20,805
- 33,496
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Washington Commanders, Boston Celtics
Two weeks is deserved.
Arguing against this is parochialism at it's worst.
Please.
Arguing against this is parochialism at it's worst.
Please.
Port are taking it to the tribunal, so i guess we'll see. It's hardly just Port supporters/club that thinks this decision is wrong.
- Nov 22, 2014
- 987
- 1,482
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
It's everyone else's fault, despite the fact it's the same bloke getting whacked. I feel like there is a common factor in these incidents and his initials are N.M.
What exactly did Murphy do to deserve getting whacked? If you say it’s because he was holding or scragging, then there’s dozens of players, including Geelong players, (I know it’s hard to believe), who deserve to be whacked every week.
Bit of a common theme with Rioli. Outed for a hit on Jordan Ridley earlier this season, and has copped suspensions at WCE for similar offences. Clearly has anger control issues. Certainly not the worst incident you would see, but totally unnecessary, and penalty about right.
Last edited:
Don’t think Murphy could give 2 f…s whether he has the respect or not of an anonymous troll on BF.
FireKrakouer
Gentlemen, this is democracy manifest.
- Jul 5, 2011
- 15,320
- 23,140
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
I would've thought 1 week since it was deliberate, high, and off the ball but didn't look like there was much force in it. Having said that, anyone who's watched boxing or MMA knows that it can be hard to tell on camera how much force was really behind a strike.
Since it's happened twice to Murphy now I'd agree that he must be stirring up forwards with niggles but it's really no excuse. Up to the field umps and MRO to determine if Murphy's breaking the rules, the shrieking of "but he started it!" from grown adults is just sad.
Since it's happened twice to Murphy now I'd agree that he must be stirring up forwards with niggles but it's really no excuse. Up to the field umps and MRO to determine if Murphy's breaking the rules, the shrieking of "but he started it!" from grown adults is just sad.
I think it might be about time Nathan wakes up to himself and realises he’s an AFL footballer, not an EPL soccer player. If a free kick was rewarded to Rioli before this incident nothing would have happened. One week for the action, one week because it happened to a Collingwood player is the only reason I can see as to why it got two weeks.
Fitzey, there’s a small village on a tiny island in the Outer Hebrides, that’s recently lost it’s Village Idiot. You’re eminently qualified, probably over qualified in fact, to slot into that role.
- Nov 18, 2017
- 1,753
- 4,546
- AFL Club
- West Coast
or 3 if you're Jordan De Goey
Similar threads
- Poll
