Best Players Votes

[97-98]

Which list best reflects the players' performance this year so far:

Coaches Award after round 7
48 Chris Judd
40 Chad Cornes
35 Daniel Kerr
34 Andrew McLeod
29 Jimmy Bartel
28 Brad Sewell
27 Gary Ablett
24 Scott Lucas
23 Barry Hall
23 Matthew Pavlich

LF50's BigFooty Medal after round 6
19 Chad Cornes
19 Chris Judd
16 Daniel Kerr
15 Andre McLeod
13 Scott Thompson
13 Simon Black
13 Robert Harvey
12 Luke Power
12 Gary Abblett
11 Heath Shaw

Here It is
Top 10 AFL players after round 6

1. Daniel Kerr (West Coast) 40
2. Gary Ablett (Geelong) 37
2. Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 37
2. Chris Judd (West Coast) 37
2. Heath Shaw (Collingwood) 37
6. Simon Black (Brisbane Lions) 36
7. Jimmy Bartel (Geelong) 35
7. Tarkyn Lockyer (Collingwood) 35
9. Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide) 34
9. Lance Franklin (Hawthorn) 34

Age Footballer of the Year after round 7
D Kerr (WC) 40
C Judd (WC) 38
C Cornes (Port) 38
H McIntosh (Kang) 37
R Harvey (St K) 34
D Wirrpanda (WC) 29
S Thompson (Port) 28
B Stanton (Ess) 28
A Simpson (Kang) 27

Herald Sun Player of the Year after round 7
19 Judd
19 C Cornes
18 Kerr
15 S Black
13 K Cornes
13 Lockyer
13 McLeod
12 Goodwin
12 R Harvey
11 Lucas
11 Fevola
11 L Power
11 S Thompson

 

[MF]

Coaches award has it just about spot on.

 

[Alphanumeric]

Coaches Award after round 7
48 Chris Judd
40 Chad Cornes
35 Daniel Kerr
34 Andrew McLeod
29 Jimmy Bartel
28 Brad Sewell
27 Gary Ablett
24 Scott Lucas
23 Barry Hall
23 Matthew Pavlich

Barry Hall?? Has he been that good so far this year??

 

[Rockford]

Coaches award has it just about spot on.

Agree. Any list that doesn't have Bartel in it after the start he has had is a joke.

 

[Bloods boy from the Bush]

Barry Hall?? Has he been that good so far this year??

He has been pretty good in some games just not as much as people expect from the big guy. He still needs to lift a bit however.
The best list is the coaches but there all pretty similar.

 

[Alphanumeric]

He has been pretty good in some games just not as much as people expect from the big guy. He still needs to lift a bit however.
The best list is the coaches but there all pretty similar.

I know he has kicked a few bags of 4 goals, but I didn't think he has been having that big an influence in games.

 

[Bloods boy from the Bush]

I know he has kicked a few bags of 4 goals, but I didn't think he has been having that big an influence in games.

He hasn't really but next to O'Keefe and Kennelly hes been the swans best player this year. Which state where their at.

 

[MF]

So many of the other awards name mediocre players in the votes just for playing better than they usually do while if a Brown or a Judd are even slightly down on their usual excellent form they are disregarded.

The thing I like about the coaches award is that they are not influenced by a players previous standards. The coaches just name the players who had the most impact on the game.

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

i reckon heath shaw deserves to be there. has been awsome and really important to collingwood.only mentioned in one list

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Age and Herald Sun lists are birdcage liner.

 

[djlowz]

So many of the other awards name mediocre players in the votes just for playing better than they usually do while if a Brown or a Judd are even slightly down on their usual excellent form they are disregarded.

The thing I like about the coaches award is that they are not influenced by a players previous standards. The coaches just name the players who had the most impact on the game.

Yep.

 

[RhEF JC]

So many of the other awards name mediocre players in the votes just for playing better than they usually do while if a Brown or a Judd are even slightly down on their usual excellent form they are disregarded.

The thing I like about the coaches award is that they are not influenced by a players previous standards. The coaches just name the players who had the most impact on the game.

Agree. People point to the AFLPA award as a more legitimate alternative to the brownlow, but purely in terms of the method used to determine the winner, you'd have to say the coaches' award should be the most prestigious.

 

[thefamilyguy]

Heath shaw should be in there too.. played well.

so has lockyer. wasn't expecting that hahahahah

 

[goal sneak]

The bigfooty medal is a real good indicator i think.

BigFooty Medal after round 6
19 Chad Cornes
19 Chris Judd
16 Daniel Kerr
15 Andre McLeod
13 Scott Thompson
13 Simon Black
13 Robert Harvey
12 Luke Power
12 Gary Abblett
11 Heath Shaw
11 Shane Crawford
10 Scott Lucas
10 Matthew Pavlich
10 Hamish McIntosh
9 Scott Burns
9 Tarkyn Lockyer
9 Rhyce Shaw
9 Jimmy Bartel
9 Nick Malceski
9 Scott West

 

[blues4flag]

Barry Hall?? Has he been that good so far this year??

Surprised he's so high up.

 

[Big John]

Agree. People point to the AFLPA award as a more legitimate alternative to the brownlow, but purely in terms of the method used to determine the winner, you'd have to say the coaches' award should be the most prestigious.

After the bigfooty medal of course.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Barry Hall?? Has he been that good so far this year??

Roos must give him 5 every week, that is the only explanation.

He has been nowhere near his best.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

coaches award without hall and pavlich

 

[oscarheel]

Coaches Award after round 7
48 Chris Judd
40 Chad Cornes
35 Daniel Kerr
34 Andrew McLeod
29 Jimmy Bartel
28 Brad Sewell
27 Gary Ablett
24 Scott Lucas
23 Barry Hall
23 Matthew Pavlich

 

[RhEF JC]

After the bigfooty medal of course.

heheh...fair point

 

[crosby123]

Top 5 of Coaches' Award = Top 5 players this year.

 

[trueblue_91]

Age and Herald Sun lists are birdcage liner.

No Bartel in the Herald Sun list

 

[Demonheart]

The coaches award is an absolute farce, there is at least one of them who has openly stated that he doesn't bother doing the votes himself, he gets someone else to do it.

 

[Big Nasty]

No Bartel in the Herald Sun list

I know, how can that be a respectable award without him?