List Mgmt. Carlton's 2019 Draft Thread

[swuzzlebubble]

While there is a degree of equity in your suggested trades, surely there is no way GWS does a fanciful trade unless they have the opportunity to
land Green plus another player.

This is where 6 for our future first comes into it although they don't get their other player until next year.
However there are complications for the back end of this draft albeit workable.
6 for 9 could be good for us if GWS don't have a better option.
Only 300 points diff so can probably square it off this year.
This would then keep open the option with Hawks of 11 & 30 for our future first if they had to match an earlier bid.

 

[Bluechip66]

What happens if GC throw a curve ball, and announce green , where would that leave GWS?

 

[swuzzlebubble]

About 750 points short

 

[Sunstar]

What happens if GC throw a curve ball, and announce green , where would that leave GWS?

GC can also prelist players till tomorrow and then swap them for draft picks (mid to late) they still have a couple of NT players and a young forward that are getting attention, a better pick swap may mean the Suns may be more open to release Martin

 

[swuzzlebubble]

Better than what?

 

[Pafloyul]

There's no 'better' pick swap, there is only the good faith of a swap of picks that benefits both clubs.

 

[Blutopia]

GC can also prelist players till tomorrow and then swap them for draft picks (mid to late) they still have a couple of NT players and a young forward that are getting attention, a better pick swap may mean the Suns may be more open to release Martin

Martin is out of contract and has requested a trade two years in a row.

If GC take him in pre-season draft they will be in court over restraint of trade and it will open up a can of worms for AFL.

Our biggest worry is Melbourne but they don’t have cap space.

 

[Bluechip66]

GC can also prelist players till tomorrow and then swap them for draft picks (mid to late) they still have a couple of NT players and a young forward that are getting attention, a better pick swap may mean the Suns may be more open to release Martin

That didn’t answer my question!

 

[swuzzlebubble]

If I was GC I'd throw the sink at pick 3 to set up for a Green bid at 1.

 

[Sluggers Blues]

I hear Melbourne will take benell with with there pick 2 in the pre season draft leavi g us martin

 

[Jeremias]

I hear Melbourne will take benell with with there pick 2 in the pre season draft leavi g us martin

Interesting, but I would have thought the Demons would wait until the last possible moment to make a final decision on Bennell.

 

[ABigOlDoofus]

Interesting, but I would have thought the Demons would wait until the last possible moment to make a final decision on Bennell.

I would have thought the same, the only way I see them taking him in the PSD is if they know another team will take him with a pick after theirs, which I would see as unlikely.

 

[The Dominator7]

Now I’m far from a rules expert but pretty sure Harley doesn’t need to go into PSD - Isn’t he available to anyone at any stage as a DFA - Freo delisted him after all

 

[smashbox gill]

I really want Dylan Williams - not at 9 but think it could be worthwhile to do a pick swap for him. Suits what we need

 

[ParapMarkets]

This is where 6 for our future first comes into it although they don't get their other player until next year.
However there are complications for the back end of this draft albeit workable.
6 for 9 could be good for us if GWS don't have a better option.
Only 300 points diff so can probably square it off this year.
This would then keep open the option with Hawks of 11 & 30 for our future first if they had to match an earlier bid.

I can’t imagine any scenario where GWS trade out pick 6 for a future pick. They are either going to trade up to get a selection before Green is nominated or they will trade down in this draft for more points to match a Green bid.

 

[ferrisb]

I can’t imagine any scenario where GWS trade out pick 6 for a future pick. They are either going to trade up to get a selection before Green is nominated or they will trade down in this draft for more points to match a Green bid.

If they want more points, they should swap pick 6 for picks 12 & 18....

 

[ParapMarkets]

If they want more points, they should swap pick 6 for picks 12 & 18....

If they don’t manage to trade for a pick before a Green bid it will be interesting to see what they do. After giving up so much to get pick 6 in the first place it must be seen as a massive failure by them if they ultimately end up retreating and trading back down.

 

[AT97]

State of play: How the first round of the draft is shaping up

Bid for GWS Academy product Tom Green is looming as the key factor in the first round of this year's draft

www.afl.com.au

 

[ferrisb]

State of play: How the first round of the draft is shaping up

Bid for GWS Academy product Tom Green is looming as the key factor in the first round of this year's draft

www.afl.com.au

The bits that most concern us

1) Looking like Serong and Kemp may both be available at 9

2) "Geelong is also closely monitoring how it could jump up the board, with the Cats seeing what it would take to secure Carlton's pick No.9."

 

[ferrisb]

2a) I think Geelong will come hard for our pick 9 if Luke Jackson (unlikely) or McAsey (likely) are still available.

 

[swuzzlebubble]

The bits that most concern us

1) Looking like Serong and Kemp may both be available at 9

2) "Geelong is also closely monitoring how it could jump up the board, with the Cats seeing what it would take to secure Carlton's pick No.9."

3. Considering bid for Henry

 

[ABigOlDoofus]

2a) I think Geelong will come hard for our pick 9 if Luke Jackson (unlikely) or McAsey (likely) are still available.

Thoughts on what they'd give up? Their two firsts with peanuts and 9 coming back?

 

[FitzroyBlueBagger]

2a) I think Geelong will come hard for our pick 9 if Luke Jackson (unlikely) or McAsey (likely) are still available.

14 & 24 swap deal for 9 & 59 then try working on another pick inside 30 with next years second as a bargaining chip along with our 43 giving us 14,24,-30 to have a crack with...

 

[GT619]

Cody Weightman is a top-15 draft prospect who will do everything he can to improve
http://m.afl.com.au/news/2019-11-11/class-of-2019-cody-weightman

 

[windows1]

The bits that most concern us

1) Looking like Serong and Kemp may both be available at 9

2) "Geelong is also closely monitoring how it could jump up the board, with the Cats seeing what it would take to secure Carlton's pick No.9."

If it’s a choice between Serong and Kemp then it’s Kemp for sure. We will just have to wait to see him.

For me if Serong is the only one left I’d rather trade down. 14 and 24 with Cats would be awesome.