If you think that was true, then it is clearly you who have no idea. Read our trading board. It wasn't daydreaming, it was a freakin nightmare. Very few thought chasing Carlisle after saints started shopping around the idea he was tradable was a good idea. Convicted drug cheat. Stupid enough to get caught doing lines (yes, all clubs have recreational drug users, but most of them are smart enough to keep it out of public view). Good player when fit, but question marks about his body now.
Yes you trading board is comedy gold. Why would anyone want to take that thread as factual. Just look at how quick Amon went from being a Hawk till not on it. The thread is a wishful thinking thread. No more, no less. As a source of facts..haha
I mean look at how Nash played everyone. on Cogs. There was a very similar poster on the StKilda Board last trade season. Same MO of tell people what they want to hear and they lap it up. Quite possibly the same guy with a different nic. Even funnier now how the mod other there now is telling the ITK's to not actually most things as posting in the thread will cost them trades. Seems to actually think it cost them Cogs. Twilight Zone!
The Carlisle "medical" was someone's mate he knew at St Kilda
Last edited: